Skip to content
Science, Maths & Technology

Silicon fen or silicon when?

Updated Thursday 23rd October 2008

Nigel Walton looks at why technology companies struggle to do well in Europe.

In the first blog in this series I discussed the lamentable failure of Europe and the UK to develop start-up companies into large gorilla-sized organisations similar to American companies such as Microsoft, Intel, Apple, Oracle and Google. Apart from a few recent exceptions, such as Vodafone, Nokia and SAP, Europe and the UK have lagged far behind. A number of plausible reasons why UK and European technology companies have failed to become world-beaters on the same scale as their US counterparts have been forwarded and include:

  • A lack of appropriate funding and tax arrangements
  • The absence of a large homogeneous home market
  • An inability to bring products rapidly to market
  • A lack of entrepreneurial culture and spirit
Doug Richard Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC
Doug Richard.

The current UK scenario, however, is not all doom and doom as the Cambridge University technology cluster, famously known as Silicon Fen, starts to come of age after thirty years of development. According to Doug Richard, founder and chairman of Library House and former judge on Dragon’s Den:

“The Cambridge cluster has just tipped over and a period of explosive growth is ahead. It manages to attract a very large quantity of capital without variation”. 

Cambridge has already spawned a number of successful £1bn companies such as Arm, Autonomy and CSR radio. So do we have a Silicon Valley in the making or is this simply California dreaming? If Silicon Fen is to provide a lead role in nurturing the next generation of “gorillas” there are still a number of obstacles in its way. For example:

  • There is a tendency for early stage entrepreneurs to exit their businesses through trade sales rather than undertaking a public flotation (this usually means selling-out to a larger US firm). According to Walter Herriot, head of St. John’s Innovation Centre in Cambridge: “If too many Cambridge companies are acquired by foreign companies the people and the intellectual property will disappear”.
  • There is a tendency for European venture capital groups to invest smaller sums than their US rivals. The differential can  sometimes be as high as 50%.
  • There is a failure of leading UK companies to invest in entrepreneurial start-ups. Cisco invests in start-up companies which benefit from the funding they receive whilst Cisco gains access to cutting-edge research.
  • There has been a failure on the part of European stock exchanges to attract young companies. Neither the LSE nor AIM are considered to be as attractive as the Nasdaq where new listings are able to achieve higher valuations.

Another way of interpreting the superior growth trajectory of US start-up companies is the American business culture itself. Europeans do not lack technical expertise (and Silicon Fen is living proof of this) but does Europe have the same level of ambition and attitude to risk as the USA? According to David Wither, CEO and founder of UK technology company Sarantel:

“In the US, you know from the start you are on your own. Nobody is going to look after you – there is no healthcare or safety net. It breeds a competitiveness, which is part of the culture.”

It might also be said that UK and European entrepreneurs are acting wisely by avoiding head-on competition with major organisations by adopting niche and complementary strategies, thereby avoiding conflict with larger rivals. This was a lesson that was learned by the pioneering UK personal computer companies such as Acorn, Sinclair and Apricot. Another interpretation is that by selling out early UK entrepreneurs are behaving in a totally rational manner. True serial entrepreneurs are good at starting and growing businesses but not well equipped to professionally manage them, so their early departure is not such a bad thing after all.

The problem is that they are not being acquired by other UK or European companies or as Walter Herriot, head of St. John’s Innovation Centre in Cambridge once commented: “I am slightly concerned that we are selling off the family silver”.

So should Europe be written off as a promising location for technology companies and is Silicon Fen really on hold until key obstacles are removed from the equation?

Cisco Pokemon Creative commons image Icon Thecameo under CC-BY-NC licence under Creative-Commons license
A CISCO Pokemon-style figure promoting the company in Cambridge

Further reading

  • 'Fen tries to be a valley' by Maija Pesola in the Financial Times on 16th Feb 2005
  • 'The fertile soil of Silicon Fen' by Maija Pesola in the Financial Times on 9th Feb 2005
  • 'Why progress requires ambition and risk' by Alan Cane in the Financial Times on 11th Feb 2005
 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

When technology is spurned, there is no development Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: OU article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

When technology is spurned, there is no development

The UK needs to get reacquainted with the idea of technology, says Nick Braithwaite in response to Lord Broers' first Reith Lecture.

Article
Rocket science Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Rocket science

Battle of the the Geeks' Ian Johnston takes us through the science which lifts rockets from launchpad to the skies. We start, though, by asking why buildings don't fall down

Article
Which way for digital democracy? Creative commons image Icon Donvanone under CC-BY-NC-ND licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Which way for digital democracy?

Ivan Horrocks asks whether social networking has distanced people from real world politics.

Article
Here's how we can save the car – and the planet at the same time Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: © | Dreamstime.com article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Here's how we can save the car – and the planet at the same time

Alexandre Rodrigues discusses how we can balance saving our most popular form of transportation and the planet we live on at the same time. 

Article
Collapse at Kinzua: Tornado Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team audio icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Collapse at Kinzua: Tornado

The collapse of the Kinzua Rail viaduct revealed what might be the crucial clue to solving an engineering mystery dating back to 1879. Part 2: Tornado

Audio
5 mins
Online lecture: Nanotechnology Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Online lecture: Nanotechnology

Professor Richard Jones discusses his experiences of exploring the social and ethical implications of nanotechnology, and the contribution scientists can make to the responsible development of science and technology.

Article
Should the NHS have been better prepared for the cyber-highwaymen? Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Edward Viles / British Library article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Should the NHS have been better prepared for the cyber-highwaymen?

The Wannacry malware attack which locked down vital systems throughout much of the NHS on Friday was preventable, explains Conor Deane-McKenna.

Article
Never mind the quality: Transcript Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Never mind the quality: Transcript

Where does the future of television look like heading? This full transcript of Digital Planet makes some predictions.

Article
Microelectronic solutions for digital photography Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Microelectronic solutions for digital photography

The human eye is a fascinating and complicated device, but how do digital cameras capture images? This free course, Microelectronic solutions for digital photography, examines one of the humanmachine interfaces that link optical information to the electronic world. You will learn how the components within a digital camera capture images for electronic manipulation.

Free course
4 hrs