People, Politics & Law

When your face is your fortune

Updated Monday 19th March 2007

How far will celebrities go to control their image? Surprisingly far, when your face is your fortune.

In ‘Elle: Super Business Model’, we see that Elle Macpherson is acutely aware of the value of her image.

Paul McCartney once said that when the Beatles were becoming popular, he had no idea it was possible to own a song. Today, though, legally owning songs can elevate people into multimillionaire status.

Photomanipulation showing a woman 'removing' her face Creative commons image Icon Creative commons image ♥KatB Photography♥ under CC-BY-NC licence under Creative-Commons license

In the commercial world, anything with value can be exploited, subject to the limits of the law. Where those limits are drawn is often a matter of debate. A developing area of concern is the right of celebrities to enjoy a reasonable expectation of privacy against published use of their images, and to have intellectual property in their own images.

Elle recently won a Press Complaints Commission (PCC) ruling against the magazine HELLO! because it published pictures of her sunbathing on a beach on Mustique. The photos showed her in a bikini. She asserted that she was staying in a private house with a private beach, and said that she had chosen the location in order to stay out of the public eye. The PCC accepted that, whether the beach was technically a public or private place, she had made an effort to find a private holiday spot. The PCC did not believe that that HELLO! had made a convincing case to warrant publication. So it ruled against the magazine.

Doug Pickett, of Wilmington, North Carolina, is not a household name but millions of people in many countries will recognise him. It was his face, on an advert a few years ago for a Ralph Lauren fragrance, which a great many people assumed was that of Leonardo DiCaprio. The advert did not attract litigation but the debate on how far the law should protect personal images became enlivened.

The former world-record holding 10,000m athlete, David Bedford, threatened legal action against the company responsible for the “118 118” television adverts. He claimed that the advert traded on his distinct persona including his former hairstyle, moustache and skimpy shorts. He discontinued his action but his complaint to the telecom regulator Ofcom was upheld and the company agreed not to use his image any more.

Cases alleging misuse of a real photograph of the claimant go back to 1901 but a recent development is the allegation of defamation through the photograph of a "look-alike". In 2001, the High Court rejected the claim of a woman whose friends and family were horrified to see what they thought was a photograph of her in a Sunday paper posing in an advert for a pornographic website. The photographed woman was her double. Following the human rights legal requirement to permit freedom of expression unless a restriction is "necessary in a democratic society", Mr Justice Moreland ruled that "it would impose an impossible burden on a publisher if he were required to check if the true picture of someone resembled someone else who because of the context of the picture was defamed". It would, in effect, bring an end to newspaper photos of riots, or of anyone involved in criminal cases, because all look-alikes might sue for defamation. 

Further reading

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

People, Politics & Law 

Remembering Gary Slapper

We're sad to report that Gary Slapper - founder of the OU Law School, visiting professor at The Open University and contributor to OpenLearn and Open2.net - has died.

Article

People, Politics & Law 

Could President Trump do what Candidate Trump promises in the struggle against Islamic State?

Donald Trump has been explaining how - were he to become President - he would "win" against Islamic State. But if he turns his stump pledges into action, would he be breaking international law?

Article

People, Politics & Law 

Why Brexit would be bad for employment rights

What has the EU done for employment rights, and what do we stand to lose or gain if we leave the EU?

Article

People, Politics & Law 

Harry Potter is mine… all mine!

Is copyright law justifiable? And what constitutes "fair use"?

Article

People, Politics & Law 

Rights Enshrined

What is the role of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) and the nature of its relationship with the UK Government? What impact does it have on UK law? With British membership of the European Union at the heart of the political agenda, the role of its Court of Human Rights and its influence on UK law has inevitably come under scrutiny. The coalition Government has pledged to withdraw the UK from the European convention of human rights, and to give Parliament the right to veto ECHR rulings. In these 4 films we hear from people who have taken cases to the Strasbourg court. We look at how cases are referred, what laws are used, what the process is like and what impact its judgments have had in the UK - in such high profile examples as Diane Pretty’s ‘Right to Die’ case.

Video
20 mins

People, Politics & Law 

Could Islamic law be the key to defeating ISIS?

The solution to ISIS could be offering a different interpretation of Islamic Law, says Muslim scholar Abdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im

Article

People, Politics & Law 

Statistics and the law

With clean-up rates and reoffending numbers, discussions of crime often circle back to statistics. But are these 'facts' really such reliable witnesses?

Article

People, Politics & Law 

Giving the jury a fair hearing

Has the idea of a jury of your peers had its day?

Audio

People, Politics & Law 

Sacred and Secular: Section 3 - Researching a blog entry

The sacred and secular blog is a forum for discussing issues arising from law and religion cases. The expectation is that not only will you express an opinion but that this opinion will be based on some research carried out by you on the case. This section considers how to frame questions for research purposes and how to carry out that research in order to form a blog entry. 

Article