Will a makeover help Avon?

Updated Thursday 2nd November 2006

The success of Avon rests on addressing some key questions.

Avon competes in a global industry which, according to estimates from Datamonitor, was worth $120 billion in 2002. Avon, which was perhaps one of the first global cosmetics companies, is now overshadowed by industry leaders such as L’Oreal and Procter & Gamble. These companies are over three times the size of Avon when measured by turnover.

The Money Programme 'Avon’s Still Calling', highlights the very different set of competitive forces the company faces now, compared to those it faced when it was founded. Competitors have grown in number, diversity and financial power. Meanwhile, the demographics, preferences and brand awareness of consumers have changed. Avon lipsticks Creative commons image Icon Mundoo under CC-BY-NC-ND licence under Creative-Commons license Lipstick traces: Avon samplers

'Avon’s Still Calling' also raises concerns about the company’s strategic response to these competitive forces. Can its cost and revenue structure and business model deliver a sustainable long-term profit? Yet the major problem identified is the lack of any retail presence. Avon relies too much on the direct selling channel.

The success of Avon rests on addressing some key questions. Some commentators have talked about the idea of “retail theatres”, outlets that offer the consumer a shopping experience rather than just an opportunity to buy the product. Would creating such a distribution channel be feasible?

Could the company generate the revenues and afford the costs associated with such a shift? If it went ahead, would Avon apply this model in all of its markets or just where its market share is static or declining?

Perhaps, and even more importantly, would they be trying to copy their major competitors? Most writers on strategy argue that “me too” strategies don’t work. You may copy a competitor’s approach, but your resources (money, brand and people) are setup in a different way.

For example, some traditional booksellers such as Blackwell in the UK and Borders in the USA launched online bookstores to compete with Amazon. However, a key source of Amazon’s advantage is their proprietary software. The competition just didn’t have the expertise or resource to successfully replicate this, and thus their online activities floundered.

Avon’s trying to improve brand awareness by increasing advertising spend and other activities, for example through its sponsorship of ITV’s Footballers’ Wives. It’s also addressed its product range and introduced internet selling.

However, the basic question remains: should Avon seek to imitate its largest rivals such as L’Oreal? Or should it take advantage of the unique capabilities and model it's developed over many years?

Avon’s model has allowed it to succeed in overseas and emerging markets (75% of turnover comes from outside the US) and to sustain profit performance. One way to expand the current model would be to sell additional products through their direct selling channel.

So far Avon has chosen to make changes within the current model. Will these be enough? Avon will need to blend strategic management thinking and thorough industry knowledge if it’s to continue calling!

Further reading

  • Avon’s Still Calling – Avon’s share price is falling and the company’s out to reinvent itself. The Money Programme discovers what it’s got up its sleeve.
  • Competitive advantage – how can companies ensure they've got a lead over their competitors?
  • Securing your brand – how do you build value into a brand? More to the point, how do you preserve that value?
  • The world's top beauty companies
  • Contemporary Strategy Analysis by Robert Grant, published by Blackwell
 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Online retailers that have made their mark Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Yuri Arcurs | Dreamstime.com article icon

Money & Business 

Online retailers that have made their mark

Profiles of four high street retailers who each blazed a trail online.

Article
The Life Story of Your T-Shirt: Consumers Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license article icon

Money & Business 

The Life Story of Your T-Shirt: Consumers

Your t-shirt goes through a lot when you're wearing it. What's the story of yours? What happens to your t-shirts when you're done with them?

Article
Heathrow under pressure Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team video icon

Money & Business 

Heathrow under pressure

While producing 'Heathrow: Ready for Take Off?', the Money Programme interviewed key people with views on the expansion of the airport. Here you can watch extended versions of several interviews.

Video
10 mins
The five billion dollar franchise: How much will Disney make from Star Wars merchandise Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Bucz article icon

Money & Business 

The five billion dollar franchise: How much will Disney make from Star Wars merchandise

The launch of the toys from the forthcoming Star Wars film was an event in its own right. How much money are Disney going to make from all this stuff?

Article
Recession and small firms: Bad news good? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Flynt | Dreamstime.com article icon

Money & Business 

Recession and small firms: Bad news good?

For some, a recession can be a shock to the marketplace or it can unleash new opportunities.

Article
UKTI Export & The British Council Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: UKTI article icon

Money & Business 

UKTI Export & The British Council

The companies featured in Theo's Adventure Capitalists were lucky to be able to draw on Theo's years of experience. But there's a source of exporting advice and support available to everybody.

Article
Planning a project Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Money & Business 

Planning a project

Gantt charts, critical path analysis, SMART objectives and estimation skills are just some of the topics covered in this free course, Planning a project, to help you understand how to plan for a project. You will gain an appreciation of the range of planning techniques available and the situations in which it is appropriate to use them.

Free course
8 hrs
Britain's oldest family businesses: Further insights Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Money & Business 

Britain's oldest family businesses: Further insights

What are the challenges facing the small and medium-sized businesses of today? We have brought together experts to look at how businesses can survive and what they can learn from history.

Article
Lifecycle of the Car Industry Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission article icon

Money & Business 

Lifecycle of the Car Industry

PY Gerbeau discusses 'The Lifecycle of the Car Industry' in the BBC/Open University's Rules of the Game.

Article