from The Open University
Alternatively you can skip the navigation by pressing 'Enter'.
More or Less: Chinese market crash, e-cigarettes and runnersFriday, 28th August 2015 16:30 - BBC Radio 4More or Less investigates the Chinese market crash, e-cigarettes, engineering and how sprinters run so fast. Read more: More or Less: Chinese market crash, e-cigarettes and runners
BBC Inside Science: Genes, dust and brainsAvailable for over a yearThis week on BBC Inside Science: obesity and genes, dust, brains and computers and the mathematics of life. Read more: BBC Inside Science: Genes, dust and brains
The world’s busiest railway 2015 – Mumbai Railway: Episode 4Available until Saturday, 26th September 2015 22:00
The world’s busiest railway 2015 – Mumbai Railway: Episode 3Available until Friday, 25th September 2015 22:00
The world’s busiest railway 2015 – Mumbai Railway: Episode 2Available until Tuesday, 6th October 2015 20:00
OpenLearn Live: August Bank Holiday Special 2015Not so much live, but with a great collection of free courses, things to watch and listen to, and... Read more: OpenLearn Live: August Bank Holiday Special 2015
Are our kids tough enough? Chinese schoolIn a unique experiment, five teachers from China take over the education of 50 teenagers in a... Read more: Are our kids tough enough? Chinese school
Challenges in advanced management accountingThis free course, Challenges in advanced management accounting, focuses on strategic management... Try: Challenges in advanced management accounting now
English: skills for learningThis course is for anybody who is thinking of studying for a university degree and would like to... Try: English: skills for learning now
The public policy – action relationship
Much literature on the public policy process focusses narrowly on the policy-making...
Much literature on the public policy process focusses narrowly on the policy-making part. This unit widens the focus to examine the implementation phase, and how change happens as a result of new policies: that is, policy – action relationship. It does this by looking at four different models of how this relationship can work through examples from varying fields. The unit will be of interest to public sector managers, their staff and the general reader.
After studying this unit you should be able to:
- understand the value of modelling the public policy – action relationship;
- explain the mechanical, organic, cultural and political models of the policy – action relationship.
- Current section: Introduction
- Learning outcomes
- 1 Models of implementation
- 2 The models in action: what counts is what works?
- 3 Governance, policy and action
- 4 The public policy-action relationship: activities
- 5 Conclusion
Study this free course
Enrol to access the full course, get recognition for the skills you learn and track your progress. Make your learning visible!
The public policy-action relationship
Most of the literature on the policy process focuses on how policy is made: the processes of negotiation and bargaining that take place, the struggle between rationality and politics, and the tension between ‘top-down’ and ‘bottom-up’ approaches. This unit is concerned with a rather different set of dynamics: the relationship between policy and what actually happens in the process of delivery. Formal, sequential descriptions of the policy process relegate this phase to the idea of implementation, which some writers have termed the neglected afterthought in the policy cycle. It is a stage of the policy process that has received scant attention in academic circles, and one that has traditionally been of rather less interest to civil servants and other officials than the task of giving policy advice. This is in part because the status and career advancement of such officials tend to be linked to their closeness to ministers or other policy makers in the process of policy formulation, rather than to public services in the process of implementation and delivery. It is also because of the temporal and spatial dynamics of policy making. Policy formulation tends to take place in the corridors of power in capital cities or the head offices of public agencies, whereas implementation happens in what are often termed ‘the provinces’ or at ‘street level’. By the time a policy is being rolled out, those at the centre are already focusing on the next problem or policy innovation and staff may have moved on to an entirely different policy area. This has been neatly summarised in the subtitle of one book, which sets out to explain ‘How great expectations in Washington are dashed in Oakland; or, why it's amazing that Federal programs work at all’ (Pressman and Wildavsky, 1973). Yet, clearly, implementation is crucial to the success of any policy.
Political success for governments and for individual ministers or political leaders – and even sometimes for chief executives of agencies – tends to be viewed in terms of being seen to do something, whether launching an initiative, introducing a new policy or responding to a problem, rather than looking back and perhaps learning from the mistakes of past policies.
For these reasons, among others, this unit is not concerned with technical questions about policy instruments and levers, but with a deeper question: how does change happen as a result of new policies? The aim is to explore the relationship between policy and action – in other words, the interconnection between a new policy and any shifts in the practice or relationships that shape the ways in which public services are delivered. This theme is explored by introducing a number of models. It is important for managers to become ‘multi-lingual’, be able to use different models in order to describe and explain what is happening and to learn from the process in order to improve practice. Learning to use multiple models will also help you to understand the implicit frameworks of explanation drawn on by others that you come into contact with – such as your partner organisations, those you have contracting relationships with, members of your governing body or board, other team members – and so improve communication and mutual understanding.
This material is from our archive and is an adapted extract from Shaping public policy: contexts and processes (B856) which is no longer taught by The Open University. If you want to study formally with us, you may wish to explore other courses we offer in this.
This is an extract from an Open University course which is no longer available to new students. If you found this interesting you could explore more free Business Studies courses or view the range of currently available OU Business Studies courses.
Copyright & revisions
Originally published: Thursday, 21st July 2011
- Creative-Commons: The Open University is proud to release this free course under a Creative Commons licence. However, any third-party materials featured within it are used with permission and are not ours to give away. These materials are not subject to the Creative Commons licence. See terms and conditions. Full details can be found in the Acknowledgements section.
- This site has Copy Reuse Tracking enabled - see our FAQs for more information.
If you enjoyed this, why not follow a feed to find out when we have new things like it? Choose an RSS feed from the list below. (Don't know what to do with RSS feeds?)
Remember, you can also make your own, personal feed by combining tags from around OpenLearn.