Science, Maths & Technology

Emmy Noether: Bucking the historical trends

Updated Friday 11th May 2012

Mathematics isn't solely the pursuit of men. We should celebrate great thinkers like Emmy Noether and the superb work of women in mathematics today

Emmy Noether Creative commons image Icon Mathematical Association of America under CC BY-ND 2.0 licence under Creative-Commons license Emmy Noether

OU research student Harry Kennard places the spotlight on Emmy Noether, the female mathematician who bucked the historical trends suggesting women can't be mathematical geniuses.

Highlighting the achievements of women in mathematics

The Fields Medal is widely regarded as the most prestigious award someone can receive for mathematical work. Since it was introduced in 1936, it has been awarded to 52 people – all of whom have been men.

Of the 54 people employed as academic staff at the Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics in Cambridge, one of the world’s most prestigious places to undertake study in mathematics, only six are women.

At every stage of tertiary education, women are opting to work in sciences such as biology and medical sciences, rather than mathematics and physics.

Historically, women have not enjoyed educational equality. Indeed, Oxford only began awarding degrees to women in the 1920s. Even today the number of women receiving degrees in mathematics is half that of men.

In turn, this lack of access has seeded a widely held, but fallacious, view that men are inherently better skilled at numerate subjects.

Despite many studies into sex difference in mathematical ability, the differences have been found to be insignificant. Moreover, studies have shown that reminding women that men are 'better' at mathematics actually causes them to underperform.

This would suggest that it is largely social factors which determine how attractive mathematics is to women; if there is a wide perception that women cannot be mathematicians then they will not become mathematicians.

In order, therefore, to promote women in mathematics, it is extremely important to highlight the achievements of those who have bucked the historical trends.

One such woman whose life and work should be championed is Emmy Noether.

The work of Emmy Noether

Noether was born in Germany in 1882. She originally planned to teach French for a living, but instead opted to study mathematics.

At the time, this was extremely unusual, but despite many institutional obstacles to her studies she achieved a doctoral degree at the age of 25 from the University of Erlangen.

The usual postdoctoral path in Germany was denied to women at this time, but she was able to continue working in mathematics by helping her father—who was also a mathematician—with his research.

She became interested in the work of the famous mathematician, David Hilbert, and in 1916, was invited to work with him in Göttingen.

She was denied the chance to lecture by the university, and had to serve instead as his assistant.

Eventually the university allowed her to take up a formal position, and she was able to build upon her now sterling reputation.

She continued to work in Germany until she was forced to move to Bryn Mawr College in the United States, following her dismissal from Gottingen by the Nazis. She remained there for the rest of her life.

In her obituary, Einstein wrote, ‘In the judgment of the most competent living mathematicians, Fräulein Noether was the most significant creative mathematical genius thus far produced since the higher education of women began’.

Had she been allowed the same privileges that men enjoyed she would certainly be a household name like Einstein.

Noether's legacy

Noether's work still receives a great deal of attention from mathematicians and physicists alike.

One of her most famous results, known simply as 'Noether's Theorem', has been widely used in many fields of theoretical physics since it was published in 1918, and forms a cornerstone of much of the physics which is probed at the Large Hadron Collider at CERN.

In its most essential form, the theory says that for each continuous symmetry of a system we can always find a conserved quantity.

This means that if, after some transformation, the system looks the same, then there must be some measurable quantity that does not change.

Conserved quantities are common in physics, the most famous of which is energy, which cannot be created or destroyed.

It is Noether's theorem that relates this conservation law to the underlying symmetry of space itself – in fact, the conservation of energy is a result of the fact that empty space 'looks the same' from one moment to the next.

Put another way, if empty space were rough or lumpy, then energy would be lost as things moved through, but the fact that space is symmetric and smooth means that energy cannot be lost.

It is because of insights like this that Noether's life and work must be celebrated.

We have a lot to thank for the perseverance and genius of this remarkable thinker. It is through publicising her work, and the superb work of women in mathematics today that we can hope to debunk the myth that mathematics is solely the pursuit of men.

Find out more about Emmy Noether and other inspiring 'wonder women' in our interactive. 

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Penalised for caring? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Money & Business 

Penalised for caring?

Women are better off today in many ways. But there are still women who are penalised for choosing to care for others.

Article
Feminist History And Women's history Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

History & The Arts 

Feminist History And Women's history

Professor Anne Laurence explores women's role in the past in this article on feminist history.

Article
What pressures are young men feeling? Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: SplitShire article icon

Education & Development 

What pressures are young men feeling?

A rigid construct of what makes a "real man" is putting a strain on real young men, says new research.

Article
Why are Olympic athletes copping so much abuse? It all comes down to gender Creative commons image Icon André Zehetbauer under CC-BY-SA licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Why are Olympic athletes copping so much abuse? It all comes down to gender

Why is there so much gender discrimination in the Olympics? Helen Owton explores sexism and misconceptions about gender in sport. 

Article
10 incredible people whose stories you'll find on OpenLearn Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

History & The Arts 

10 incredible people whose stories you'll find on OpenLearn

We're ten this year - isn't that amazing? What's even more amazing is this list of ten extraordinary people and their incredible stories...

Article
What do sports authorities have to do to take account of transgender competitors? Creative commons image Icon Santeri Viinamäki under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license video icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

What do sports authorities have to do to take account of transgender competitors?

Transgender people are now able to compete at the Olympics - but there are some who worry this might create opportunities for cheating. Katharina Lindner explores the questions.

Video
5 mins
Returning to STEM: Register your interest Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Monkey Business Images | Dreamstime.com article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Returning to STEM: Register your interest

Get a preview of our new course, Returning to STEM, and sign up to be notified when it launches.

Article
Postgraduate study skills in science, technology or mathematics Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Education & Development 

Postgraduate study skills in science, technology or mathematics

Are you about to undertake a PhD in science, technology or mathematics? If so this free course, Postgraduate study skills in science, technology or mathematics, will help you to examine your work processes. You will consider and develop the nature of postgraduate work and look at the planning of work needed at doctoral level.

Free course
14 hrs
Three Irish Poets - Introduction Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Image of Nuala Ní Dhomhnaill: Paul Sherwood/The Gallery Press. Others: Public Domain article icon

History & The Arts 

Three Irish Poets - Introduction

A look at three female Irish Poets – Ellen O'Leary, Katharine Tynan and Nuala Ní Dhomhnaill.

Article