Debate: The Bible and Darwin

Updated Sunday 21st December 2008

DMWessel, a community member, wondered if there is common ground between the Bible and Darwin

A bronze of Rodin's The Thinker Copyrighted image Icon Copyrighted image Copyright: Jupiter Images

I know it's a touchy subject but I thought people might be interested in this slant on things:

Evolution says that life came from the 'primordial soup (mud)' and the Bible actually says, what I am convinced, is the same thing:

"And the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground." (Gen. 2:7)
Dust (as powdered or gray; hence clay, earth, mud:-ashes, earth, ground, mortar, powder, rubbish) ‘of the ground (soil - from its gen. redness).

Darwin said that human beings came from the primates, and Bible writings have this to say:

(Genesis) Adam/man (Hebrew-synonyms) = ‘ruddy (red)’, rosy, the flush of blood

"...man became a living soul" (Genesis 2:7b):
soul (Hebrew & Greek) = breathing creature/the animal sentiment principal only

- does not suggest a ‘human’ being but rather a ‘ruddy’ creature (as coming from the ‘red’ earth - dust/ground)

"Prior to being put into the garden, ruddy did not have 'spiritual' ability, he only gained that after he entered the garden; '...and the Lord God planted a garden eastward in Eden; and there he put the man (ruddy) whom he had made." (parentheses mine, Gen. 2:8 & 15)

So then, Adam/man was not initially a ‘human’ being as many believe but rather a ‘ruddy creature of earth’, an animal (had to have been a chimpanzee/rhesus monkey because according to recent genome mapping, somewhere along the line we picked up the chimp gene - see attached 'chimphand').

It was the gaining of this other element that enabled one primate to change from animal to human, and unless he had gained it, could not have changed - thus the reason we don't see other primates in various stages of change.

Religious tendencies are observed strictly in the human species. If human beings are in part ‘soul (animal)’ then why aren’t such tendencies evident in other primates? Could it be because we have something the other animals don’t have?

soul = mortal
spirit = immortal

animal = sou
human being = soul + immortal spiritl

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Science, Maths & Technology 

Cyborgs and cybernetics

What are cyborgs? Would a cyborg future deliver positive human advances or a Hollywood-style nightmare in which human beings have become a sub-species? Could we one day download our minds? This album gives an insight into the development of cybernetics and how it is used to fuse technology and humanity. The interfaces that communicate between man and machine are developing rapidly and to Prof. Kevin Warwick at Reading University, cyborgs are a technological evolutionary step forward from humans. With increasingly intelligent robots and nano-technologies, can man keep up with the machines? This material forms part of The Open University course T209 Information and communication technologies: people and interactions.

Audio
15 mins

History & The Arts 

Philosophy and the Human Situation

Philosophy and philosophical enquiries are relevant in some shape or form to many aspects of everyday life, for example our treatment of the environment, the rapidity of today's technological progress, whether animals should have rights and if so how they should compare to ours. Philosophy also encompasses questions about the existence of God, how life is sustained on earth, and even at what point should the Government intrude on a person's freedom. This album introduces the study of philosophy and the human situation, and contains talks and debates from leading philosophical thinkers and teachers, past and present. This material forms part of The Open University course A211 Philosophy and the human situation.

Audio
4 hrs 30 mins

Science, Maths & Technology 

Are Manned Missions Worth It?

Professor David W Hughes compares the benefits of sending probes to explore the solar system against the value that manned missions could offer

Article

History & The Arts 

A Brief History of Science

From the discovery of metals up to mapping the human genome, take a quick crash through the development of scientific knowledge.

Article

History & The Arts 

Art, censorship and morality

Should artists have complete freedom? Or should we limit what they say and how they say it? Discover the dilemmas of art, censorship and morality.

Audio
15 mins

History & The Arts 

Trust and the state of nature

Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679), perhaps the greatest English political philosopher, argued that life in the state of nature would be, "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short". But what is the state of nature? Need it be so miserable? And why does this matter, anyway? Jonathan Wolff, Professor of Philosophy, University College London, considers the issues.

Article

History & The Arts 

Thomas Aquinas and the First Mover Argument

This animation looks at Thomas Aquinas and his theory that god is at the start of everything.

Video
5 mins

History & The Arts 

Sandel on Kant and the capacity for reason

Michael Sandel looks at how Kant's emphasis on our capacity to reason has a place for beings who lack much in the way of reasoning ability or rationality

Video
5 mins

History & The Arts 

To lie or not to lie?

A lie’s a lie, right? But what if it wasn’t that simple? This game makes you think about your moral responses to different lies

Activity