Science, Maths & Technology

The information economy

Updated Wednesday 6th August 2008

The Open Minds programme explores the information economy.

Serving a stable society? A waiter Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: photos.com

Meet the participants

John Monk

John Monk is Professor of Electronics at the Open University with an interest in the philosophy, sociology, aesthetics and ethics of technology. He is a Chartered Engineer and has worked in a number of European telecommunications and engineering companies.

Paul Taylor

Paul Taylor is the IT Correspondent for the Financial Times. His twenty years on the paper began after working on various local papers in London and the South East. Before becoming IT correspondent he reported largely on foreign issues, which involved postings to New York and Bangkok, and spent three years covering stories on UK IT companies.

John Higgins

John Higgins is the Director General of the Computing Services Software Association.

About the discussion

We store it, we mine it, we harvest it. Not a natural resource, but information – the key to the digital revolution.

Will the growing trade in information create a social divide between those who are informed and those who are not?

John Monk says that there is a danger that a divide will develop in society between those who use the Internet for buying and selling and financial services and those who don’t. People who don’t have or can’t afford access will be disadvantaged, and with this in mind we should take measures to ensure the technology is more inclusive.

Paul Taylor suggests that the information underclass should be angry about this state of affairs – access to information should be a right and should be seen as such even more strongly in the future. It is very important that the Internet is supplied through universities, colleges, cafés, shopping centres and other public places. Digital television and its successors will hopefully help to close the gap and make access less dependent on personal computers.

John Higgins says that people shouldn’t get angry – they should get even. We often underestimate people’s ability to get hold of information. The government need to take strong measures to make new products accessible and user-friendly – if they don’t, people won’t use them, industry will step in and provide products that people want at prices they are willing to pay.

There is an increasing amount of information being gathered from us without our knowledge – store cards and Internet sites for example. Should we be concerned?

Paul Taylor believes that concern over our increasing lack of privacy is very valid and will shortly become a hot issue. For example, most people don’t realise that in the City of London you’re on a camera 95 per cent of the time. What we used to consider our personal lives is no longer personal.

John Monk suggests that it is a difficult balancing act - we install technology to bring benefits but we sometimes get over enthusiastic because of these benefits and gloss over the problems. We need to be more critical of the technology and take responsibility for being better informed as individuals.

Many new technologies monitor what we use and give us more of it. Does this narrow our horizons and our ability to discover new things?

John Monk argues that people often try to divorce politics from technology but communications of all sorts are used for control. It is important to look at technology more critically because of the political content.

How robust are the industries based on rapidly changing new technologies?

John Higgins suggests that the whole industry is not robust, but it is very adaptable. It can change with the times, listen to consumers and adapt quickly. In fact, the very nature of the technology allows us to do this – there are no large investments in machinery, bricks and mortar. However, companies rise and fall very easily – small mistakes can have big repercussions.

Paul Taylor suggests that the industry is still in its teenage years. It is by nature moving fast and changing all the time, but this is a positive attribute and we should not be surprised. One danger is that the industry still talks about the boxes and the machinery as being the most important thing – it hasn’t yet learned that people are more interested in what the machinery can do, what problems it can solve.

John Higgins says that it’s always been the case that all industries focus on what they know. It’s natural that many people in the industry still focus on what they’re delivering.

Control of these new technologies seems to be concentrated in the hands of a few powerful individuals. How can we take power back?

John Higgins suggests that access to the media has been in the hands of a small group of distributors. We now have a situation where a huge variety of people are distributing services to anyone who chooses to make that information available to them. There is still wealth in the hands of a few providers of the technology, but the technology is available to everyone.

Paul Taylor agrees - information gives people power. The Internet, for example, makes it much easier to access information about goods and services. There is a definite move to disintermediation – taking out the middle man. However, there should be some kind of contract between the supplier of personal details and the consumer of these details, which we very often don’t have at the moment.

John Monk says that there has always been the danger that authoritarian regimes, for example, sustain their power through communications systems and there is the opportunity for individuals to gain huge amounts of power. However, it is not those distributing the information, but those censoring and managing it that we need to be wary of.

John Higgins disagrees. He argues that originally the broadcast media were being controlled so there was the opportunity for authoritarian states to manage the information. Now we don’t have those controls so any group can set up a web site and it can’t be censored. This does bring more opportunities, but there are dangers in the all-powerful consumer. Great changes in consumer trends can completely destroy industries almost over night.

John Monk counters that the anarchy of the Internet is largely to do with it being a teenage industry – it has yet to develop a political maturity. All sorts of technologies have been exploited for political purposes and the Internet will be no different.

Until recently up to 90 per cent of technology research was carried out by the military, now the bulk is funded by private business. Is this any more benign?

John Monk suggests that, while this culture may seem more altruistic, they have their own interests at heart. It is important to have suitable political systems in place if we are concerned about the degree of control we have over new developments.

John Higgins, however, believes that there is a difference – the paymasters of the military are the political controllers while the paymasters of business are you and me. If they don’t deliver what we want we will buy someone else’s product.

Should we expect to see an increase in cyber terrorism, such as the use of computer viruses to completely stymie a whole country?

John Higgins says that the governments of the USA and the UK are extremely concerned about the vulnerability of our underlying infrastructures. Their biggest challenge, after the Millennium Bug, is protecting this critical infrastructure. It will be in the news before long.

John Monk points out that it has already been in the news. There have been worldwide cases of individuals attacked organisations with the ‘ping of death’ – flooding their systems so that no other communications can get through.

Paul Taylor agrees. He says it is a classic iceberg – we only hear about a fraction of the attacks. It doesn’t only concern military targets and industrial espionage, it is a huge and growing problem. It is a fine balance between those determined to profit and those charged with blocking their attempts – the task is to remain one step ahead of the bad guys.

Are we only four meals away from anarchy?

All three guests agree that this is an alarmist statement, but it may well be right.

John Monk offers hope in that because we’re alarmed we are prompted to take counter measures, but that may not be enough.

Take if further

The Digital Economy, Don Tapscott (McGraw Hill, London)

Digital Delirium, Arthur and Marilouise Kroker (eds) (New World Perspectives, Montreal)

If you’d like to explore the natural world as well as the one we have built, why not investigate Open University biology courses?

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Connecting: Connecting with drama Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Connecting: Connecting with drama

We explore how Radio 4's Connecting series dramatises the opportunities and risks of modern communication technologies

Article
Man vs machine Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Man vs machine

Should we worry about robots one day getting tired of being the junior partners?

Article
Learning to swim in murky seas: Exploitation of the Electorate via Social Media Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: rawpixel article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Learning to swim in murky seas: Exploitation of the Electorate via Social Media

Learn psychological self-defence and start resisting the dark arts of political communication, in Volker Patent’s second article on Brexit and the General Election

Article
Has media literacy become self-destructive? Creative commons image Icon 1uffster (Jeanie) under Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0 license article icon

Education & Development 

Has media literacy become self-destructive?

Danah Boyd, founder of Data & Society, asks if American society has become too distrustful of experts

Article
Finding information in technology Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Finding information in technology

As part of a review of content, this course will be deleted from OpenLearn on 18 May 2017. If you are interested in similar courses, go to the 'Skills' tab and look under 'Skills for Study'. The internet provides a world of information, but how do you find what you are looking for? This free course, Finding information in technology, will help you discover the meaning of information quality and teach you how to evaluate the material you come across in your study of technology. You will learn how to plan your searches effectively and be able to experiment with some of the key resources in this area.

Free course
9 hrs
Key skill assessment unit: Information technology Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Key skill assessment unit: Information technology

Skills in information technology (IT) cover a broad range, from using software packages effectively to developing a critical understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of IT solutions. Developing your IT skills means planning your work, practising your skills, seeking feedback from others and reviewing your approach. In this free course, Key skill assessment: Information technology, you will learn to use and adapt your skills effectively and confidently in different situations and contexts.

Free course
50 hrs
Information technology: A new era? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 2 icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Information technology: A new era?

Do the advances in information technology equate to a new industrial revolution? The advances made by IBM, Dell and many other manufacturers have resulted in massive changes to our working lives. This free course, Information technology: A new era?, looks at whether it is possible to predict the future of this industry by comparing it to the development of the automobile industry in the USA.

Free course
15 hrs
Download your free 'Digital Technology Past and Present' information pack Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Download your free 'Digital Technology Past and Present' information pack

Download your free information pack on 'Digital Technology Past and Present' to accompany the BBC Make it Digital season.

Article
Ourproject.org Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Ourproject.org article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Ourproject.org

Free software and free knowledge for a free society.

Article