Skip to content

Extinctions at World Heritage Sites aren't just environmental disasters

Updated Thursday 1st June 2017

As species vanish at alarming rates from protected areas, the impact goes beyond loss of diversity.  Emilio Rodríguez Mega reports.

El Arco, Cabo San Lucas, Baja California Sur Creative commons image Icon Kirt Edblom under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license El Arco, part of the protected coast at the Baja California Sur

Poaching, illegal fishing and deforestation are threatening more than quarter of UNESCO’s World Heritage sites, according to a report by the WWF  (World Wide Fund for Nature) — and the consequences are not just environmental.

The report states that 18 out of the 50 threatened sites are in Latin American countries such as Argentina, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Honduras, Panama and Peru. It also says the number could be higher because the illegal extraction of species in the region — a business with annual profits of almost US$ 2 billion — is not as well studied as it is in Africa or Asia.

In 2016, WWF reported that biodiversity declined 60 per cent on average between 1970 and 2012, and that illegal trade was one of the main engines of species loss.

The new report, published in April, warns that if this trend continues, a new wave of extinctions will begin, especially since many of these World Heritage Sites are shelters for endangered plants and animals.

This is the case already in the islands and protected areas of the Gulf of California, in Mexico, which harbour the remaining population of 30 marine vaquitas. Illegal fishing for totoaba, a fish species protected by the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Flora and Fauna (CITES), is the main cause of the vaquita’s decline.

“Many vaquitas fall into nets that are illegally placed for [fishing] totoaba", says Andrés Cisneros Montemayor, resource economist at the University of British Columbia, Canada. "And Asian demand represents a huge incentive for totoaba overfishing. As long as it continues, this problem will not end".

But besides the environmental impact of illegal species extraction, these activities also harm the people living in affected regions. In Belize, for example, illegal fishing combined with pollution and uncontrolled coastal development have damaged the marine-protected areas and reef system on which some 200,000 people depend — almost half of Belizeans.

Nadia Bood, a marine biologist at WWF-Belize, warns that populations of some fish, lobsters and molluscs have declined dramatically in recent years, leaving local fishermen and traders with less stock to sell. “It's a constant battle” she says. “Unless NGOs, society and government work together, we will not see a major change”.

This article was originally published by SciDevNet under a CC-BY licence


For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

World Heritage Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 2 icon

History & The Arts 

World Heritage

This free course provides an overview of World Heritage, its political and cultural origins and the role of UNESCO and other agencies in identifying and listing sites. It identifies and discusses with exemplification the major conventions and protocols affecting World Heritage. It shows how World Heritage expanded from cultural to natural and other sites, as well as embracing landscapes, and intangible and industrial heritages. It provides case studies of New Lanark as industrial heritage, Bath and Edinburgh as World Heritage Cities, and the Tarragona archaeological and historical ensemble as a driver of economic change in the development of cultural tourism. It also contains an audio case study exploring the Lake District World Heritage bid.

Free course
10 hrs
OU on the BBC: Saving Species: Series 3, Episode 9 Creative commons image Icon Baylands bird watcher / Don DeBold / CC BY 2.0 under Creative-Commons license article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on the BBC: Saving Species: Series 3, Episode 9

The Saving Species team explores the growing phenomenon of citizen science.

OU on the BBC: Saving Species: Series 3, Episode 3 Creative commons image Icon Bombus sylvarum / Alain C. / CC BY-NC-SA 2.0 under Creative-Commons license article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on the BBC: Saving Species: Series 3, Episode 3

Can Britain's wildlife flourish in the face of constant pressures of land development? The Saving Species team investigate


History & The Arts 

World Archaeology

How do archaeologists investigate and understand ancient sites and civilisations? Interpreting archaeological evidence accurately and methodically is the key to obtaining a critical perspective on the development of the human race. This album provides an introduction to archaeology and its methodologies for excavation of sites that can be more than 12000 years old. Like piecing together a jigsaw puzzle but without a picture guide, archaeologists can establish how cities and civilisations developed, why humans started farming, and how empires formed and collapsed. This material forms part of The Open University course A251 World archaeology.

1 hr
The unseen world Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Thinkstock audio icon

Nature & Environment 

The unseen world

In an extended interview recorded by the Saving Species team, biodiversity advocate, Aaron Bernstein, talks about the wonders of the microbial world and how it redefines our understanding of life.

15 mins

Science, Maths & Technology 

Darwinian Demons

Is 'natural selection' inimical to bio-diversity? Why is the natural world not dominated by a few 'super' species? And in the future, can the richness of nature be preserved? In this album, Jonathan Silvertown, Professor of Ecology at The Open University, explains how Darwinian theory uses the concept of niche specialisation to account for the diversity of flora and fauna on Earth. If it were not for environmental niches, Darwinian 'demons', might emerge, powerful species whose evolutionary fitness makes them all conquering. However, according to Darwin, the natural world is infinitely complex and inhabited by a multitude of different species, each of which is peculiarly adapted to its local environment. The tracks on this album were produced by The Open University in collaboration with the British Council. They form part of Darwin Now, a global initiative celebrating the life and work of Charles Darwin and the impact his ideas about evolution continue to have on today’s world. © British Council 2009.

25 mins
Amphibians in decline Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Nature & Environment 

Amphibians in decline

Tim Halliday asks whether the sixth great extinction is being foreshadowed by amphibians in decline?

Global exploitation and the reptile trade Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Nature & Environment 

Global exploitation and the reptile trade

Tim Halliday looks at the trade in reptiles and asks whether it is having a detrimental effect on some species

Human impacts on the lives of animals Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Nature & Environment 

Human impacts on the lives of animals

Tim Halliday explores the human impact upon animals