Debate: Richard III - Innocent?

Updated Tuesday 29th January 2008

CatherineJ, forum member, spoke up for a maligned monarch

A public meeting Copyrighted image Icon Copyrighted image Copyright: Jupiter Images

I would like to discuss this if anyone is up for it. Like many "Ricardians" I don't believe he killed the "Princes in the Tower" though I do accept that he COULD have.

There is valid evidence to suggest that Edward IV's marriage to Elizabeth Woodville was illegal and therefore their children, including the boys, were illegitimate, so could not inherit. Indeed recent evidence has come to light that Edward himself may have been illegitimate.

There were always rumours to that effect, since hre mother herself said he was, but evidence may now bear this out, in which case Richard was rightful king.

Certainly in the late 15thC any rival is a problem, but the evidence against Richard is circumstantial to say the leats, and downright dodgy at times.

When the main evidence comes from the people who overthrew him, and is put besides their descriptions of him as hunchbacked and born with teeth you have to, at the very least, take a second look.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

History & The Arts 

Tremors - Reformation & Counter-reformation England

Henry VIII's desire for divorce sparks a reformation in England

Article

History & The Arts 

World War 100: 8 October - The Balkan War

The First Balkan War broke out when the Balkan League attacked the Ottoman Empire on 8 October 1912. Find out more with the next instalment of our World War 100 series 

Article

History & The Arts 

Irish Plantations: By map

Developments in Ireland were a major factor in the English Civil War. Plot the impact of the war on Ireland as events unfolded with our series of maps of the Irish plantations

Article

History & The Arts 

World War 1: More free resources from The Open University

Discover more about the First World War and its traumatic effects on those that survive it with The Open University.

Article

History & The Arts 

Debate: Fulford Gate, 1066

Forum guest Huscarl recalled a day when the British were not covered in glory

Article

History & The Arts 

Expert opinion: Origins of the First World War

Listen to two leading historians give their thoughts on the origins of the First World War.

Audio
30 mins

History & The Arts 

Total War - Parliament

Inspired by Cromwell, and in the face of possible defeat, a new approach was needed by Parliament

Article

History & The Arts 

The Solemn League

A promise to uphold religious freedoms led to a deal between the English Parliament and the Scots: The solemn league

Article
1 July 1916: the beginning of the Battle of the Somme article icon

History & The Arts 

1 July 1916: the beginning of the Battle of the Somme

On the centenary of the end of The Battle of the Somme, discover why the British consider it the bloodiest battle of the First World War, surpassing the Battle of Verdun, and why the Germans don't hold the same view. 

Article