Society, Politics & Law

Dams, development and the nation

Updated Tuesday 12th May 2009

Giles Mohan discusses the advantages and disadvantages of a Chinese company building a Ghanaian hydroelectric project.

In a remote corner of western Ghana, close to the border of Côte d’Ivoire, is a new village. But it’s unlike the many villages you drive through to get there, with their mud houses and now seemingly ubiquitous mobile phone card sellers sitting under their bright, branded umbrellas.

This new village has around 250 Chinese in it, 60 Pakistanis, and 2000 Ghanaian workers, many with families. The houses are prefabricated cabins laid out in neat rows and it even has broadband connection. Barely twelve months ago this village did not exist, but is the work camp for the Bui Dam. This hydroelectric project is being built by the Chinese company Sinohydro and is one of a growing number of dam projects in Africa and the rest of the developing world being funded and built by China.

The workcamp for Ghanaian workers Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Giles Mohan
The workcamp for Ghanaian workers

The case against such dams is persuasive. They are seen as ecologically damaging and socially disruptive and they often arise out of non-transparent governance arrangements. Moreover, some people question whether such energy-intensive development should be encouraged at all. On the other hand, for many African countries, their infrastructure is so poor that basic welfare is compromised as roads are often impassable and electricity for basic activities is erratic or non-existent. So things like the Bui Dam can be seen as absolutely vital for Ghana and countries like it. Such questions are important and there are no easy answers. One approach is to evaluate them on a case by case basis.

The company contracted to build Bui Dam is the Sinohydro Corporation. It was one of the main contractors on the Three Gorges Dam in China and, as part of the government’s “Go Out” policy, has embarked on an ambitious internationalisation strategy with projects in 50 countries. However, according to the International Rivers Network, Sinohydro has repeatedly received low grades by China’s State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission for its poor safety record, construction and environmental accidents, and pollution. Indeed, some even blame the Sichuan earthquake of May 2008 on geological problems created by dam construction in the region.

The Bui Dam, and others built by Sinohydro, are “EPC” projects, meaning “engineering, procurement, construction”. This is the preferred route for many African governments since the price is agreed up front and fixed. The Chinese favoured the dam project as opposed to the Ghanaian Government’s preferred option of a railway from the coast to Burkina Faso in the North, because the sale of electricity would guarantee repayment in a way that a railway could not.

When it comes to these large Chinese projects, rumours abound about the importation of labour, some of it even sourced from convicts, and also that the Chinese import all the capital equipment and inputs and that they treat local workers badly. How true is this?

Much of the capital equipment is Chinese. Most of the heavy vehicles and the quarrying and aggregate plant are Chinese (although the aggregate crusher is American). The dam is the first in Ghana to be built using roller compacted concrete as opposed to rock fill and so requires huge amounts of cement which is coming from Ghacem, in Ghana’s main port city of Tema, which is German-owned.

The site of the Bui Dam Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Giles Mohan
The Bui Dam site

The contract with Sinohydro specified the upper limits of Chinese labour on the project, which meant recruitment of unskilled and semi-skilled labourers from within Ghana. Interestingly, the Chinese have brought in 60 Pakistanis to drive the heavy equipment who count as “Chinese” for purposes of the imported labour quota. Communication is a problem but the Chinese organise in small work teams with one Chinese foreman and one Ghanaian foreman, both of whom have some English, and 3-4 Ghanaian labourers under them. Even then much communication is via drawings.

Chinese corporations in general do not encourage trade unions, and originally did not allow for it at Bui. But a deputation from the Ghana TUC argued that it was enshrined both in Ghanaian law and the contract and so they had to. The union has pushed for better protection from the debilitating black fly which comes during the rainy season, although this threat affects all workers and is being dealt with through a daily insecticide programme.

All the Chinese labour is male and they sleep in the dormitories. In theory, they are not allowed to drink alcohol, but socialise in a club with TV and table tennis. Mixing between Ghanaian and Chinese workers of all levels is limited although there are “inter-national” soccer games, which one Ghanaian official told me proudly were always won by the Ghanaians and that in general the Chinese were “not friendly”.

The Bui Power Authority’s role during construction is essentially to monitor the delivery of the contract and so it has its own engineers to report on quality and progress, and to monitor health and safety and environmental standards. One engineer joked that the Chinese don’t care about hard hats and pointed to a tree that they had saved given that the Chinese were too willing to remove it.

Chinese and Ghanaian workers Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Giles Mohan
Chinese and Ghanaian workers

Sinohydro and other Chinese firms are looking to deepen their footprint in Ghana and Africa more broadly. Although the Chinese seemed to have got a foothold in Africa through these semi-commercial, Chinese government-supported projects they are now competing more openly for tenders and, as one European aid official told me, “winning in straight fights”. For example, one Chinese firm is building roads in Northern Ghana funded by French aid, and Sinohydro also has plans for four smaller dams in Ghana.

But these are essentially turnkey projects and so have limited multipliers locally, which is why it is so imperative that African governments ensure that local content agreements are written into contracts. That said, African infrastructure needs are so chronic and have been so overlooked by donors for years that the Chinese are welcome for the investment they bring and the speed of their operations. They look set to continue for many years to come.

For more information on China and Africa visit Durham University's guide to The Politics of Chinese engagement with Africa. For more about the Bui Dam see
Sinohydro and Bui Power Authority sites.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Elections, oil and a Chinese dam in Ghana Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Giles Mohan article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Elections, oil and a Chinese dam in Ghana

After a visit to Ghana, Giles Mohan discusses their economy and the involvement of the Chinese in their energy production.

Article
Economy v environment Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Economy v environment

Maggie Smith weighs up the impacts of China's rapid and fuel-intensive development.

Article
About Syria Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

About Syria

From its arrival as a separate nation following the unravelling of the Ottoman Empire to its current status as a gateway to the Mediterranean, Syria is a country with a rich history and many stories to tell.

Article
How was the US election viewed in the Middle East Creative commons image Icon U.S. Embassy Tel Aviv under Creative Commons BY 4.0 license video icon

Society, Politics & Law 

How was the US election viewed in the Middle East

OpenDemocracy's Adam Ramsay toured the West Bank during the closing stages of the US election campaign. What he heard may give an indication of how Trump's victory will be received in the region.

Video
Enough Giving? Charity, Aid & Development Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Enough Giving? Charity, Aid & Development

Here, Doctor Matt Smith gives his personal perspective on the interplay between charity, aid and development.

Article
What Role is There For Development Agencies? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

What Role is There For Development Agencies?

How development agencies can help communities stabilise themselves in the face of the HIV AIDS challenge

Article
Anurag's life in Pune Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC video icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Anurag's life in Pune

For Anurag, football, playing the tabla, and eating an ice lolly by Khadakwasla Lake, are all part of his life in Pune. Watch Anurag's video diary

Video
5 mins
Global data: the importance of perspective Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Global data: the importance of perspective

The importance of perspective when interpreting global data on the poor and the rich in the 21st Century world.

Article
China in Africa Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: 350jb | Dreamstime.com article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

China in Africa

Is there a Chinese conspiracy to take over the world? And should we in the west be worried? Giles Mohan, Professor of International Development at the OU, has his finger on the pulse.

Article