Herbal medicine

Caldar Bendle gives an overview of herbal medicine, its history and its role in medicine today.

By: Calder Bendle (Guest)

  • Duration 10 mins
  • Updated Monday 2nd February 2009
  • Introductory level
  • Posted under Health Studies
Share on Google Plus Share on LinkedIn Share on Reddit View article Comments
Calder Bendle Copyrighted image Copyright: Production team

The History

Perhaps all human cultures throughout the world and throughout history have used some form of herbal medicine. Certainly plants which are still used as medicines have been found in ancient burial sites around the world – the oldest may be the grave of a Neanderthal man from (what is now) Northern Iraq estimated to be 60,000 years old. Currently, worldwide, most medicines are still derived from plant sources.

Within different cultures herbal medicines have been used in different ways. In Britain, until relatively recent times, there were folk healers with a reputation for curing particular complaints. These people often learned their skill from their parents and would typically only use a small number of plants and would only claim to be able to help one or two types of affliction. The old herbals in this country were to some extent originally compilations of such information.

Traditional healers around the world have learned to find plants within their immediate environment that help to heal a range of illnesses and injuries. Virtually all tribal peoples around the world employ some form of herbal medicine. Many cultures have developed complex theoretical frameworks for understanding both disease and the application of herbs as medicine. Herbal medicines are an important part of Traditional Chinese medicine, of Ayurvedic practice in India, and of Tibb Unani medicine across the Islamic world. Herbs were the main tools for improving health in the ancient Greek theories of health and illness and these formed the basis of medical knowledge in Europe up until the modern era.

Over thousands of years of trial and error use, detailed pictures of the actions and applications of plant medicines have been compiled and refined. The theoretical constructs around their use change, but the plants remain. Over the last 150 years traditional descriptions of the ways in which plants work as medicines have been supplemented with biochemical analysis and research into plant pharmacology. Initially this research saw the development of pharmaceutical drugs derived from plant sources.

Plants were analysed to determine which, of the dozens of complex organic compounds of which they are composed, were the "active constituents". The thinking was along the lines of "why give a patient a herb tea with an indeterminate amount of active ingredients, when it is possible to administer a small white pill with precisely measured amounts?" And so drugs such as digoxin, derived originally from foxgloves, and aspirin, based on chemicals found in meadowsweet and willow bark, were isolated and then synthesised artificially.

More recently we have discovered that the effect of isolating a medicinal compound from its parent plant may increase the number of side effects associated with that drug. The substances in plants that chemists wanted to eliminate from medicines can turn out to have a modulating effect on a herb's actions and are possibly beneficial. For example if meadowsweet is used as an anti-inflammatory, it does not have the stomach-irritating side effects that are associated with aspirin. It seems that nature has provided us with well formulated drugs in the form of the weeds that grow on our doorsteps!

Herbal Medicine Today

There are two main ways in which herbal medicine is accessed in this country at the present time:

  • Over the Counter Medication (OTC) from health food stores and chemists
  • Via a consultation with a professional medical herbalist.

Whilst OTC remedies are marketed very much in the line of a particular herb being the remedy for a particular complaint, medical herbalists will work rather differently. A herbalist will think of herbs as having a number of actions (such as promoting wound healing or as being anti-inflammatory) or qualities (such as being drying or cooling), and will try to match these as carefully as possible to what they have learned about the patient and their needs. To do this they will usually make up a mixture of herbs which will be dispensed as either a tea or as a tincture.

The aim of this prescription will be to support the body's own tendency to heal itself, and will be uniquely formulated for each particular patient. Two people suffering from, say, rheumatoid arthritis, are likely to be offered the same anti-inflammatory herb from a health food shop. If the same two people visit a medical herbalist, they will probably each be given different prescriptions according to how long they have had the illness, how it affects them and which factors alleviate or aggravate their condition. The herbalist will also take into account the patient's general state of health and medical history.

A wide range of herbs is used in this country, from all over the world. These range from common British "weeds" such as dandelion – a powerful diuretic and liver tonic; to exotics such as the bark of the South American Lapacho tree – an immune-system stimulating plant used for its antibiotic and anti-fungal actions. While most of the plants used as remedies are very gentle in action some need to be treated with great respect.

Many herbs have lots of actions, some of which will be deleterious for particular users. For example sage is a useful first aid remedy for mouth infections and sore throats, but it also reduces the supply of breast milk in feeding mothers. Other herbs may interact with orthodox medication and a few are poisonous in the wrong dosage. For these reasons it is wise to consult a trained medical herbalist, or at least to refer to a good reference book.

Although the government is seeking to register herbalists in the UK, there is currently no legal restriction on the title "herbalist". Whilst there are very few people practising as herbalists without training it is wise to check someone's credentials if you are seeking a consultation.

Ask about a herbalist's training, their medical knowledge and their willingness to communicate with orthodox medical practitioners if necessary. Word of mouth referrals are probably useful in finding out about a particular herbalist and their approach. There are a confusing number of professional bodies covering herbalists from both western and other approaches. Those organisations whose members are likely to be state registered in the near future will be members of the European Herbal Practitioners Association.

In recent years the huge demand for herbal remedies in the OTC market has damaged populations of some plants that are harvested from the wild. Most herbalists in this country see their role as looking after the plants that they use as well as the health of their patients. To this end they seek to obtain their supplies from ecologically minded suppliers.

How Effective is Herbal Medicine?

The modern use of plants as medicines is based upon thousands of years of empirical research. Professional herbalists add to this information with well observed case histories noting the effects of particular plants. Lots of new information is also available from the worlds of chemistry and pharmacology.

Whilst very little research has been carried out by herbalists themselves, they have been very good at assimilating new information and adding this to their traditional knowledge base. Huge advances in organic chemistry over the last century mean that many of the constituent chemicals of medicinal herbs have been identified and their actions investigated.

For hundreds of years it has been known that the bitter tasting aromatic herb chamomile has many useful applications. These include its use as an antispasmodic and anti-inflammatory for the digestive system. We are now able to say that the bitter taste is due in part to the presence of anthemic acid, and that the volatile oil that gives chamomile its distinctive aroma includes the components spiroether and azulenes. We are further able to demonstrate that spiroether is a strong antispasmodic, that azulenes can have anti-inflammatory action, and similarly to explain the other healing effects of this herb in terms of the chemicals of which it is composed.

Very recent research is also demonstrating that although herbs often contain only small amounts of these pharmacologically active chemicals, that they work synergistically together. That is, that a trace of one chemical will increase by many times the effectiveness of another.

The chemical analysis of herbs is also useful in identifying possible herb/drug interactions – herbalists are constantly updating their information in this area.

Clinical trials are very expensive to fund, and there have been few clinical trials yet of the way in which medical herbalists actually work – that is with long consultations and the use of prescriptions containing a number of herbs. There have, however been lots of trials of the effectiveness of individual herbs. A recent book by the herbalist Kerry Bone lists eight positive clinical trials on chamomile testing its anti-diarrhoeal, anti-inflammatory, antispasmodic and sedative effects. Some herbs have had many times more clinical studies made into their effects.

Over the last 20 years orthodox physicians have generally become more accepting of the value of both medical herbalists and of the plant remedies that they use. A small number of medical herbalists are employed within the NHS, either in specialist outpatient departments or in doctors' surgeries. Other doctors refer patients on to herbalists and several universities now offer postgraduate training in herbal medicine for doctors.

Once thought ready to be consigned to history, herbal medicine and herbal remedies are more studied and researched in universities than at any time in the past.

This website is provided for general information only. You should not treat it as a substitute for the medical advice of your own doctor or any other health care professional.

The BBC and the Open University are not responsible or liable for any diagnosis made by a user based on the content of the OpenLearn website.

The BBC and the Open University are not liable for the contents of any external internet sites listed, nor do they endorse any commercial product or service mentioned or advised on any of the sites. Always consult your own GP if you are in any way concerned about your health.