Skip to content

The Big Question: How safe is the food we eat?

Updated Friday 17th December 2004

Hygiene questions, adulteration, sell-by dates - should we just close our eyes, swallow hard and hope?

Raw chicken Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC

With the increasing globalisation of the food trade, market stalls, grocers and supermarkets now offer us a bewildering choice of affordable products. But the food we eat has often travelled thousands of kilometres and passed through scores of hands to get to our plates. So can we be sure where it's been and what's happened to it in the meantime? This week's Big Question with Emma Joseph is: Can we trust what we eat?

Felipe Fernandez Armesto Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission "One needs to be quite sceptical and extremely careful about the health of our food, not because we need regulation, but because where it's produced far from the consumer, there is no community control on the producers to produce good food", says Felipe Fernandez Armesto, Professor of Global Environmental History at Queen Mary College, in London. As food has become increasingly mass-produced, says Professor Armesto, its cost may have been reduced, but so has its quality.

So how safe is the food we eat?

"The incidence of food-borne diseases has clearly been going up", says Jorgen Schlundt, director of the Food Safety Department at the World Health Organisation.

"In all parts of the world a lot of people everyday get sick and even die from unsafe food. In the developed countries it's estimated that one third of the population every year gets a diarrhoea case from micro-organisms in food. In developing countries this number is probably a lot higher."

Food contaminated by harmful micro-organisms can cause diseases like diarrhoea as well as other illnesses affecting the joints, the liver and other organs. It kills some 2 million people every year.

The most common bacteria found in food (usually poultry and eggs) is Salmonella, which causes salmonellosis. It is killed by the heat when the food is cooked.

Why are there more cases of food poisoning?

There are many explanations, says Jorgen Schlundt.

"We've had changes in the production system, there are very big herds now, which means that the bacteria can spread more quickly. There are issues about how we treat our food ourselves in the kitchen, issues about the long food chain and things that happen in slaughterhouses, issues about the change in our population… and all of these things could have some influence in how we get the bacteria into our bodies."

So how can we protect ourselves?

"What you can really do at home is rinse your food to take out some of the chemicals that might be there, and make sure that you heat treat everything. Don't mix what you have cooked with anything that's raw", advises Mr Schlundt.

How can we know where our food has been?

Michiel Korthals Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission "A piece of meat or chicken that we buy already packed in the supermarket is likely to have passed at least ten stages before reaching the shelves", says Michiel Korthals, Professor of Food Ethics at Wageningen University, in Holland. And, he says, something can go wrong at every one of those stages.

The movement of food from the fields to the plate is often referred to as the "food chain" - and today, the food chain is longer than ever. But Professor Korthals is sceptical about the term itself. "It is rather optimistic, because it sounds as if the whole food business is organised very well, like a chain with links. But that's not the case. It looks more like several plates of pasta with very unclear ways of supplying and transporting food. It's one big mess," he says.

So, how do we know what is in our food?

To protect the health of consumers, 170 countries have made a commitment to stick to food standards set down under international treaties -- known as the Codex Alimentarius. The Codex covers issues like the nutritional quality of food, additives, contaminants and labelling.

"By law, in Europe, the label has to be accurate," says Tim Lang, professor of Food Policy at the City University in London. The labels show the nutritional breakdown of a product, with the biggest ingredient first.

So, do we trust it?

Tim Lang Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission "Trust in food goes up and down," says Tim Lang. "It dropped dramatically in Britain over the period of the food scandals. It began over additives, in the late '70s. Most additives were purely cosmetic, they served no function, just made the food look ok. But in the case of a colouring for yellow, tartrazine, it became a very big issue, because it was associated with hyper-activity."

Concerns over "Mad Cow disease clearly hit the public. But BSE wasn't deliberately put into food. It raised the whole question about the methods of production -- had the intensive production system put in place since the '60s really got out of control? It became a deeply philosophical issue that went way beyond additives and contaminants."

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

What happened to Rio 2016's leftover food? Creative commons image Icon Indra Galbo under Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0 license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

What happened to Rio 2016's leftover food?

Gourmet chefs fed the athletes of the Olympic Games. Then, they fed the poor.

Article
Meat here? Hunting for data about the food supply chain Creative commons image Icon Gene Huntlicensedfor reuse under CC BY 2.0 under Creative-Commons license article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Meat here? Hunting for data about the food supply chain

What does that food supply chain look like? And what sorts of data are available that allow us to explore the operation of that supply chain?

Article
Ever Wondered About... Food additives? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Ever Wondered About... Food additives?

Are the additives in foods giving us more than just a longer shelf life and distinctive flavour?

Article
What is music? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

History & The Arts 

What is music?

What is music and where does it come from? A number of people contribute their ideas in this article which was originally part of the "Big Question" series.

Article
The Big Question: Can fast food ever be healthy? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

The Big Question: Can fast food ever be healthy?

A quick burger or a cheeky chicken nugget - delicious, perhaps, but must they always be bad for you?

Article
OU on the BBC: Shared Planet – All the episodes Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Julian Hector article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on the BBC: Shared Planet – All the episodes

All the episodes so far from BBC Radio 4's Shared Planet.

Article
Thinking Allowed: Hoarders and microbreweries Creative commons image Icon Earthworm under CC-BY-NC-SA licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Thinking Allowed: Hoarders and microbreweries

On this episode of Thinking Allowed Laurie Taylor hears about the sociological perspective on hoarding and microbreweries in the UK is discussed.

Article
Breaking Science: Science of envy, sugar and kids... Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: photos.com audio icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Breaking Science: Science of envy, sugar and kids...

The root of teeth development, cold genetics, the science of complex emotions and does sugar make kids hyperactive?

Audio
30 mins
Journeys In Thought - Kierkegaard In Berlin Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Article