Society, Politics & Law
  • Video
  • 10 mins
  • Level 1: Introductory

Your truth or theirs - the making of public opinion introduction

Updated Friday 5th November 2010

A public form of political gossip, a way for politicians to test out public reaction to policies, an accurate prediction of how people will vote? Getting political opinion polling in perspective...

Video

Copyright The Open University

Audio

Copyright The Open University

Text

Vox pops:
I think you should believe opinion polls sometimes but I think people can manipulate them in whatever way they want to. Especially politicians which are known for that anyway. 

Vox pops:
It's lovely to open a newspaper at home and be able to see what the public are feeling and you know what people are thinking, but at the same time it all depends on, you know, who’s been asked, where, when.

Vox pops:
They shape opinions, they massage opinions and I don’t think they are democratic.

Jeremy Vine (archive):
I show you a graph first of all these are the polls… 

Peter Snow (archive):
The swings suggested by the polls is a mere 3 per cent. Only a couple of seats.  

Mark Pack:
Opinion polls are sort of the public form of political gossip, you know, who’s up, who’s down, who’s doing well, who’s in, who’s out. And in the end politics is about who is the most popular with the public. 

Peter Riddell:
All politicians deny being led by polls. I mean if you ask a politician: “The poll shows you know, you’re doing disastrously, you’re 15 points behind”, or something like that, so: “Oh, I don’t pay any attention to the poll. The only poll that matters is on Polling Day.” Well, that’s baloney.

Mark Pack:
People often use opinion polls to test out: “Well if we said this or we took this line on a policy, or we changed our mind on something else, how would the public react?” 

That gets into quite tricky territory because to the extent the job of a politician is to decide what they believe in and try to persuade the public to believe in it.

Peter Riddle:
For newspaper and media outlets, they’re partly a marketing tool, because they can make headlines, they can get picked up by other papers. Also, it’s what they regard as part of their tool for covering politics.

Mark Pack:
The very fact of reporting that the public think something then makes the public more likely to think that. The classic example being levels of liberal democrat support in parliamentary by-elections, where very often, when the party support had begun to grow and therefore there will then be tangible signs of that, including sometimes constituency opinion polls, then more people support the party, and so you get this bandwagon effect that can roll and roll and roll.

Jacqui Smith:
My experience of going out and knocking on doors during election campaigns is that people will play back to you the opinion polls, not you know not directly but they will say things like, well of course you're behind at the moment, aren't you, and things like that. 

Vox pop:
If you hear that Gordon Brown is behind every day you're not likely, you know, to cast your vote for him - you think, well he’s a loser so what’s the point of me backing him? 

Archive voiceover:
And the winner is Nick Clegg, at least so say the post debate polls and even his political opponents.

Jeremy Vine (archive):
Suddenly they are pushing Labour into third place and it gets better for them. Amidst all the Clegg-mania, so called, they then start wrestling with the Conservatives for the first place here. 

Peter Riddell:
One of the problems with polls is to get them in perspective, to realize the difference between underlying trends and what might just be a temporary blip. And we saw that, classically, in the 2010 election, when there were instant polls, and it turned out that they did register quite accurately what people thought at the time. Nick Clegg’s ratings rose a lot, but it was almost like a reality TV show - when you’re actually asking people how they’d vote on Polling Day, it turned out different answers.

Jacqui Smith:
Interestingly, what you saw, is a bit of a conflation of what people's voting intentions were and who people thought had done well in the debates. People will need to be more sophisticated about whether or not what their polling is, do you think that X has done a good job on the television, rather than which way will you vote if the election is tomorrow.

Peter Riddell:
As a journalist, my own feeling has been very much that you’ve got to report polls responsibly… but it’s very difficult, sometimes, to say, actually this poll might be wrong or it may exaggerate it, let’s be cautious.

Mark Pack:
There are or have been occasions, several General Elections, even in my lifetime, let alone over a longer period of time, when the opinion polls have turned out to get public opinion badly wrong. So you have to remember that they’re not absolutely perfect, they are a degree art, as well a degree science.

Neil Kinnock (archive):
Comrades, well, alright!

 

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Your truth or theirs - the making of public opinion: Perspectives Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Sunnycatty | Dreamstime.com audio icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Your truth or theirs - the making of public opinion: Perspectives

Opinion polls have their uses - but it is important to remember they do not, nor are intended to, predict the future. Join Dave Middleton for a discussion about the pitfalls of polls, and dangers of irresponsible media reporting.

Audio
15 mins

Society, Politics & Law 

Pitfalls of Polls

What are opinions polls? A public form of political gossip, a way for politicians to test public reactions to policies or an accurate prediction of how people will vote? Opinion polls have their uses, but it is important to remember they do not, and are not intended to, predict the future. Getting political opinion polling in perspective is not always as straight forward as it seems.

Video
15 mins
Dominic Weston - Earth in Vision Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Nature & Environment 

Dominic Weston - Earth in Vision

Dominic Weston, a seasoned series producer of natural history programming, discusses the place of storytelling in natural history filmmaking, whether environmental messages can be packaged as entertaining television, and the future of wildlife television.

Video
30 mins
Caroline Underwood - Earth in Vision Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Nature & Environment 

Caroline Underwood - Earth in Vision

Caroline Underwood, award-winning series producer for Canadian television, looks back at how the landscape of environmental and natural history programming has transformed over the last few decades, and the challenges it faces today and moving forward into the future.

Video
30 mins
James Smith - Earth in Vision Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Nature & Environment 

James Smith - Earth in Vision

James Smith of the BBC's Natural History Unit talks about the experience of live broadcasting natural history content, as well as audiences craving the countryside in their homes, and how the NHU archival footage could be used to document the changing state of the UK's natural heritage.

Video
30 mins
David Allen - Earth in Vision Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Nature & Environment 

David Allen - Earth in Vision

David Allen, head producer at Passion Planet, discusses how to turn blue-chip filmmaking on its head, the importance of compelling stories, and the opportunities around opening up archives.

Video
30 mins
Lisa Sargood - Earth in Vision Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Nature & Environment 

Lisa Sargood - Earth in Vision

Lisa Sargood, award-winning former Science and Nature Commissioner at the BBC, introduces to the debate around natural history broadcasting the question of how digital technologies, social media platforms and the overall infrastructure of information will be critical to the future of environmental programming. 

Video
30 mins
Abbie Barnes - Earth in Vision Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Nature & Environment 

Abbie Barnes - Earth in Vision

Abbie Barnes, founder of Song Thrush Productions, describes what it is like starting out as a young natural history filmmaker, exploring wildlife in Britain, and the role of social media in connecting with new audiences.

Video
30 mins
Krishan Arora - Earth in Vision Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Nature & Environment 

Krishan Arora - Earth in Vision

Krishan Arora, consultant producer and former BBC commissioner, discusses the issues around commissioning environmental programmes in both the UK and abroad - including the once-upon-a-time industry reluctance to use the word "environment" - and outlines the ethical issues surrounding making archives open to the public.  

Video
30 mins