Skip to content
Health, Sports & Psychology

Is the first step in beating superbugs to defeat poverty?

Updated Wednesday 1st June 2016

A two-speed health service can only aid the spread of disease resistant 'superbugs', warns Jason Silverstein

Antibiotic binding to a ribosome Creative commons image Icon MRC Lab of Molecular Biology, Wellcome Images under Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0 license The small (30S) subunit of a prokaryotic ribosome with antibiotic molecules bound and showing up as the light sources in amongst the constituent rRNA and protein molecles. Many antibiotics work by interferring with normal ribosomal functions, preventing accurate protein synthesis. The antibiotics seen as the light sources are spectinomycin, streptomycin and paromomycin. On May 26, 2016, researchers at the Walter Reed National Military Medical Center reported the first case of what they called a “truly pan-drug resistant bacteria.” By now, the story has been well-covered in the media: a month earlier, a 49 year old woman walked into a clinic in Pennsylvania with what seemed to be a urinary tract infection. But tests revealed something far scarier—both for her and public health officials. The strain of E. Coli that infiltrated her body has a gene that makes it bulletproof to colistin, the so-called last resort antibiotic.

Most have pinned the blame for the impending doom of a “post-antibiotic world” on the overuse of antibiotics and a lack of new ones in the development pipeline. But there’s another superbug incubator that hasn’t gotten the attention it deserves: poverty.

Last month at the IMF meeting in Washington, D.C., UK Chancellor George Osborne warned about the potentially devastating human and economic cost of antimicrobial resistance. He called for “the world’s governments and industry leaders to work together in radical new ways.” But Gerry Bloom, a physician and economist at the Institute for Development Studies, argued that any measures to stop overuse and concoct new drugs must be “complemented by investments in measures to ensure universal access to effective antibiotic treatment of common infections.”

“In many countries, poor people obtain these drugs in unregulated markets,” Bloom said. “They often take a partial course and the products may be sub-standard. This increases the risk of resistance.”

For at least fifteen years, we’ve known about these socioeconomic origins of antimicrobial resistance. Other studies have revealed problems with mislabeled or expired or counterfeit drugs. But the clearestlink between poverty and the rise of antimicrobial resistance is that poor people may not see a qualified health care provider or complete a course of quality antibiotics. Instead, they might turn to unregulated markets for substandard drugs.

But why do people resort to unregulated markets or take drugs that aren’t that great if they are available?Marcella Alsan, an assistant professor of medicine at the Stanford School of Medicine who studies the relationship between socioeconomic disparities and infectious diseases, led a study that answered this question. In last October’s Lancet Infectious Diseases, Alsan and her colleagues showed that it might have a lot to do with requiring copayments in the public sector. To show this, they analyzed the WHO’s 2014 Antibacterial Resistance Global Surveillance report with an eye toward the usual suspects, such as antibiotic consumption and antibiotic-flooded livestock.

“We found that out of pocket payments were the most significant correlate of antimicrobial resistance across countries,” Alsan told me. “But when we looked more deeply into the data, we found that that entire correlation was driven by countries that had in place a policy by which copayments were imposed in the public sector.”

That means some of the poorest of the poor need to fork over a copayment anytime they want to receive antibiotics from a public sector provider. That gives us a pretty good idea of why someone might decide to use the “unregulated market” or why they might only complete part of their treatment and save the rest of their antibiotics for a family member or the next time they’re sick.

“If you think about a model in which there’s two sectors to obtain healthcare, there’s a private sector and a public sector. It’s sort of like you have Coke and Pepsi. If you start taxing Pepsi, then people are probably going to drink Coke,” she explained. “We can see that in healthcare, too. And that’s great if the private sector is homogenous and well regulated, but often times the private sector is really heterogeneous. When you drive people into the private sector, you are driving at least some of them into less qualified providers with lower quality medications.”

Rather than shame individuals for taking antibiotics incorrectly, we need to understand how poverty constrains their options. “We presume a lot sitting really far away from some of the populations that are most heavily afflicted,” she said. “What would be the alternative medical care that people could obtain if we shut down informal provision? How would people afford antibiotics if we required copayments everywhere?”

In addition to alleviating the burden of copayments for the poorest patients, what might make a difference in the fight against antimicrobial resistance in low-income countries is the same as what might make a difference in the fight against Zika or Ebola. In other words, the things that many of the fortunate take for granted like health care staff and a regulated supply chain and a functioning public health system.

“Antimicrobial resistance is not unique,” Alsan added. “It is just another manifestation of underinvestment in basic public health infrastructure.”

This article originally appeared on the PLOS blog network under a CC-BY licence

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Researching cycling in the US & the UK Creative commons image Icon New York CDOT under Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0 license audio icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Researching cycling in the US & the UK

Peter Wood shares his experiences researching cyclists - on both sides of the Atlantic.

Audio
10 mins
British public open to compromise on Brexit deal, new research finds Creative commons image Icon [trading] by Humberto Acevedo, via Flickr under Creative Commons BY-NC 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Article
An uncomfortable truth: How Britain has criminalised rough sleepers Creative commons image Icon Yurly Akopov under Creative Commons BY-NC 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

An uncomfortable truth: How Britain has criminalised rough sleepers

You can judge a society by how it treats those most in needs. The last 200 years or so of criminalisation of the homeless doesn't reflect that well on the UK.

Article
Taking part in the voluntary sector video icon

Money & Business 

Taking part in the voluntary sector

This course is for people who are interested in being involved or progressing in the voluntary sector.

Video
How are scientists testing for the growth of antibiotic resistance? Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Janice Haney Carr / Center For Disease Control and Prevention article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

How are scientists testing for the growth of antibiotic resistance?

Is following the evolution of bacteria going to help us find a solution to the growing problem of antibiotic resistance?

Article
What are premature babies telling us about antibiotic resistance? Creative commons image Icon Science Museum under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

What are premature babies telling us about antibiotic resistance?

A new study of the bacteria found in the guts of children born before full-term shows the superbug problem is a growing threat.

Article
The public policy – action relationship Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Money & Business 

The public policy – action relationship

Much literature on the public policy process focuses narrowly on the policy-making part. This free course, The public policyaction relationship, widens the focus to examine the implementation phase, and how change happens as a result of new policies: that is, policyaction relationship. It does this by looking at four different models of how this relationship can work, through examples from varying fields. The course will be of interest to public sector managers, their staff and the general reader.

Free course
7 hrs
OpenLearn Live: 14th January 2016 Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Carl Van Vechten collection at the Library Of Congress article icon

History & The Arts 

OpenLearn Live: 14th January 2016

An artist who painted her way from Serbia to the US. Then more free learning across the day.

Article
Charlie Sheen, Rock Hudson and the changing face of HIV stigma Creative commons image Icon By Joella Marano (Charlie Sheen) [CC BY-SA 2.0], via Wikimedia Commons under Creative-Commons license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Charlie Sheen, Rock Hudson and the changing face of HIV stigma

How has the treatment and attitudes towards HIV changed between 1985 and 2015? Peter Keogh explores...

Article