Skip to content
Society, Politics & Law

Are the police corrupt?

Updated Tuesday 22nd January 2013

What moral lines are police officers willing to cross? A recent survey by Dr Louise Westmarland explores just this question

Tape protecting a police investigation Creative commons image Icon By Hugovk via Flickr under Creative Commons Licence under Creative-Commons license One of the expectations the public has of the police is that they will carry out their duties in a fair and unbiased way. Serving ‘without fear or favour’ is a well used mantra for forces across the world.

As recent press coverage has shown however, it seems that some UK police officers, in some very high places, are not adverse to cozying up to the press and politicians – viewing the acceptance of hospitality, gifts and even cash as a ‘perk’ of the job.

But how widespread is this attitude? The survey, which involved a research team including Professor Mike Rowe from Northumbria University, Dr Courtney Hougham of the International Centre for Comparative Criminological Research (ICCCR) at the OU, and Dr Roger Grimshaw from the Centre for Crime and Justice Research (CCJS), one of ICCCR’s external partners, used a scenario based questionnaire.


I found that officers thought that stealing money or goods was ‘very serious’ and that over 98 per cent of those who responded would definitely report a corrupt colleague in these cases.

On the other hand, regarding minor gifts and misdemeanours, officers were less sure they would blow the whistle and in terms of a drink driving colleague and the use of excessive force, such as punching a suspect for attempting to escape, they were also unsure about their response. Only about 50 per cent of officers said they would definitely report a colleague in these cases.

The survey received responses from over 500 officers, from three contrasting police forces all across the country. It is the first national survey of serving police officers to ask about attitudes towards policing and integrity.  

Moral compass

The findings of the research suggest that officers are guided by a well formed ‘moral compass’ where offences are clearly ‘illegal’ in the sense that they are offences such as theft. On the other hand reporting a colleague for some offences they may view as ‘ambiguous’ as defined by beliefs endorsed by police occupational culture – sometimes called ‘cop’ or ‘canteen’ culture – is more problematic.

Taking a social harm approach, for example, studied in some depth throughout the OU’s  third level criminology module Crime and justice, it might be argued that covering up for a drink driving colleague or punching a suspect, who may, for example, have a pre-existing medical complaint, could be much more harmful than stealing a watch or taking money from a wallet equivalent to a day’s pay for that officer.

Whilst acceptance of stealing is not a behaviour anyone would want to encourage in police officers, there needs to be more of a discussion in policing circles about what constitutes ‘harm’.  

Social media

I'm hoping to take my research forward by surveying more officers across numerous UK forces and developing a new questionnaire to take more up to date scenarios, including attitudes towards the use of social media, inappropriate sexual behaviour and the way officers’ beliefs about occupational culture and corruption are linked.

I hope to ask questions in a future survey that will explore the way police officers rationalise their use of discretion. In effect police officers have a great deal of power to decide how to proceed in many cases, and this is often regarded as something, along with police ‘culture’ that should be curbed and controlled.

On the other hand, discretion, informed by cultural values, is an essential part of policing, and research is needed to explore how it is used appropriately, but ways in which aspects such as the potential social harm of certain actions could be better anticipated. 


For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Methods in Motion: Acknowledging the active participant article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Methods in Motion: Acknowledging the active participant

Participants come to research interviews with their own expectations, and researchers have to take account of this, says Senior Lecturer in Social Psychology Dr Stephanie Taylor.

Methods in Motion: Is Q still the answer? Creative commons image Icon Annette Dubois under Creative Commons BY-NC 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Methods in Motion: Is Q still the answer?

Paul Stenner considers social constructionism - and wonders if it ever-changing times means research methods also need to change.

Methods in Motion: What does Open Methodologies mean? Creative commons image Icon SomeDriftwood under Creative Commons BY-NC 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Methods in Motion: What does Open Methodologies mean?

A changing society needs changing methods to make sense of itself. Open Methodologies offers a new way of research. Elizabeth Silva explains more.

Themes in discourse research: The case of Diana Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Themes in discourse research: The case of Diana

This free course, Themes in discourse research: The case of Diana, introduces some of the main themes and issues in discourse research using Martin Bashir's famous interview with Diana, Princess of Wales as a case study. Through this it examines the role of discourse in shaping social interaction and its psychological implications for the study of minds, selves and sense-making. The course aims to demonstrate that in studying discourse we cannot help but study social life.

Free course
4 hrs
The Met: Episode five Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

The Met: Episode five

In the final episode of OU/BBC's The Met a new recruit learns his way around the London streets and Homicide investigate the tragic death of a four-month-old baby. 

The Social Science Centre Lincoln Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: The Social Science Centre, Lincoln article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

The Social Science Centre Lincoln

Free co-operative higher education.

Credibility of the police under scrutiny as fears mount of unchallenged racism Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Gary Edwards article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Credibility of the police under scrutiny as fears mount of unchallenged racism

Only one per cent of racist complaints against the police are upheld, writes Dick Skellington

Citizen Social Science Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Citizen Social Science

How mass participation can address persistent social challenges through the use of networked digital technologies.

Opening the wardrobe Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Antikainen | article icon

Money & Business 

Opening the wardrobe

From 2-9th November 2013, The Open University will be asking you to open your wardrobe and share your secrets with us in our wardrobe audit.