Skip to content

Whose war was it, anyway?

Updated Friday 11th February 2005

Bill Purdue asks some searching questions about popular views of the second world war.

Squadron Leader LW Feltham DFC Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC

Ten years ago, when we celebrated the fiftieth anniversary of VE Day, the end of the Second World War in Europe, everyone seemed to know their parts. At least in my North Pennine village they did. The walls of the local pub were adorned with war-time propaganda posters and a bonfire was lit on the same spot as in 1945. At the dance in the village hall there were WAAFs, naval officers, GIs and ARP wardens moving to the music of Glen Miller. I can’t remember if anyone did a Prince Harry although there was a touch of ‘Allo ‘Allo about some of the costumes. The raffle prize was a box of retro foodstuffs including a tin of Spam and a packet of dried egg.

What was evoked was perhaps a rather cosy British image of the war but what it displayed was considerable pride in Britain’s record in standing alone against Germany during 1940-41 and some nostalgia for the cohesion of society during the war-time years.

But the accuracy of this image of Britain at war can, of course, be challenged. It comes to us filtered by films, journalism, books and TV series; even for those who lived through the war what have become standard accounts and images may overlay memories.

Sixty years after the end of the war the ranks of those who lived through it (at least as adults) are considerably thinned. In 1995, the Queen and the Queen Mother stood on the same balcony as in May 1945, while this year only the Queen survives from the family group that marked a defining moment of victory. Do people in 2005 know their parts so well? Is there still general agreement on the basic account of Britain’s war?

Perspectives of the war have always been changing. The mere passage of time sees to that and the perspectives of those who know the war from the accounts of parents or from black and white films have inevitably differed from those who experienced its hardships, tragedies and triumphs. Now those who know of the war-time atmosphere even as second-hand memory are necessarily becoming the minority.

Historians have, as one would expect, been debating, attacking and defending the view of a sturdy and patriotic Britain, reluctant to go to war but resolute and defiant when the conflict came. Was this a war which united the nation? Was the story of cheerfulness and cohesion in the face of threatened invasion and relentless bombing a myth? What about the black market, an increase in crime, strikes and profiteering? Did the class war go on as the war between states developed? Was the positive image of Britain at war due to the success of government propaganda? In the end we can’t go back to find out, even though historians scour the archives for evidence.

In our Open University study guide, The People’s War?, James Chapman and I explore some of these issues making use of the important evidence garnered by the BBC’s on-line WW2 People’s War which invited e-mail accounts of memories of the war. The pack includes my book The Second World War (a broad account of the war and a discussion of the main debates), a Study Guide and a DVD which includes clips from newsreels and feature films. We conclude that with many reservations the by now traditional account stands up well. Yes, there is mythology in it but no account stands the test of time unless there is a strong factual basis for it. Britain at war was a remarkably cohesive, disciplined and resolute society.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Britain's Great War: The darkest hour - guide & clips Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC/Dave Williams video icon

History & The Arts 

Britain's Great War: The darkest hour - guide & clips

How Germany's attempts to starve Britain into submission edged the nation close to defeat.

Video
10 mins
Britain's Great War: War comes to Britain - guide & clips Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC / Dave Williams video icon

History & The Arts 

Britain's Great War: War comes to Britain - guide & clips

Jeremy Paxman traces the story of the dramatic early stages of the First World War.

Video
10 mins
Britain's Great War: The war machine - guide & clips Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC/Dave Williams video icon

History & The Arts 

Britain's Great War: The war machine - guide & clips

In the second episode, the whole population is enlisted to turn an unprepared Britain into a war machine.

Video
10 mins
Strange job: being Queen Elizabeth II, Britain’s longest reigning monarch Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Public Domain article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Strange job: being Queen Elizabeth II, Britain’s longest reigning monarch

Queen Elizabeth II has become Britain's longest-reigning monarch. So how has she managed to keep her job for so long?

Article
Wartime Farm - Episode 1 Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Lion TV / BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Wartime Farm - Episode 1

After the outbreak of hostilities, our heroes of the Home Front get stuck in to keeping the nation fed.

Article
Wartime Farm - Episode 2 Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Lion TV / BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Wartime Farm - Episode 2

As our wartime farmers continue to get to grips with agriculture under fire, they pitch in for silage and meet the Land Army.

Article
OU on the BBC: The Brits Who Built The Modern World ARCHIVE Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Nathan Kendall/OFTV article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on the BBC: The Brits Who Built The Modern World ARCHIVE

Join us for the series that tells the story of how an exceptional generation of British architects conquered the globe with their high-tech vision.

Article
OU on the BBC: Britain's Great War Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC / Dave Williams article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on the BBC: Britain's Great War

How Britain was transformed by the First World War, focusing on extraordinary personal stories to illuminate often cataclysmic events.

Article
The July Crisis: Ultimatum and outbreak of war Creative commons image Icon Wilhelm Dahms, Lübeckische Anzeigen vom 2. August 1914 [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons under Creative-Commons license article icon

History & The Arts 

The July Crisis: Ultimatum and outbreak of war

A series of diplomatic maneuverings in July 1914 led to an ultimatum from Austria-Hungary to Serbia, and to war.

Article