Science, Maths & Technology

Statistics and the media

Updated Monday 10th January 2005

"Don’t believe everything you read" takes on a new perspective after you spend some time discovering how the media uses statistics.

Newspapers Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC

It’s not always fun being a statistician. Suppose you were at a party, talking to someone you’d never met, and they happened to tell you they were a statistician. What would you do?

Say, “Wow, how interesting!” and ask them excitedly about the latest figures on exports of engineering goods?

Or notice an alleged old friend at the other side of the room, who requires your immediate attention?

Well, I can reveal that the friend-across-the-room option is used on 82% of such encounters. Statistics is boring. Well, isn’t it?

Actually, no. I mean, obviously I’d say that, because I’m a statistician, but in fact the British public seems pretty keen to read statistics about the way we all live. The media are full of data from surveys on pretty well every aspect of our lifestyles. That’s how we know that over five times as many of us have internet access than we did six years ago, that British men spend, on average, 25 minutes longer a day watching TV or listening to the radio and music than do British women, or that sales of used cars in Britain were worth over 2 ½ times as much in 2005 as in 1995. Or that UK residents took nearly 43 million holidays abroad in 2004. [Data from Social Trends 2006, UK 2005 Time Use Survey, British Lifestyles Survey 2006.]

We do like knowing what our fellow citizens are getting up to. And, if the information is in the form of impersonal statistics, we don’t have to feel guilty about spying on our neighbours. I became a statistician partly because I like poking my nose into other people’s business — most people don’t go quite to this extreme, but we’re still interested.

This fascination certainly isn’t unique to us Brits, either. The French seem even keener on statistics. They regularly publish glossy books on the topic, from which you can learn that there are 17.5 million pet dogs and cats in France, or that 13% of French people prefer to make love in the afternoon (as opposed to some other time of day). [Source: Francoscopie 2005. Francoscopie is published every two years by Larousse and sometimes gets onto best-seller lists.]

Can we believe any of this stuff? After all, there are lies, damned lies and statistics. Well, much of it comes from Government surveys, or surveys done by competent research organisations. They interview large samples of people, and they make sure their samples are representative. They generally avoid biased or leading questions. Their results probably aren’t absolutely accurate in every detail, and they never tell you absolutely everything you want to know.

But they do tell you something useful, and are unlikely to be far from the truth. But some statistics in the media come from more dubious sources, ranging from the slightly unreliable to the totally invented (like my 82% figure for statisticians at parties…).

In America there’s a research organisation called the Statistical Assessment Service that makes annual Dubious Data Awards to press stories that are particularly silly in relation to statistics or scientific logic.

My favourite is one of their Top Ten for the year 2000, a report of a survey where 70% of the people surveyed had tried to quit smoking, and not one had succeeded. Sounds depressing for anyone trying to give up — but close inspection revealed that the poll had specifically sampled only people who smoked. So anyone who actually managed to quit wouldn’t have been asked.

Newspaper delivery [Image by Indrarado via Flickr under CC-BY-NC-SA licence] Creative commons image Icon Indrarado via Flickr under Creative-Commons license
Five out of six...? Newspaper delivery [by Indrarado via Flickr under CC-BY-NC-SA licence]

Usually you need to read the small print to make a judgement on the reliability of statistical information. Did they ask enough people? Which people did they ask? Was it just people who wrote in or called up? What were the people asked, exactly?

But this sort of small print often isn’t there in brief press reports. If nothing at all is said about where the information came from, perhaps you should smell a rat. It’s also worth thinking about who produced and published the data, and why.

For instance, Mintel, publishers of the British Lifestyles Survey, are a big (and well-respected) UK market research company. Presumably they provide this sort of information to the media because it’s good PR. It keeps their name in the public eye, and helps them to sell the reports on things like Gastro-intestinal Remedies and UK Schoolwear Shopping Habits, from which they mainly earn their crust.

Of course, this doesn’t mean there’s anything wrong with the information they provide. Mintel certainly do use appropriate survey methods. But how would you know that, if you knew nothing at all about them? Be careful out there, but don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater and ignore everything statistical just because some of it is rubbish.

So, should you talk to statisticians at parties? Perhaps you’ll learn something fascinating. In my own career I’ve worked on things like the growth rate of certain kinds of grass, and the speed at which rubbish can be incinerated, and I’ll happily tell you all about that…

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

More or Less: interview with Tim Harford Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC audio icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

More or Less: interview with Tim Harford

Tim Harford, from More or Less, talks with Kevin McConway on why statistics matter and how they can impact the future.

Audio
20 mins
Big data and bioinformatics: Powerful tools for decoding DNA Creative commons image Icon By Nogas1974 (Own work) [CC BY-SA 4.0], via Wikimedia Commons under Creative Commons BY 4.0 license article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Big data and bioinformatics: Powerful tools for decoding DNA

With so many researchers all over the world producing information, is there a way for other scientists to look at large sets of results and use them to make new discoveries? 

Article
Finding information in mathematics and statistics Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Finding information in mathematics and statistics

This free course, Finding information in mathematics and statistics, will help you to identify and use information in maths and statistics, whether for your work, study or personal purposes. Experiment with some of the key resources in this subject area, and learn about the skills which will enable you to plan searches for information, so you can find what you are looking for more easily. Discover the meaning of information quality, and learn how to evaluate the information you come across. You will also be introduced to the many different ways of organising your own information, and learn how to reference it properly in your work. Finally, discover how to keep up to date with the latest developments in your area of interest by using tools such as RSS and mailing lists.

Free course
9 hrs
Getting started with SPSS Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Getting started with SPSS

Handling statistical data is an essential part of psychological research. However, many people find the idea of using statistics, and especially statistical software packages, extremely daunting. This free course, Getting started with SPSS, takes a step-by-step approach to statistics software through seven interactive activities. No statistics software is needed.

Free course
3 hrs
Interpreting data: Boxplots and tables Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 2 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

Interpreting data: Boxplots and tables

This free course, Interpreting data: Boxplots and tables, is concerned with two main topics. In Section 1, you will learn about another kind of graphical display, the boxplot. A boxplot is a fairly simple graphic, which displays certain summary statistics of a set of data. Boxplots are particularly useful for assessing quickly the location, dispersion, and symmetry or skewness of a set of data, and for making comparisons of these features in two or more data sets. Boxplots can also be useful for drawing attention to possible outliers in a data set. The other topic, which is covered in Sections 2 and 3, is that of dealing with data presented in tabular form. You are, no doubt, familiar with such tables: they are common in the media and in reports and other documents. Yet it is not always straightforward to see at first glance just what information a table of data is providing, and it often helps to carry out certain calculations and/or to draw appropriate graphs to make this clearer. In this free course, some other kinds of data tables and some different approaches are covered.

Free course
16 hrs
An introduction to data and information Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

An introduction to data and information

Ever wondered how a computer processes data into information? This free course, An introduction to data and information, will help you to understand the distinction between the two and examines how a computer-based society impacts on daily life. You will learn what computers can do with data to produce information and how computers can be used to work with data and search for it, control machines, and support commercial operations.

Free course
20 hrs
Storing and processing information Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 2 icon

Money & Business 

Storing and processing information

The purpose of this free course, Storing and processing information, is to discuss the main ways in which organisational data is managed, prior to decision-making activity. Organisations are increasingly dependent on information. However, they must first be able to get at information when it is needed, where it is needed and in the form it is needed. Moreover, this information has to complement the gathering, analysing and communication stages of the information management process.

Free course
3 hrs
Introduction to the context of accounting Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Money & Business 

Introduction to the context of accounting

Revenue, profit and loss, balance sheets are these accounting terms that intimidate you? This free course, Introduction to the context of accounting, will help you to understand the very basics of accounting, from its historical beginnings to the objectives of modern day accountants. You will learn how an accountant in business balances conflicting demands to maximise market share and profit.

Free course
4 hrs
More confusing terms in statistics Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Sunnycatty | Dreamstime.com article icon

Science, Maths & Technology 

More confusing terms in statistics

Kevin McConway explains why statisticians use everyday words for not-so-everyday concepts - and how to translate what they really mean.

Article