Skip to content
Society, Politics & Law

The end of the line: Is fishing in crisis?

Updated Tuesday 22nd May 2012

The once-abundant oceans are running short of fish, while trawlers discard edible catch. Can the recent high profile political campaigns offer a solution to the crisis?

Sardines Creative commons image Icon Rockyeda under CC-BY licence under Creative-Commons license Sardines: An alternative to a world without fish? 'Over-fishing', 'discarded' fish thrown back into the sea by fishing fleets because they have exceeded their EU quota; illegal fishing by pirates in search of the expensive - and now rare - fish species, (at an estimated annual cost of £9 billion) and the continual threat to endangered species like blue-fin tuna are all consequences of what many have begun to call a 'crisis' in the fishing industry.

Underpinning the 'crisis' is a wider story of social hardship; economic divisions; decline in traditional fishing communities and working practices, and environmental destruction. The driving forces of this crisis - namely the rapid expansion of global trade, the impact of the industrial food system and the dominance of supermarkets - have combined to put pressure on fish stocks, fishing communities and the health of the sea.

There are stories, too, of changing consumer patterns, and the juxtaposition of the pursuit of new exotic 'global' tastes, with the lack of appeal of 'local' familiar fish, while the loss of traditional skills and knowledge has contributed to the crisis. Yesterday's staples – including oysters in Britain and lobsters in North America – have become today's luxuries.

Over-fishing has been a feature of the expansion of global trade, with both factory and illegal or unregulated fishing contributing to declining fish stocks. In short, there are too many boats and too few fish. According to the World Wildlife Fund, 1% of industrial fishing fleets account for 50% of all catches.

Declining fish stocks have become an international issue, the concern of the European Union as well as national governments and the subject of increasing political debate. It has led to heated arguments between environmentalists, campaigning journalists and representatives of the fishing industry, while it has produced another example of the gastronome as a political subject, bringing together questions of politics and pleasure

According to Charles Clover in his book The End of the Line, recently made into a successful documentary film, over-fishing will mean extinction for the most popular fish species over the next decades. He argues that the way we currently consume fish is completely unsustainable.

Clover proposed a campaign to "reclaim the ocean", in which he called for more marine protected areas, in order to conserve the environment, oceans and eco-systems; responsible fishing and a more curious consumer who will ask fishmongers and restaurants where the fish is from, and whether it is an endangered or exploited species.

Discards have become a major feature of the fishing crisis, publicised by the high profile campaign led by celebrity chef Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall, who has argued that half of all fish caught in the North Sea are discarded. His Fish Fight was a very creative campaign against the practice of discarding fish on the grounds that the fishing team have exceeded their quota, and that the fish being discarded are less valuable than other species.

His campaign became part of a wider battle against over-fishing, and for changing the way we consume fish, which engaged the public through petitions, challenging them to become more discerning consumers. The Fish Fight campaign also developed effective alliances with movements like Greenpeace to force the large supermarkets (including Tesco and Morrisons) to change their practices.

It drew on the knowledge of marine biologists, as well as local fishermen, to highlight the cause of endangered fish species. Hugh's Fish Fight, became a powerful campaigning lobby which has complemented other campaigns such as restaurants banning the use of bluefin tuna.

One feature of the Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall campaign is to try and raise awareness of simple, traditional fish like mackerel and sardines, which have lost their previous appeal but which are cheap, high in Omega 3 fish oils and universally recognised as good for the brain and heart. Maria Damanaki Creative commons image Icon The European Parliament under CC-BY-NC-ND licence under Creative-Commons license Maria Damanaki

This attempt to re-educate people about wider varieties of fish - including the more than 50 different species that come ashore in Cornwall - has also been reflected in many other movements such as the biennial Slow Fish gathering in Genoa, Italy, organised by the Slow Food movement.

Here, fisherfolk, activists, chefs and consumers meet to debate the politics of fish and to taste sustainable dishes. At its 2011 meeting, Sanjay Kumar, an Indian chef based in Cornwall took his campaign for the Cornish sardine to EU fisheries minister Maria Damanaki.

So, will the crisis in the fishing mean the 'end of the line?'

Leading economists and ecologists, led by Dr Boris Worm, Professor of Marine Biology at Dalhousie University in Nova Scotia, Canada, estimated in 2006 that if current momentum continues there will effectively be no seafood at all by 2048. This four year study attracted a lot of attention, featuring in both The End of the Line and Hugh's Fish Fight, while being challenged by some in the fishing industry, and has become an issue of hot political debate.

It was followed by a further study by Worm and Hilborn in 2009 that showed some recovery of fish stocks due to improved conservation practices. In 2011, Worm again warned that some regions 'may run out of seafood by the middle of the century if current trends continue'.

The first victims of the crisis in the fishing industry have been those who have earned their living from fishing and the sea. This could be the 'end of the line', too, for many in the Billingsgate fish market where generations of workers have plied their trade, as well as having devastating consequences for many communities in the UK, which were built on the back of the fishing industry.

However, there are at least signs that some aspects of the crisis are now being addressed . Hugh's Fish Fight resulted in the support of European Union Fisheries minister Damanaki calling for a change to the EU's Common Fisheries Policy to ban discards (though this has since been opposed by a British parliamentary committee).

Research on the impact of Charles Clover's film, particularly following the large audiences it attracted after its Channel Four showing, suggested consumers were changing their behaviour.

Some supermarkets like Waitrose experienced major increases in the purchase of sustainable fish options and several leading chefs removed bluefin tuna, a species facing extinction, from their menus.

The future success of the campaign, for those seeking sustainable alternatives, would now seem to depend on two factors.

The first is about politics. The alliance between chefs, consumers, environmental activists and local fishing communities will need to grow further as it has done in other spheres of the growing politics of food.

The second is about pleasure. The rediscovery of interest in traditional fish like sardines and mackerel will have many benefits for work, health, and environment, but above all educating people about the local and varied tastes and flavours of the sea close to home will be key to a more sustainable solution.

Further reading

The Fish Market: Inside Billingsgate
The End Of The Line

Hugh's Fish Fight
Slow Fish: The Food Programme: Sanjay and the Sardine
The Marine Conservation Society's Good Fish Guide

Editor's note: This article was amended by the author on 28th May 2012 to provide extra clarity in response to reader's comments.

Doctor Worm on Fish Stock Collapse

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Will Brexit spell the end of fishing quotas? Creative commons image Icon "Four guys, seven salmon" by blackbodypie, via Flickr under Creative Commons BY-NC 4.0 license article icon

Nature & Environment 

Will Brexit spell the end of fishing quotas?

The Leave campaign promised that Brexit would help fishers ‘take back control’ of Britain’s fishing waters and stocks. But how quotas are allocated has always been a national decision.

Article
The coast on your plate Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Liza Griffin article icon

Nature & Environment 

The coast on your plate

Quotas and overfishing—Liza Griffin explores the implications of the British appetite for fish

Article
Applying Ecology Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Production team article icon

Nature & Environment 

Applying Ecology

Studying ecology is not just about increasing our knowledge of how the natural world works. It can also help us to understand and find the solutions to many environmental problems

Article
Learning from audio visual material: Migrants and borders Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 2 icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Learning from audio visual material: Migrants and borders

This free course, Learning from audio visual material: Migrants and borders, provides you with a further opportunity to practise the learning from audio visual material skills you learned in DD208_1. You should have completed DD208_1 before commencing with this course.

Free course
5 hrs
What does toilet paper teach us about poverty? Creative commons image Icon paul under Creative Commons BY-NC 4.0 license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

What does toilet paper teach us about poverty?

The purchasing pattern of a bathroom staple has a lot to teach us about how poverty works. Atif Kukaswadia explains.

Article
Identity in question Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Identity in question

Why is identity important and how are identities formed? This free course, Identity in question, looks at the many different ways in which identity can be categorised. By examining the requirements of the state, how a child views gender, and the importance of race or place of birth, you will start to understand how each individual can have more than one identity.

Free course
12 hrs
Wales and rugby Creative commons image Icon Antonio Cinotti [CC BY-NC-ND 2.0] via Flickr Creative Commons under Creative-Commons license audio icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Wales and rugby

Gareth Williams talks about rugby and its place in Welsh culture.

Audio
20 mins
Negotiating Notting Hill Creative commons image Icon By The Style PA via Flickr under Creative Commons license under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Negotiating Notting Hill

Melissa Butcher reflects on her experience at the Notting Hill Carnival, and looks at crowd behaviour

Article
The social in social science Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 3 icon

Society, Politics & Law 

The social in social science

In a complex and rapidly changing world, social scientific study examines how we produce things, communicate, govern ourselves and understand our environments, and how to solve the problems we face in the organisation of social relations and processes. This free course, The social in social science, provides a basic overview of how social science contains deeply embedded cultural assumptions, and outlines the important relationship between philosophical thinking and practical research methods in social sciences.

Free course
15 hrs