People, Politics & Law
  • Video
  • 5 mins
  • Level 1: Introductory

60 second adventures in economics: The Paradox Of Thrift

Updated Tuesday 18th September 2012

Is it better to save or to spend? According to Keynes, if you don't spend, you're going to make the economy even worse.

Transcript: Much like a child getting his pocket money, one of the biggest economic questions is still whether it’s better to save or spend.

Free-marketeers like Hayek and Milton Friedman say that, even in difficult times, it's best to be thrifty and save.

Banks then channel the savings into investment, in new plants, skills and techniques that let us produce more. And even if this new technology destroys jobs, wages will drop, and businesses hire more people – so unemployment falls again.

Simple. At least in the long run... But then a "live-fast-die-young" kinda chap called John Maynard Keynes cheerfully pointed out that “in the long run we're all dead”.

So, to avoid the misery of unemployment, the government should instead spend money to create jobs.

Whereas if the government tightens its belt when people and businesses are doing the same, less is spent, so unemployment gets even worse. That is the paradox of thrift.

So instead they should spend now and tax later when everyone's happy to pay - Though making people happy to pay tax was something even Keynes didn't solve.


For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

What's On 

OpenLearn Live: 8th July 2015

Something to think about: A collection of free learning, insight and research from around OpenLearn and around the world.

Dawn of the digital census article icon

People, Politics & Law 

Dawn of the digital census

With online returns for the UK's 2011 census opening tomorrow, Dr Ruppert, research fellow with the ESRC Centre for Research on Socio-cultural Change (CRESC), explores the impact of the web on the census


Health, Sports & Psychology 

What factors prevent us from fighting climate change?

Our deep-seated beliefs and values can prevent us from doing our utmost to battle climate change. Nadine Marshall discusses how some people are more adaptive than others

10 mins

What's On 

OU on the BBC: Silverville - Episode 6

Concluding the stories of life in a retirement village.


History & The Arts 

The Silverville diaries: Welcome to Lovat Fields

There's a change of pace and lifestyle ahead for Bart Cope as he lives with the residents of Lovat Fields, for the BBC/OU series Silverville


People, Politics & Law 

Uganda: Biography Of A Nation

Discover more about this diverse country, its people, history, government and economy in an article by Carolyn Baxter entitled 'Uganda - an overview'


People, Politics & Law 

Money’s Second Life?

Our increasingly virtualised world has seen music switch from physical formats to digital downloads. Should money also go digital - and if it does, would it necessarily be for the best?


People, Politics & Law 

Poverty? What poverty?

According to former Tory MP Edwina Currie, poverty isn't prevalent in the UK. We explore perceptions of poverty with this collection of articles and free course tasters.


People, Politics & Law 

Leslie Budd on... the Eurozone

Has the Greek debt crisis exposed flaws in the euro economy system? Leslie Budd examines the consequences of a currency crisis and the knock-on effects of cuts in public expenditure.

5 mins