Society, Politics & Law

Negotiating Notting Hill

Updated Friday 18th September 2009

Melissa Butcher reflects on her experience at the Notting Hill Carnival, and looks at crowd behaviour

Each year after Notting Hill Carnival there is debate in media columns and talkback radio about whether the Carnival has outgrown its current site. ‘The streets of gentrifying Notting Hill can no longer accommodate Europe’s largest street party’, is one argument. ‘The Caribbean community has moved on and so should the carnival’ is another. On reflection, there are two deep-seated fears being presented here: first, fear of the crowd, its sheer size and unpredictability; and second, the fear of the stranger and his/her ambiguity.

Notting Hill crowd Creative commons image Icon scottroberts under CC-BY-NC-ND licence under Creative-Commons license
Notting Hill carnival crowd

The popular belief is that crowds are volatile and can equal trouble. Such impressions have ultimately led to crowd control tactics such as ‘kettling’. However, psychologists at St Andrews University, researching how people behave at demonstrations, large sporting or music events, have found that there is wisdom embedded in crowds which nearly always act in highly rational ways, and are more likely to cooperate than panic in an emergency. The findings pointed to an ‘identity shift’ which drives people in a crowd to act in the best interests of themselves and those around them. Decades earlier, Elias Canetti wrote of similar sensations when he described the individual’s transcendence when subsumed into a crowd, now free of the burden of distance from others.

Explore personal experiences of post colonial English with this course.

Trying to make my way up Ladbroke Grove during Carnival it is hard to feel this transcendence. At first there is a sense only of discomfort; then a feeling of suffocation as my 5’ 2” frame is squeezed on all sides, pulled back, loses sight of my partner, and becomes surrounded by strangers.

According to Canetti: "there is nothing that man (sic) fears more than the touch of the unknown … It is only in a crowd that man can become free of this fear of being touched."

Not just any crowd though. A crowd in which we lose our fear of being touched by the unknown is a crowd that is already dense with familiarity. This is a closed crowd; a crowd that sets its boundaries and desires permanence at the expense of disorderly growth.

The open crowd, a Notting Hill crowd, is another experience altogether. It is potentially limitless and exists so long as it grows, pulling people, barbeque smoke and sequins into its wake as it roils its way through the neighbourhood, disintegrating as quickly as it began when it reaches sunset.

Perhaps then the tensions that infiltrate Notting Hill Carnival are not generated in the diversity of people per se, but in the dynamics of closed and open crowds, order and spontaneity. Their meeting can be fraught as incursion into each other’s territory is unwittingly made. The closed crowd may not even appear on the streets. Its adherents appear silent, invisible in cultural frameworks dominated by established social hierarchies (for example, men, capital, Englishness).

Its boundaries are of course always contested (for example, by women, youth, or other cultural frames of reference) and sometimes breached by the open crowd. But the open crowd’s impermanent nature may not provide any lasting infrastructure on which to build equality and can block a thoroughfare as easily as any gated community.

On a daily basis then we must negotiate with either crowd, sometimes going with the flow, sometimes stepping to the side to avoid collision; watching, always watching. These negotiations are inflected by personal dispositions of, as Bauman puts it, mixophilia and mixophobia: the love of the city and all its crowds, and its inverse proposition, the fear of the city with all its strangers.

Adding to our repertoire of skills that as individuals we deploy to navigate the city, we find a means to move. Holding hands, forming a human chain, and like water, sliding between the cracks of space that mysteriously open up once some unseen pressure of presence is applied to the crowd, we make our way up Ladbroke Grove.

Notting Hill Carnival on iTunes U

Notting Hill on iTunes

Carnival and the performance of heritage, a series of Open University podcasts on iTunes U


 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

How can the Hajj be made safer? Creative commons image Icon Omar Chatriwala under CC-BY-NC-ND under Creative-Commons license article icon

History & The Arts 

How can the Hajj be made safer?

After a second tragedy at the 2015 Hajj, could understanding the psychology of crowds help to make future pilgrimages safer for everyone?

Article
60 second adventures in economics: Rational Choice Theory Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Society, Politics & Law 

60 second adventures in economics: Rational Choice Theory

People are pretty rational. But not quite rational enough for the good of the economy.

Video
5 mins
Discuss: Working class leisure Creative commons image Icon By Chitrapa (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0], via Wikimedia Commons under Creative-Commons license activity icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Discuss: Working class leisure

From music hall to football to karaoke. Fill in our short leisure survey and share your thoughts and memories.

Activity
Education in Northern Ireland: segregation, division and sectarianism? Creative commons image Icon lightruth under CC-BY-NC under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Education in Northern Ireland: segregation, division and sectarianism?

Is education in Northern Ireland a vehicle for social cohesion or for perpetuating community divisions?

Article
Discuss: Representations of the working class Creative commons image Icon By Goldfinger at sr.wikipedia [CC-BY-3.0-rs], from Wikimedia Commons under Creative-Commons license activity icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Discuss: Representations of the working class

The working class in the media: stereotypes or accurate potrayals? Fill in our short survey and share your thoughts and memories.

Activity
Off the Road? Creative commons image Icon me'nthedogs under CC-BY licence under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Off the Road?

Writing a time when the US car industry was on its knees, Engin Isin argued that the impact of the automobile has been to change our lives for the worse.

Article

Society, Politics & Law 

Welfare, crime and society

If you feel that you are being watched, it may well be that you are. Surveillance is an ever growing feature of 21st century life in countries across the world, raising issues of social justice, security and community. The tracks on this album explore how forms and practices of surveillance reveal the entanglements between welfare, crime and society and the tensions and overlaps between policies aimed at delivering social welfare and those intended to control crime. The material is drawn from the course DD208 Welfare, crime and society

Audio
1 hr 15 mins
Psychological research, obedience and ethics Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Psychological research, obedience and ethics

In this free course, Psychological research, obedience and ethics, you will learn about the importance of ethics in research that is undertaken by psychologists. You will read about the famous study on obedience conducted by Stanley Milgram, and watch two psychologists talk about their research with meerkats and chimpanzees.

Free course
5 hrs

Society, Politics & Law 

Fiscal Responsibility and Monetary Policy

Why do economies go into recession, and what should policymakers do? How do governments use money to influence the economy? Over the past century governments have used a variety of strategies to avoid economic instability, and the current economic crisis has been handled very differently from the Great Depression, the last comparable global downturn. Getting the balance right - between government spending and taxation, low inflation and low unemployment, low interest rates for borrowers and rewards for savers - is difficult in practice, and the subject of ongoing debate in economic theory.

Video
25 mins