Skip to content

Bringing out the bad guy with Star Trek

Updated Wednesday 22nd May 2013

How does "soft" science fiction like Star Trek offer new ways to explore old questions about who we are and what made us that way?

One of the most freeing things about ‘soft’ science fiction like Star Trek is that writers are offered a wealth of new ways to explore old questions about who we are and what made us that way.

One way of understanding who we are which goes back to the cultures of the ancient world is to define ourselves against who we are not.

The ancient Romans have often been used as an example of what we (like to think we) are not – decadent, violent, arrogant, depraved.

However, some productions, including the Star Trek episode ‘Bread and Circuses,’ turn that trope on its head by making us question whether perhaps we are more like the Romans than we like to think (see also The Hunger Games and Peter Watkins’ The Gladiators).

Gladiatorial combat seems far removed from anything in our society – brutal, unforgiving, violent. But in ‘Bread and Circuses,’ when we encounter a planet that essentially represents a world where the Roman Empire never fell and the Romans have access to 20th century technology, the audience are shown a brutal televisual landscape in which gladiatorial fights are used to bolster ratings and keep television networks in business.

Watching these fights unfold on our own televisions, knowing the metaphorically cutthroat nature of the business, we are asked to consider the ways in which we resemble the Romans, rather than allowing ourselves to take comfort from our differences.

Exactly what aspects of ourselves Star Trek: Into Darkness will reflect remains to be seen. Stories are, ultimately, about their audience, the good guys representing how we define ourselves and the bad guys defining what we think we are not – but there is usually something of the bad guy in us too, if we look closely enough, and that is the marker of the best stories.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Star Trek 50 Creative commons image Icon B9TRIBECAlicensedfor reuse under CC BY-ND 3.0 under Creative-Commons license article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Star Trek 50

To celebrate the 50 years of Star Trek, we're taking you where no man has gone before: into the minds of our academics as they go star trekking... 

Article
Star Trek and the Greeks Creative commons image Icon Marie-Lan Nguyen / Wikimedia Commons under Creative-Commons license article icon

History & The Arts 

Star Trek and the Greeks

Like many science fiction series, Star Trek in all its incarnations has drawn upon human history

Article
The Dog of Alcibiades article icon

History & The Arts 

The Dog of Alcibiades

Getting people to gossip about your dog can be a useful way of distracting them from talking about you! 

Article
Perseus: what’s in a name? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Thinkstock article icon

History & The Arts 

Perseus: what’s in a name?

As the Perseid Meteor Shower reaches its annual peak, Dr Joanna Paul, a Lecturer in Classical Studies, lifts the lid on the details behind its namesake, Perseus, a mythological character whose story has been told time and time again.

Article
Crowdsourced annotation: what do you think? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Trustees of the British Museum activity icon

History & The Arts 

Crowdsourced annotation: what do you think?

Take a look at 'crowdsourced' resources to help understand ‘The Histories’ alongside the Hestia project. We direct you to other resources so that you may extend your enquiry by comparing accounts, cross-referencing evidence, or verifying sources.

Activity
The City: The Roman and Greek Cities Creative commons image Icon Image by CharChen via Flickr under Creative Commons licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

History & The Arts 

The City: The Roman and Greek Cities

The concept of the city was central to both the Roman and the Greek sense of identity.

Article
‘Lydios logos’: the story of Croesus activity icon

History & The Arts 

‘Lydios logos’: the story of Croesus

Herodotus tells the story of Croesus in the first tale, or ‘logos’, of his great work ‘The Histories’. Explore the contradictions in his narrative with other contemporary and archaeological evidence. Think about the extent to which Herodotus deserves his title ‘father of history’.

Activity
Contesting power through satire Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license activity icon

History & The Arts 

Contesting power through satire

Explore the use of satire from Classical Greece through to 2013 with this interactive timeline. 

Activity
Myth making at the movies - Musings on Mad Max: Fury Road Creative commons image Icon Clawsoncat via Deviantart under CC-BY-ND licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

History & The Arts 

Myth making at the movies - Musings on Mad Max: Fury Road

The film Mad Max: Fury Road is set in the dystopian future, but is the narrative a recycled story from Roman and Greek times? N.B. contains spoilers for the movie. 

Article