Health, Sports & Psychology

Beating stress in the City jobs: A Trader’s experiments with psychological reorientation in trading

Updated Thursday 25th September 2008

Darren Agombar was surprised at how psychology helped reduce his stress levels, as he explains

Two similar significant events that occurred four years apart in my professional life elicited very different emotional reactions. The first event produced a highly stressful experience that made me question my confidence and ability and even whether I should change career.

The second, four years later and almost identical in nature resulted in a very different response, and I experienced a massive reduction in the feelings of anxiety and stress, and consequently disruption to my confidence and output.

These two almost identical occurrences and my completely different responses to these events calls into question what had changed in the interim period? On reflection I wondered about the reason behind the change. What had I done or been exposed to in the prevailing four years that had caused the reduction in the stress reaction?

Desk full of paperwork Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Mrbhughes | Dreamstime.com
Busy... or stressed?

I have spent 20 years trading financial markets, in London, Dubai and Tokyo on behalf of international banks and more recently for my own company utilising personal capital. This has given me a detailed insight to the nature of this environment and the stresses and strains individuals can suffer, including me. Trading requires a high level of decision making and the results can be virtually instant, a matter of seconds.

This contributes, along with the pressure of having to be able to react and make decisions in a very short period of time repeatedly can cause high levels of stress that can result in negative effects on confidence and performance. My own experiences of this environment support this notion and I was subject to ups and downs in my own wellbeing as I felt the force of poor runs in revenue making, and these could result in prolonged periods of anxiety.

In 2004 I started my own trading company managing my own capital, something I had long harboured a desire to do, to test myself further professionally. After an initially successful 6 months I experienced a large and unexpected loss.

This had a very negative effect on my confidence, the experience followed along similar lines to previous episodes, in that I felt stress, self doubt and anxiety but this time much worse. The loss added to the change in circumstances working for myself had resulted in such as; working alone, no regular salary, different systems etc exasperated the feelings of stress and anxiety and as a result it took a lot longer to return to profitability and regain confidence.

In the past I had been interested in books and articles on mainstream behavioural finance and had used the theories and concepts to develop my own trading strategies and understand those of the people I managed. However, these did not give me the solutions I needed to rebuild my confidence I lost after the first event and the downturn was significant enough to trigger me into sourcing a new solution. I began to research into academic psychology and decision making through the Open University library with whom I had been studying. This had almost instant results and I began to identify biases and influences that had been affecting my trading for many years, I quickly began to make fundamental changes to my approach. The result was a quick return of performance with enhanced consistency and ultimately strengthening of confidence. This positive event led me to continue to study this area and make the use of psychology and decision making an integral part of my overall strategy.

This leads me to my comparison point and how I came to realise that a by-product of my studies in psychology with the Open University has been a reduction in stress. Again I experienced a large unexpected loss when market conditions altered drastically in a short period of time. The lead up to the loss was similar to the previous experience in that I had made good profits, the loss was not larger than my risk management parameters nor did it exceed previous profits.

What was different was my reaction, I didn’t really notice it at the time, and it was not until further reflection that I realised there had been a fundamental change. At the time some of the same thoughts entered my mind, such as questioning my ability, confidence issues etc but they did not elicit the same emotional response. They did not develop into anything more than a speed bump. I was able to get back on a profitable track much more quickly than the previous experience.

I think there is sufficient evidence to conclude that gaining an understanding of how decisions are influenced by hard wired heuristics, how these can affect the efficiency of decision making in my professional arena, financial markets, has resulted in a reduction in stress levels. It challenges the belief that exists in many high reward industries involving risk taking that this has to be accompanied by stress to merit a high salary. Significantly, being able to see the affects of decisions in an abstract form has allowed some detachment from the emotional influences experienced in the past. This could have equally interesting implications for industries where high levels of decision making is required and results are judged over short periods of time such as sport and medical diagnosis and treatment.

However, in a general business environment the outcome of decisions may take longer to be valued and judged. It is more common for results to be produced quarterly or annually, meaning a much longer period of time will have passed between decisions and outcome. In this scenario accurate data from keeping a business journal would be essential to ensure accurate recall of the environment and conditions decisions were made in.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Making decisions Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Money & Business 

Making decisions

Do you hate making decisions? Does the ability of others to make snap decisions really frustrate you? This free course will help you understand some of the processes involved in decision making. Attention to the psychology of decision making and the social context in which decisions are made can improve your understanding of others and yourself.

Free course
4 hrs
Identifying faces Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Identifying faces

Using an E-FIT facial composite system the Open University has created some celebrity images. Look at the images and see if you can tell who they are.

Article
Taking perspectives of others Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Screengrab from OU video video icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Taking perspectives of others

This example of children's ability to take the perspective of others shows some of the ways in which our research is carried out and our ideas about child development

Video
5 mins
Are you a secret hoarder? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Suemack | Dreamstime.com article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Are you a secret hoarder?

Collector or hoarder: How can we define a healthy relationship to personal possessions?

Article
I-Spy: Episode 3 Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

I-Spy: Episode 3

Episode three of the five-part online infidelity drama I-SPY: Rhianna tries to find evidence on the web for Oliver’s alleged infidelity and the couple argues with each other on Oliver’s late return from the pub.  

Video
5 mins
Did you see it? The magic of misdirection Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: The Open University video icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Did you see it? The magic of misdirection

Are you pretty sharp? Do you pride yourself on your Holmes-like powers of observation? Try watching the 'Bet You Can't Do This' video

Video
5 mins
Reith 2003: Emotion in Mind Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Reith 2003: Emotion in Mind

Writing in response to the Reith Lectures 2003, Dr Bundy Mackintosh considers the importance of emotion in the proper functioning of the brain

Article
Keep your mind on your driving; keep your hands on the wheel Creative commons image Icon dsearls under CC-BY-SA licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Keep your mind on your driving; keep your hands on the wheel

Could you be more prone to car accidents if you listen to football commentary on the radio while you are driving?

Article
Visual identification: Photo credit card study Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Katarzyna Zwolska via Dreamstime.com under Limited Royalty Free Licenses (RF-LL) video icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Visual identification: Photo credit card study

Dr Nicola Brace, Senior Lecturer in Psychology talks us through the challenges eyewitnesses’ face when remembering unfamiliar people.

Video
5 mins