Skip to content

How can the Hajj be made safer?

Updated Monday 28th September 2015

After a second tragedy at the 2015 Hajj, could understanding the psychology of crowds help to make future pilgrimages safer for everyone?

The crowd crush at the annual Hajj pilgrimage in Saudi Arabia has claimed the lives of more than 700 people and injured at least 850 more. Sadly this is not the first such tragedy to affect the event. The Hajj attracts millions of pilgrims from across the world every year and involves several complex rituals, which means it is always a potentially dangerous event.

In recent years, great lengths have been taken to ensure the safety of pilgrims, with, according to Saudi government sources, more than £200bn spent since 1992 on redesigning the infrastructure of the Hajj, which involves events at several sites in and around the city of Mecca. One key way that organisers plan for the safety of crowd events such as the Hajj, but also parades, carnivals and sporting competitions, is by using computer simulations to model large groups of people.

The public security control room at the 2009 Hajj Creative commons image Icon Omar Chatriwala under CC-BY-NC-ND under Creative-Commons license A large task: The public security control room at the 2009 Hajj

Two crowds

In a recent systematic review of computer models we drew upon the social identity approach, which suggests a distinction between physical crowds (where people are simply in one place) and psychological crowds (where people in a physical crowd share a common self-definition – a social identity).

A group of people at an event may all see themselves and each other as Muslims, Manchester United supporters, or music lovers, for example. This shared identity affects the behaviour of the crowd and is therefore imperative for understanding and predicting the crowd movements, including flow and congestion.

Recent research has shown that feelings of group identity may mean psychological crowds are easier for their members to cope with even if they are tightly packed or very slow moving because they feel safe within the group. But when there are several psychological crowds within the same physical space they can inadvertently limit the movement of one another.

In a recent (unpublished) study we found that people in one psychological crowd walk more closely together, walk more slowly and walk further distances to stay together than people who are just in physical crowds. Those outside the psychological crowd did not try to walk through it but instead walked around it.

Despite the importance of shared identity to understanding psychological crowds, computer modellers have so far either neglected crowd psychology in their models or treated crowds simply as a mass of identical individuals. Where groups are included within the crowd, the model has been to use small groups of two to five people. But the modellers have assumed that all crowds are simply physical crowds.

As a result, these simulations cannot adequately predict the behaviour of psychological crowds. A key issue, as mentioned, is that a physical crowd may contain more than one psychological crowd – for example, Sunni and Shia. So assuming that the crowd is simply made up of individuals who behave like particles or billiard balls in a mass doesn’t account for a number of features of crowds such as that at the Hajj.

Modelling the Hajj

This has several important implications for existing simulations of the event. For example, they can’t predict how different groups favour different locations in the Hajj, such as the Shia preference for worshipping in the open. This is particularly important due to the variety of rituals the pilgrimage involves. A model that treats the crowd as a homogeneous entity also can’t explain how large groups of people will try to stick together within a moving crowd, separating themselves from other groups and creating mass contraflows.

We should be wary of relying exclusively on computer models, however. They cannot give absolute predictions or guarantee safety. In order to avoid disasters, we also need to monitor the density and flow of crowds in real time to prevent these disasters from emerging. But by combining computer modelling with crowd psychology, we can better understand crowd behaviour and develop simulations that can make events safer and hopefully avoid disasters such as the events we have witnessed at the Hajj.The Conversation

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.


For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Negotiating Notting Hill Creative commons image Icon By The Style PA via Flickr under Creative Commons license under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Negotiating Notting Hill

Melissa Butcher reflects on her experience at the Notting Hill Carnival, and looks at crowd behaviour

60 second adventures in economics: Rational Choice Theory Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Society, Politics & Law 

60 second adventures in economics: Rational Choice Theory

People are pretty rational. But not quite rational enough for the good of the economy.

5 mins
Psychological profiling Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: By let ideas compete via Flickr under Creative Commons licence article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Psychological profiling

Paul Britton, the man known as 'The Real Cracker', is perhaps the UK's leading psychological profiler. He has helped police solve some of the country's most shocking crimes. How did he get started?

DEBATE: Is the focus on female virginity and celibacy in some religions a form of controlling women? Creative commons image Icon Peter Panter under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

History & The Arts 

DEBATE: Is the focus on female virginity and celibacy in some religions a form of controlling women?

Is the idealisation of female virginity an attempt to keep women’s sexuality in check or is it an empowering choice? 

Who was Mary Magdalene? Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Artemisia Gentileschi article icon

History & The Arts 

Who was Mary Magdalene?

She appears in all the gospels, but we're still not entirely sure who Mary Magdalene was.

Studying religion Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

History & The Arts 

Studying religion

This free course, Studying religion, will give you an opportunity to think about some of the key concepts and methods of the discipline of Religious Studies. You will meet examples of different forms of religious practice and belief, mostly from Britain and India.

Free course
20 hrs
Do dogs want to go to heaven? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Castrothecigar | article icon

History & The Arts 

Do dogs want to go to heaven?

Have you ever wondered what happens to our pets when they die?

Video Interview: Rabbi Dr Deborah Kahn-Harris Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: The Open University video icon

History & The Arts 

Video Interview: Rabbi Dr Deborah Kahn-Harris

Rabbi Dr Deborah Kahn-Harris talks to the Open University's Graham Harvey 

10 mins
Babies and Guns: Religion and the US Presidential Elections Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

History & The Arts 

Babies and Guns: Religion and the US Presidential Elections

Melanie Wright explores the role of religious belief in American elections