Private equity

Updated Tuesday 5th June 2007

All private equity investors have to do is to buy a company, load it with debt, and benefit from reduced tax bills. The stakeholders who pay for this are a country’s taxpayers.

'The AA; Rescue or Wrong Turn?' highlights the advantages of private equity to at least some stakeholders. Whilst the private equity takeover of the AA has not been a good experience for all employees, or even customers, private equity investors have already got their investment capital back, and are looking forward to billions of pounds of profit when they sell the AA on. How did they do it? Model AA Van Creative commons image Icon kenjonbro under CC-BY-NC licence under Creative-Commons license A model AA van from 1963, when the company was owned by its members

Firstly, by taking advantage of the glut of money around the world. Banks are falling over themselves to lend money, at ultra-low interest rates and with no strings attached. And the private equity firms do not even need to have a good credit rating. They secure the debt they borrow on the assets of the companies they buy. With pre-determined debt interest costs, any increase in profits from reducing staff numbers, for example, goes straight to the private equity investors.

But there is another reason why private equity is a ‘no brainer’. Debt interest payments, and not equity dividends, are tax deductible for corporation tax purposes. All private equity investors have to do is to buy a company, load it with debt, and benefit from reduced tax bills. The stakeholders who pay for this are a country’s taxpayers. Lower corporation tax receipts usually mean higher taxes elsewhere. This has had such a major impact that some countries have changed their tax laws.

For example, the private equity purchase of the main Danish telecoms operator, TDC, in early 2006 for 13bn euros (with a special dividend of nearly half that paid to private equity investors less than six months later) was 90% debt funded. It is estimated that this private equity financing alone has reduced Danish corporation tax revenues by more than 12%, and the recent private equity takeover of Danish cleaning company, ISS, will have made matters even worse for the Danish government – and for Danish taxpayers. The Danes are currently conducting a review of the tax deductibility of debt payments. And the German government is reforming its corporation tax rules, also with a view to limiting the tax deductibility of debt. However, Ed Balls, Economic Secretary to the UK Treasury, said recently that the government had no plans to review the tax deductibility of debt principle as far as UK-based firms were concerned.

This tax game is nothing new. Leveraged buyouts in the 1980s aimed to exploit exactly the same tax relief. That boom ended when interest rates went sky high, and a recession meant interest payments had no profits against which to be offset. If interest rates go up this time, or if there is a recession, we will experience a sense of déjà vu. But the secretive nature of private equity companies will make it much harder to find out exactly who is bearing the pain this time around.

Further reading

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Osborne can fashion a fragile win from his Autumn Statement, but savers are sacrificed Creative commons image Icon Gary Edwards under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Osborne can fashion a fragile win from his Autumn Statement, but savers are sacrificed

Was the Autumn Statement an example of principled economics as a well as clever politics?

Article
Starbucks in the Star Chamber Creative commons image Icon Catherine Pain under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Starbucks in the Star Chamber

Starbucks and others were able to rebuff attempts to pillory them over their tax payments. This suggests that regulators still lack the power to keep private enterprise aligned with public interests, writes Alan Shipman.

Article
How to make investment decisions Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC video icon

Money & Business 

How to make investment decisions

To invest or not to invest? Jon Moulton shares stories of success and failure from his life as an investor of private equity.

Video
5 mins
article icon

Money & Business 

The language of private capital

The rise of the private equity firms may not necessarily be a bad thing, but on the other hand, the idea of using one language for business may not necessarily be a good thing.

Article
Evan Davis on... financial innovation Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Jupiter Images audio icon

Money & Business 

Evan Davis on... financial innovation

Evan Davis from The Bottom Line gives us his view on financial innovation.

Audio
5 mins
Getting a good deal Creative commons image Icon HK-DMZ under CC-BY-NC-SA licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Money & Business 

Getting a good deal

Price comparison sites can take the strain out of shopping in more ways than one, as Gabriel Reedy discovers first hand

Article
Valuing brand assets Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Money & Business 

Valuing brand assets

Peter Walton explores the complexities of putting a value on a brand

Article
How much attention should companies pay to their share price? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: photos.com article icon

Money & Business 

How much attention should companies pay to their share price?

Janette Rutterford explains why share prices have been up and down so much recently - and if it matters.

Article
Saving time and pennies: Comparison websites considered Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team video icon

Money & Business 

Saving time and pennies: Comparison websites considered

Martyn Hocking from Which? magazine looks at the advantages of price comparison sites. Can you trust the sites to always find the best deal - and why should you approach their results with caution?

Video
5 mins