Society, Politics & Law

What happens now MPs have voted yes to the Article 50 bill?

Updated Friday 3rd February 2017

This week, the UK's House of Commons voted yes at the first reading of the bill which would allow the triggering of Article 50. But what happens next?

John McDonnell Copyright free image Icon Copyright free: Garry Knight John McDonnell

Less than 12 hours after the vote to trigger Article 50, John McDonnell was on Radio 4 arguing that the ‘real fight starts now’. McDonnell confidently believes that Labour will have a significant say on how the negotiations are conducted and influence over the process through the Commons. At present there is little to suggest he is correct, however it is likely to rally the Corbynites who will (ultimately) blame the moderates for the lack of success. For McDonnell, this is a win/win situation as the grip over the party gets stronger.

In political terms, the problem is that Labour’s fight has already been lost. Given the concessions made by Corbyn to May and the Conservatives, there is no single market access to fight over, no solidarity with EU social democrats, and no prospect of what some call a ‘soft Brexit’. By conceding so much ground (possibly all of it) to the Tories, May now has a free hand to conduct the negotiations as she sees fit, with little or no prospect of Labour affecting how they will play out. Put simply, Labour has left the battlefield without firing a shot, and now the Tories are claiming complete victory.

However, this victory may be premature because there is always the Liberal Democrats who will – they argue – continue fighting for a strong relationship between the UK and the EU. This position is likely designed to appeal strongly to the 48% of voters who supported Remain, however it must be remembered that 22% of Liberal Democrat MPs (2, to be precise) voted against Farron’s position and backed the triggering of Article 50. Whilst this is the minority, it does indicate that the Liberals are not a cohesive group of pro-EU MPs, rather they are as divided in percentage terms as the Labour Party. As a broader electoral strategy, however, it makes sense for the Liberals to appeal to the 48%, even if they secure even a fraction. This could pay dividends at the ballot box.

This leaves us with the SNP. As the third largest party, they have substantial impact on the Commons vote, however given they have their own agenda it is hard to see them pushing for and succeeding in achieving a softer Brexit for the UK. Put simply, the SNP exist to safeguard what they see as the interests of the Scottish people, which they undoubtedly now see as an independent Scotland within the EU. This potentially puts the rUK into a difficult position (should they secure independence), however current polling data suggests this is unlikely in the immediate term. This may change, however when the impact of Brexit begins to be felt in the run up to departure.

Thus, the Conservatives appear to be in a strong position to take the UK out of the EU. With the exception of Ken Clarke and Anna Soubry, the Party seems to be united behind their leader as she begins the process of UK departure from the EU. Brexiteers and Remainers now united for the best interests of the Conservative Party. At some point someone may have to think of the country, otherwise the threat from UKIP will never go away. In that sense, Cameron’s referendum gamble failed twice.

But whilst we have been consumed by our own process, we must also recognise that there are two players in this negotiation. The EU has its own interests to safeguard, especially in a world that has a resurgent Kremlin and belligerent Donald Trump as President. These factors will likely make the EU more defensive than may have been the case in a more stable world. Put simply, it has its own message to send – that of stability and continuing in the face of a world where one of its members has turned its back on it. This will likely make the EU a hard negotiator, and one which the UK negotiation team will need to be ready to face. It is important they are prepared because it is very likely the EU will be, and to consume our own propaganda too much will leave us in a very weak negotiation position. Put simply, the arguments of the referendum need to be put aside if a good deal is to be reached. The lesson for May, therefore, is not to assume UK exceptionalism will carry the day, or we may well face running over a cliff faster than expected.

This article was originally published by Political Studies Association's Insight blog under a CC-BY-NC-ND licence

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Scotland Votes 2016: Campaign snapshots Creative commons image Icon First Minister Of Scotland under Creative Commons BY-NC 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Scotland Votes 2016: Campaign snapshots

On May 5th, Scotland votes in a parliamentary election. Here's a quick round-up of what's happening on the campaign.

Article
Should the Tories be worried about their low membership numbers? Creative commons image Icon Altogetherfool under CC-BY-SA licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Should the Tories be worried about their low membership numbers?

The Conservative Party are enjoying a moment of victory - but although their future should be cloudy, the elation continues. Mike Garnett explains.

Article
Has Jeremy Corbyn saved Labour simply by standing for election? Creative commons image Icon Global Justice Now under CC-BY licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Has Jeremy Corbyn saved Labour simply by standing for election?

Tomorrow [September 12th, 2015] the new leader of the Labour Party will be announced. Jeremy Corbyn is favourite to win, to the consternation of some centrists in the party - but win or lose, Chris Game thinks Corbyn's campaign has given a boost to everyone's prospects.

Article
The Labour Party purges Creative commons image Icon World Economic Forum under CC-BY-NC-SA licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

The Labour Party purges

The UK Labour party is cancelling the memberships of significant numbers of people who joined in order to vote in its leadership election - and even some who joined before. Michael Chessum asks how far it will go.

Article
The moderate authoritarians: Labour's soft middle gets tough Creative commons image Icon stopwar.org.uk under CC-BY licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

The moderate authoritarians: Labour's soft middle gets tough

The purge of Labour supporters to weed out extremists, real and imagined, shows that even moderates can be authoritarian, says Peter Bloom.

Article
What is a confidence and supply government? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Photos.com article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

What is a confidence and supply government?

There's suggestions we might find ourselves with a confidence-and-supply government after May 7th. What does that actually mean - and what does it mean for you?

Article
Postcode patterns Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license activity icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Postcode patterns

Learn to read and interpret social statistics by exploring Milton Keynes, home of The Open University.

Activity
Donald Trump, President elect: A collection Creative commons image Icon Gage Skidmore under Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Donald Trump, President elect: A collection

This Friday, Donald Trump will be inaugurated as the 45th President of the United States. Experts from the OU and beyond share their insights into the man - and what his policies might mean for the world.

Article
From the 'Red Clyde' to the 'Blue Clyde'? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Press Association article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

From the 'Red Clyde' to the 'Blue Clyde'?

Gerry Mooney looks at how colour represents various forms of protest - particularly with regards to the struggles and protests on Clydeside during WW1 and the 2014 Scottish Independence Referendum.

Article