Skip to content
Society, Politics & Law

Why don’t Londoners remember 7/7 like New York remembers 9/11?

Updated Tuesday 7th July 2015

New York and London both honour those lost in terror attacks - but remember in very different ways. Victor Seidler suggests the difference in the attacks may explain why.

Emergency services outside Russell Square on 7/7/05 Creative commons image Icon Francis Tyers under CC-BY-SA licence under Creative-Commons license Emergency services outside Russell Square Tube on 7th July 2005 London is marking ten years since the attacks of July 7 2005, in which 52 people were killed and more than 700 injured by a group of suicide bombers. But far from being “London’s 9/11”, Britain remembers its terror attack rather differently to the US.

While the US spent many years after 2001 contemplating its place in the world – and indeed seeking to export its idea of democracy to other countries, the British were forced to look inward at their own culture. The government of the time was heavily involved in the same War on Terror as the US, but this was a homegrown attack that required a homegrown response.

Taken aback

The 2001 terrorist attack on the World Trade Center in New York and the Pentagon near Washington DC seemed to come out of nowhere. The attacks struck central symbols of US global power and cut deep into the American psyche. Many suddenly felt unsafe in their own country.

The events raised fundamental questions about what it means to be an American citizen and in some ways brought the country together after the deep divisions of the Vietnam War.

Analogies were made with Pearl Harbour, since this was an unprovoked attack by a foreign enemy. But for a while, 9/11 also closed down intellectual discussions about the exercise of America’s global power and the causes of terror, as if talking about these issues was somehow to condone what had happened that day.

Up until that moment, war and ethnic conflict was what happened elsewhere. Now the US was at the centre of a new world of global terror. Though many were sceptical at the time, 9/11 did become a watershed moment in the West. It was as if everyone in the US could see themselves as a target, and their sense of security was shattered once and for all. This shaped the way 9/11 was to be remembered and memorialised.

There was a moment of pause. People reflected upon how the US, which was supposed to bring good into the world, could be hated so much that it could be so violently attacked.

The vigils and reflection were soon put aside. President George W Bush, driven by heroic masculinity, was to seek revenge in Afghanistan and Iraq. You were with the US or against it.

A different kind of shock

By 2005, many felt it was only a matter of time before London was hit. After Bali and Madrid and, indeed, New York, London seemed an obvious target, particularly given Britain’s involvement in the Iraq War.

This was not an attack that came out of nowhere. It was already several years into the War on Terror, and people were already concerned about whether the motives for invading Iraq and Afghanistan were just.

This was also a city already accustomed to the threat of terrorist attack. The IRA bombing campaigns of the 1980s and 90s had shaped London life to a certain extent.

But what was long-lasting was the realisation that the young men who had taken so many lives on 7/7 had been brought up in Britain – three of the four attackers were British born and the fourth an early migrant.

They declared war on the UK in homemade videos released after the bombings. This helped create a different kind of remembering. The separate lives being lived by different communities in the UK had been made visible. There were questions about second-generation experiences and a lack of integration between communities.

The London Olympics of 2012 brought a moment of healing, as the city embraced the spirit of multiculturalism – but more recent events have awoken the memories of 7/7.

Because it was young British men who took so many lives in London that day, there are complex feelings about what it is to be British. But where the Americans thought about their own national identity on the global stage, the UK was interrogating relations at home. Young nationals were identifying more with sufferings in foreign lands than with their fellow citizens, and no-one appeared to have noticed.

A decade on, more young men have been lost to the idealism of radical groups abroad. They are fighting in Syria and Iraq but the same questions are being asked back home.

When British values are invoked, they need to be values that can be shared by young British Muslims. We need to remember 7/7 as a warning of what can happen when young men feel bereft of a sense of belonging.

The Conversation

Victor Seidler is Emeritus Professor of Social Theory at Goldsmiths, University of London.

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Hospital: After the terrorist attack Creative commons image Icon trolvag under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license video icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Hospital: After the terrorist attack

The day of the Westminster Bridge terror attack, the team making the BBC/OU co-production Hospital were filming in St Mary's Hospital. Watch some of the activity as medical crews responded to the developing incident.

Video
10 mins
OpenLearn Live: 29th July 2016 Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Imperial War Museum article icon

History & The Arts 

OpenLearn Live: 29th July 2016

The buses that went to the front.

Article
Armistice Day Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Luckynick | Dreamstime.com article icon

History & The Arts 

Armistice Day

The armistice which marked the end of the First World War took effect at 11am on 11th November 1918. For Remembrance Day, here's a collection of resources to commemorate and remember these events.

Article
OU on the BBC: The Somme - From Defeat To Victory Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on the BBC: The Somme - From Defeat To Victory

Was The Somme as much a disaster as history records? This BBC/OU co-produced drama investigates.

Article
War lands home: homeland debts & credits Creative commons image Icon Army.mil, some rights reserved under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

War lands home: homeland debts & credits

Can we blame the recession on the cost of the war on terror? Engin Isin considers how they are related

Article
OU on the BBC: Civil War - About the series Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Wark Clements article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on the BBC: Civil War - About the series

The English Civil War was part of a wider struggle for supremacy between Catholics and Protestants in Europe.

Article
What if...: Changing the course of history Creative commons image Icon cheesy42 under CC-BY licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

What if...: Changing the course of history

 A spell of pondering what might have been lead to The Things We Forgot To Remember

Article
Beyond the slaughter and loss of the First World War Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

History & The Arts 

Beyond the slaughter and loss of the First World War

Michael Portillo asks why we only think of slaughter and loss when we recall the Great War.

Article
The Things We Forgot To Remember - World War One Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

The Things We Forgot To Remember - World War One

As part of the Things We Forgot To Remember series, Michael Portillo investigated why we only think of slaughter and loss when we recall the Great War

Article