Skip to content
Society, Politics & Law

1968 and the 9 to 5

Updated Tuesday 2nd September 2008

1968 was a year of revolutions, but Mark Banks suggests that work isn't the new freedom for all.

As has been widely reported, this year marks the 40th anniversary of the tumultuous events of 1968, where – if only for a brief moment – it appeared that Western capitalism was about to be toppled by the various riotous and revolutionary efforts of students, political activists and disgruntled workers. Much effort has gone into evaluating the impacts of 1968, not least by the BBC in John Tusa’s recent Year of Revolutions radio programmes.

One area of life which 1968 appears to have had a profound (but largely unacknowledged) influence upon is the realm of work. I recently finished Luc Boltanski and Eve Chiapello's much-praised (and exhaustingly thick) book The New Spirit of Capitalism which takes up this theme and argues that, in the wake of 1968, employers and governments began to carefully manipulate emerging desires for individual freedom, creativity and autonomy raised by the counterculture. Thus, traditionally conservative capitalism began to take on board (rather than reject) radical values, absorbing them into the world of business, in order to provide disaffected populations with opportunities for more meaningful and fulfilling kinds of work. This had the effect of ‘buying off’ the counterculture; so tempering revolutionary impulses while also protecting established corporate and governmental interests.

Thus in the 1970s and 80s, in order to appeal to desires for ‘individual freedom’ work became more personalized, and was placed more under individual control. Indeed, what we refer to as the ‘individualization’of work came to the fore, realised in the increased use of personalized contracts, performances, tests and rewards, the promotion of flexible and portfolio working, the growth of an ethic of self-responsibility in the workplace and the disavowal of collectivization, unionization and the idea of ‘shared’ interests - all of which proved seductive, not just to revolutionary artists and political agitators, but young people more generally inspired by the possibilities of ‘creative freedom’, ‘selfhood’ and ‘autonomy’. The concurrent growth of various kinds of cultural, informational and knowledge based occupations (in public services, in media, design, technology and science) also gave rise to the idea that work could become more ‘creative’, choice-laden and personally ‘expressive’. The old idea that work is intrinsically boring, functional, alienating or oppressive was soundly challenged by the growth of a new discourse that promoted work as the principal route to personal freedom and individual growth. Work became, not the barrier to freedom, but freedom’s provider.

Raoul Vaneigem quote on a bus stop advertising box Creative commons image Icon weegeebored under CC-BY-ND licence under Creative-Commons license
A Raoul Vaneigem quote on a bus shelter

Thus for Boltanski and Chiapello, capitalism hijacked the values of 1968 and inserted them at the heart of economic life – and the social and artistic critiques that flowered in the 1960s have now been incorporated into the management ideology and textbooks of contemporary capitalism. Take for example Raoul Vaneigem's The Revolution of Everyday Life, published in 1967 as a searing indictment of the inauthenticity and alienation induced by capitalism, highly valued at the time as a must-read text for any budding Left revolutionaries, and strongly condemned by the Establishment - yet as Boltanski and Chiapello point out, with its emphasis on free expression, self-directedness and choice there is little in there that would now be out of place in any contemporary corporate training manual or management textbook:

"The problem then is how to organize, without creating a hierarchy; in other words, how to make sure the leader of the game doesn't just become 'The Leader'"
Raoul Vaneigem

"Leaders don't create followers, they create more leaders"
Tom Peters – contemporary management guru

I realise I’m being a bit selective. But while we often think of the counterculture as being a glorious failure, it was in some sense a huge success. The demands of the revolutionaries were not ignored – on the contrary they have been absorbed and contained into the heart of the economy, embedded in organizational life, and workers in all kinds of service and knowledge based, creative and artistic, advertising, marketing and media, public service professions have been rewarded with some semblance of the kind of freedom, authenticity and enchantment that the counterculture so vocally demanded. Ironically, then, the revolution has occurred – but inside rather than outside of capitalism. But is work really the new freedom? Maybe for some – doubtless not for many more others.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

What makes people happy at work? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Money & Business 

What makes people happy at work?

Experts identify what makes workers happy - and why it's important.

Article
Relationships at work article icon

Money & Business 

Relationships at work

There remains serious controversy over whether one should form relationships at work. Peter Bloom explains.

Article
Life stories Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Life stories

This free course, Life stories, looks at the way in which objects, trends, cultures or disabilities may contribute to a person's identity, and the contribution that our own life stories make to who we are, and how remembering and revisiting our past may help us to move forward with our lives.

Free course
4 hrs
The father of modern management Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Jupiter Images article icon

Money & Business 

The father of modern management

We look at one the world's most influential management thinkers, Peter Drucker 

Article
Family-friendly employment and the dream of the work-life balance Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Zoran Karapancev | Dreamstime.com article icon

Money & Business 

Family-friendly employment and the dream of the work-life balance

Getting a balance between work and life is an attractive idea - but you've got to be able to separate them in order to balance them.

Article
article icon

Money & Business 

Happy workers

The signs are that British workers are less happy than they used to be but not because they are under greater time pressures. Other factors come into the picture.

Article
Reith 2004: The Climate of Fear: A Quest for Dignity Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Reith 2004: The Climate of Fear: A Quest for Dignity

In his fourth lecture, Wole Soyinka believes that freedom from fear starts with respect for an individual's dignity. Lynda Morgan is not totally convinced by the argument.

Article
Education in Northern Ireland: segregation, division and sectarianism? Creative commons image Icon lightruth under CC-BY-NC under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Education in Northern Ireland: segregation, division and sectarianism?

Is education in Northern Ireland a vehicle for social cohesion or for perpetuating community divisions?

Article
Newry: Frontier town or border city? Creative commons image Icon D Mull under CC-BY-NC-ND licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Newry: Frontier town or border city?

Newly-minted Newry's city status may be - but it still relies on the same commerce and location that has kept it thriving across the centuries as a town.

Article