The Open University since 2006
Alternatively you can skip the navigation by pressing 'Enter'.
Thinking Allowed 2016: A special programme on Pierre BourdieuMonday, 27th June 2016 00:15 - BBC Radio 4This special episode of Thinking Allowed explores the ideas of French socialist Pierre Bourdieu. Read more: Thinking Allowed 2016: A special programme on Pierre Bourdieu
Canals: The Making of a Nation: HeritageMonday, 27th June 2016 20:00 - BBC Four
All in the Mind - Summer 2016: All in the Mind Awards Ceremony from the Wellcome Collection in LondonTuesday, 28th June 2016 21:00 - BBC Radio 4
Genius of the Modern World: NietzscheTuesday, 28th June 2016 23:00 - BBC Four
Thinking Allowed 2016: A special programme on Pierre BourdieuAvailable for over a yearThis special episode of Thinking Allowed explores the ideas of French socialist Pierre Bourdieu. Read more: Thinking Allowed 2016: A special programme on Pierre Bourdieu
Making young children give everything to football is a bad idea – here’s whyBritish football clubs want children to specialise in only football from a young age, but would a... Read more: Making young children give everything to football is a bad idea – here’s why
OpenLearn Live: 27th June 2016The musician who aimed to take a mop to power; Hubble gets another five years of star gazing.... Watch now: OpenLearn Live: 27th June 2016
The value of coffeeThis free course explores the economic and cultural value of coffee. You will follow the chain of... Try: The value of coffee now
Introduction to bookkeeping and accountingLearn about the essential numerical skills required for accounting and bookkeeping. This free... Try: Introduction to bookkeeping and accounting now
What does it take to become a critical practitioner in social work? This free course, Becoming a critical social work practitioner, will guide you through some important concepts. An understanding of 'critical perspectives' will help you take a positive and constructive approach to problems that arise in social work practice.
After studying this course, you should be able to:
- demonstrate a critical understanding of the nature and boundaries of personal and professional discretion and judgement in the delivery of social work services; recognising the complex tensions between personal and social processes in people's lives
- demonstrate an understanding of the complex relationship between justice, care and control and the practical and ethical effects of this relationship.
- Learning outcomes
- 1 Understanding critical practice
- 2 Constructive social work
- 3 Critical use of language: service user views and professional power
- Keep on learning
Study this free course
Enrol to access the full course, get recognition for the skills you learn, track your progress and on completion gain a statement of participation to demonstrate your learning to others. Make your learning visible!
2.3 Objective conditions and subjective definitions
Reread the story about the three baseball umpires, which you'll find on page 11 of ‘What do we mean by “Constructive social work”?’
After you have read the story again, read the three paragraphs following it which include a quote from Fuller and Myers (1941), about objective conditions and subjective definitions. Think about what you have read and draft answers to the following questions:
How would you describe the differences between the three umpires in terms of their ‘world view’ (or how they see things) in calling balls and strikes?
If they were three social workers discussing how they ‘see problems’, what difference might this make to their practice?
If social work was practised according to the first or second type of approach used by the umpires what might be the likely result?
What are the implications of the third approach for social work practitioners' power?
In what ways were you persuaded (or not!) by the distinction between objective conditions and subjective definitions?
Did this distinction help to further explain the difference between the three umpires?
Do you think that the existence of ‘problems’ is self-evident – or does it depend, as the authors argue, on someone claiming or asserting that a problem exists?
What are the implications for social workers' practice in general and your practice in particular?
When you have drafted your answers to these questions, you may wish to share them using the Comments section below. You will also be able to see the comments from others studying this course and can, if you wish, post further comments agreeing or disagreeing with them. Your developing thoughts will contribute towards an online group debate about the different views and responses to what you have read.
The story demonstrates three different ways of approaching practice; the first assumes that what we see and hear is not interpreted by us, or filtered by our assumptions – that what we see is the way things ‘really are’. The second accepts that reality appears only as we, or rather ‘I’, see it, that is, only through my own perceptions and prejudices or ‘constructs’. The third approach recognises the importance of our own constructs of reality but, in addition, accepts that there is power in our social positions. In other words, we can use our position within social situations to ‘call’ and thereby create and define an interpretation of what has happened.
What it is crucial to understand is the power of the role that certain people play within certain situations. In baseball, cricket or football, the umpire or referee enforces the rules of the game. Although many people may have contributed to creating the rules, the person who interprets them has power as a result of their position. The rules of the game may have been socially created and constructed from many different sources but they are open to interpretation and professional judgement.
Social work practice shares some similarities with this scenario – but it also has some important differences. The ‘rules’ concerning services and interactions between social workers and service users have been constructed socially via agency and government policy. Nevertheless, these rules have to be put into practice by the social worker interacting with service user(s) and colleagues, often over long periods of time. However, absolute split-second decisions do not have to be made by social workers acting alone! So, in implementing ‘the rules of the game’ social workers can see these rules as:
more or less fixed, permanent and outside their control
as a matter for their discretion and judgement only
as a social process that they and the service user are part of, and over which they have significant influence, but not full control – however, neither does anyone else!
In our view, if social work is practised according to the first or second approaches it is likely that partnership with service users will fail because the service will be bureaucratic and impersonal, or idiosyncratic and judgemental.
In effect, practising the first two approaches would undermine Glaister's pillars of practice, as discussed in Activity 1.
The quote from Fuller and Myers which follows the story makes a key philosophical distinction with profound professional practice implications. There are ‘objective conditions’ in all social work situations, about which disagreement is unlikely. For example, there is no bed for a child; no heating in an elderly person's house; a family has no money. In addition, and overlaying these conditions, there are also ‘subjective definitions’ of situations through which everyone, including social workers, assigns meanings, values, judgements and assessments.
The objective absence of bed, heating or money may clearly be a priority problem in given situations. However, there is an equal possibility that it may not be assessed as a problem, or not one necessarily requiring social work intervention, when a range of other information about specific circumstances and possible future actions are negotiated or taken into account.
To pursue these examples: the parents may be happy for the child to sleep with them until a bed can be found; the elderly person may prefer to wear more clothing rather than spend money on heating; the family may have friends or relatives who are willing and able to help. This key distinction between objective conditions and subjective definitions is crucial to understanding the ‘constructive’ approach to social work practice.
Copyright & revisions
Originally published: Monday, 29th February 2016
Last updated on: Monday, 29th February 2016
- Creative-Commons: The Open University is proud to release this free course under a Creative Commons licence. However, any third-party materials featured within it are used with permission and are not ours to give away. These materials are not subject to the Creative Commons licence. See terms and conditions. Full details can be found in the Acknowledgements and our FAQs section.
- This site has Copy Reuse Tracking enabled - see our FAQs for more information.
If you enjoyed this, why not follow a feed to find out when we have new things like it? Choose an RSS feed from the list below. (Don't know what to do with RSS feeds?)
Remember, you can also make your own, personal feed by combining tags from around OpenLearn.
All our alternative formats are free for you to download, for more information about the different formats we offer please see our FAQs. The most frequently used are Word (for accessibility), PDF (for print) and ePub and Kindle to download to eReaders*.
- Word (976 KB)
- PDF (2.1 MB)
- ePub 3.0 (10.3 MB)
- ePub 2.0 (737 KB)
- Kindle (303 KB)
- RSS (266 KB)
- HTML (10.2 MB)
- SCORM (10.2 MB)
- OUXML Package (32 KB)
- OUXML File (103 KB)
- IMS Common cartridge
- Moodle backup (10.3 MB)
*Please note you will need an ePub and Mobi reader for these formats.