• Video
  • 5 mins
  • Level 1: Introductory

Origin Day Lecture: Audience Question Six

Updated Wednesday 25th November 2009

Would the panel care to comment on the grip that creationism has on the minds of the wider public?

Video

Copyright British Council

Text

 

Armand Leroi (as Chair) 

Ladies and gentlemen, let me throw it open to the floor, to the audience.  I instantly see a series of hands going up, the one thing I will ask is that you have a microphone in your hand before you speak. Gentleman, right in front of me on the left.

Male speaker (in audience)

Thank you.  In this institution which has pioneered the promotion of the public understanding of science, I think there’s a small elephant in the room.  Professor Wilson has outlined exciting areas for research and development to promote evolutionary theory, but have we, to use the phrases by Randal Keynes, failed to use the power of the idea to explain when a large percentage of the population believes in creationism and intelligent design to the extent if statistics are to believe up to a fifth of science teachers in the United States believe it should be taught in science classes as a viable alternative.  Would the panel care to comment on the grip that creationism has on the minds of the wider public?

Armand Leroi   

Very briefly.

Randal Keynes

The simplest suggestion, just, you know, to offer science?

Armand Leroi    

Yes.

Peter Bowler

Well, I think it’s, coming from Northern Ireland where this is a particular problem, more so than most other areas of the United Kingdom, one is aware of the strength of the institutional religious promotion of creationism, and I think we do have a difficult problem balancing our desire to teach and inform about science without alienating people who are coming from very different cultural, intellectual background to what many of those of us who are interested in science come from.  And so I think there are serious issues to be debated here about how we present evolution, and you can probably imagine where I would go from there if I had the time, but I’ll leave it at that.

Armand Leroi

Sandy, debate them or ignore them?

Sandy Knapp

Well I think actually one of the things that is interesting about science is science is often portrayed as something which is proved, and I think one of the things we have to fight against as scientists is the concept of proof in science, science is about evidence and support of evidence.  And the other thing that I think is kind of frightening about science and about being a scientist is scientists are often set aside from society.  Scientists are a part of society so I say to people, and I've said it in this very room, to a room full of eight year olds, I've said okay who here is a scientist, and no one raises their hand but they all sit there, so who here is a scientist?  Come on.  In true tradition of the Royal Institution, I would argue that every single one of us does a scientific experiment every single day, when we set our alarm clock five minutes later and see if we can still get to work on time.  And if you can describe science in that way, then we’re all scientists and it becomes less mysterious, so I think the mystery of science needs to be beaten back.

(3’16”)

 

Watch the full lecture

EO Wilson Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: British Council Professor EO Wilson's lecture to mark Origin Day

 
 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Wake up call Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: The Open University video icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Wake up call

Pen Hadow is a polar explorer and also runs a business - Geo Mission - which is an environmental sponsorship organisation. He talks about the work he does to highlight the devastation being caused in the Arctic, as well as his solo expedition to the North Pole in 2003

Video
5 mins
Rough Science 6 Colorado: Photo Video Diaries: Mike Bullivant Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team video icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Rough Science 6 Colorado: Photo Video Diaries: Mike Bullivant

Exclusive video extra in which Mike Bullivant talks about the challenge for the Photo programme, from the sixth BBC/OU TV series Rough Science, based in Colorado

Video
5 mins
Science and society: A career and professional development course Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Education & Development 

Science and society: A career and professional development course

Scientists throughout the world are increasingly interested in the relationship between science and society. Part of their concern is with the social responsibilities scientists have in relation to broader public interests. That raises important issues to do with the ethical and social dimension of scientists' work and how scientists explain and perhaps justify their work to the wider public. Science and society: A career and professional development course, is a free course that explores this further.

Free course
30 hrs
How can Wikipedia Activism restore diversity to science? Creative commons image Icon James Kegley - Howard Hughes Medical Institute under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license activity icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

How can Wikipedia Activism restore diversity to science?

Using Wikipedia to celebrate the achievements of the many scientists who aren't white men can help restore a sense of balance to science, says Hilda Bastian.

Activity
Dr Benny Peiser - Stories of Change Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Dr Benny Peiser audio icon

Nature & Environment 

Dr Benny Peiser - Stories of Change

Dr Benny Peiser, the Director of the Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF) is interviewed by Roger Harrabin for 'Stories of Change'.

Audio
OpenLearn Live: 7th August 2015 Creative commons image Icon Kirsten Lara Getchell under CC-BY-SA licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OpenLearn Live: 7th August 2015

Rounding off our week of scientific musicians, and tracking free learning across the day.

Article
The nQuire young citizen inquiry Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: nQuire article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

The nQuire young citizen inquiry

We want young scientists to develop a personal sense of wonder.

Article
Bang Goes The Theory 7:  Episode 5 Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Nike Sh | Dreamstime.com article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Bang Goes The Theory 7: Episode 5

This week the Bang team reveal how much we really know about what's on our dinner plate.

Article

Science, Maths & Technology 

Women in Science

How have individual female scientists contributed to the advancement of science through time? To celebrate the 100th anniversary of International Women’s Day (March 8th) and to mark International Year of Chemistry 2011, The Open University asked some of the female scientists currently working in its Faculty of Science, to nominate their personal choice of outstanding woman of science. The female scientists nominated include several Nobel Prize Laureates, such as Marie Curie, Dorothy Hodgkin and American geneticist, Barbara McClintock. The academics also talk about their own experiences of being a woman in the sciences today.

Audio
50 mins