Skip to content
Science, Maths & Technology

Globalised innovation: One size fits all?

Updated Friday 6th July 2007

A one world approach can lead to one size fits all results, warns Tom Hewitt in his response to Lord Broer's third Reith Lecture.

This lecture hasn’t really stimulated my imagination nor my excitement about technology.

To the contrary, it has brought out the pessimist in me. You cannot take exception to much of what is said, not at least about the kinds of industries and the kinds of technologies referred to by the speaker.

But the result is flat; an almost monochrome portrayal of how things have to be done.

The recurring examples used – air travel, computers, mobile phones, pharmaceuticals, etc – result in a one-model-fits-all approach to innovation.

A model where international sourcing and markets are prerequisites for competitiveness. National competitiveness is no competition at all.

This is Harold Wilson’s ‘white heat of technology’ gone global.

I don’t dispute this as a description of certain elements of the global economy.

The Foxlink factory, China [Image: DCMaster under CC-BY-NC licence] Creative commons image Icon DCMaster via Flickr under Creative-Commons license
Foxlink facotry, China [Image: DCMaster under CC-BY-NC licence]

However, it implies a model of development where only global players survive resulting in ever more uniform products, ever more concentration of economic power, and an ever more precarious existence for the majority of technology producers.

It is the technological equivalent of the predictable monotony of the retailers found in every UK high street.

In the first lecture, Alec Broers boldly said that technology will determine the future of the human race. Now he describes how technology drives international competitiveness.

This is naïve.

Technology plays a part but international competition is also determined by less savoury practices - transfer pricing, tax havens, contract bribes (aka industrial lobbying), poorly paid and unrepresented labour; all the trappings of that old-style capitalism that Broers says has now passed.

And to cap it all, this ‘fast moving and ultra-competitive world’ is fuelled, according to the speaker, by paranoid, stressed out, macho survivors who will stop at nothing to get their products to market.

Stop the world, I’m getting off!

More responses to this lecture

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

What Brexit and Trump mean for Global Justice and International Development Creative commons image Icon Gage Skidmore under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

What Brexit and Trump mean for Global Justice and International Development

Brexit and Donald Trump appear to drive global justice and international development efforts into unchartered waters says Professor Theo Papaioannou. 

Article
Working with our environment: an introduction Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Nature & Environment 

Working with our environment: an introduction

Global warming: are we responsible? Is our environmental impact damaging the planet? This free course, Working with our environment: an introduction, examines the use of ozone-depleting technology, the impact of fossil fuel use and explores how the development of technology can influence the direction of a society. From the Industrial Revolution to the present day, find out how we have changed the planet.

Free course
11 hrs
article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Technology and light - International Year of Light

Free learning resources in technology, relating to light, as part of The Open University's International Year of Light celebrations.

Article
The Open University and The International Year of Light Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

The Open University and The International Year of Light

The Open University  is a “Gold Associate Sponsor” for the International Year of Light & Light Based Technology 2015

Article

Society, Politics & Law 

Technology, networks and international order

How have technological change and the rise in organised networks affected international order? William Brown, Senior Lecturer in Government and Politics, is joined by fellow Open University lecturers Dr Simon Bromley and Dr Helen Yanacopulos to investigate the key issues through recent events such as the 'Jubilee 2000 debt campaign’ and the financial crisis of 2008, along with a look at traditional political ideals such as Marxism and Capitalism. This material forms part of The Open University course DU301 A world of whose making?

Audio
25 mins

Society, Politics & Law 

Global response to the financial crisis

What caused the financial crisis of 2007-9 and the recession that followed? How did governments and the international banking system respond? Senior Lecturer William Brown is joined by three course team members to address the key issues that emerged as a result of the financial crisis and what it reveals about shifts in the international system. The album also explores how the principles of game theory could be applied to regulating complex financial problems. This material forms part of The Open University course DU301 A world of whose making?

Audio
35 mins
Truth Will Out: Global Warming - viewers respond Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Truth Will Out: Global Warming - viewers respond

What did the public have to say about the issue of global warming? Take a look at the comments we received.

Article
Reith 2007: Bursting at the Seams - Survival in the Anthropocene Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Reith 2007: Bursting at the Seams - Survival in the Anthropocene

Dr Stephen Peake responds to the 2007 Reith lecture by Jeffery Sachs on 'Survival in the Anthropocene'

Article
The climateprediction.net story Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Nature & Environment 

The climateprediction.net story

As the results are announced, we look back at the rollercoaster ride of the experiment. Bob Spicer tells the climateprediction.net story

Article