Skip to content
Society, Politics & Law

The military in our midst

Updated Friday 24th May 2013

Taken from her openDemocracy column 'Up in Arms', Vron Ware explores the overlooked role of the ‘military wife’ as a key to interpreting far-reaching policy decisions.

The costs of Iraq and Afghanistan have frequently been calculated under broad headings of death and money: the numbers of lives lost and the expense of training, equipping and maintaining sustained warfare overseas. But non-stop combat affects the relationships between military and civilian communities at home too in ways that are not always visible. How do those of us who inhabit the belligerent Nato bloc calculate the impact of living with the military in our midst?

State armed forces constitute social institutions as well as national ones. We are used to them providing the symbolic resources that feed the very concept of a nation, embodying a particular set of values predicated on the use of lethal force and preparedness to die. But in more prosaic terms they are also employers with responsibilities for thousands of people whose lives are circumscribed by the demands of military life.

The combination of the words ‘women’ and ‘military’ usually prompts two distinct questions. First, the issue of female soldiers and whether they should be allowed access to all combat roles, a subject rather exhausted with the Pentagon’s recent decision to drop the gender bar in the US armed forces. The second question relates to the high levels of military sexual assault illustrated by the disturbing documentary, The Invisible Wall. But the focus on gender in the workplace ought not to obscure what happens in bases and garrisons where soldiers actually live.

Duty of care

In order to fully understand the social dimensions of the military, as an employer with a duty of care as well, we only have to look at its invisible support structures: the service family.

Cynthia Enloe has identified the role of what she calls the Model Military Wife – the ideal embodiment of compliance and resourcefulness who functions as the ‘bedrock’ of military culture. Military wives and girlfriends are also civilians but they operate in a strange space where they perform unpaid work for their partners’ employer. Hence the term first used by feminist anthropologists Hilary Callan and Shirley Ardener in the 1980s to describe the dynamics of the ‘incorporated wife’, whether she was married to a diplomat, businessman, politician or soldier.

Without the unquestioning loyalty of families standing behind their soldier, military institutions would simply fall apart. While the importance of the ‘service family’ is recognised in official defence doctrine and acknowledged in piecemeal reforms, there are endemic problems that remain hidden from view.

The green machine

The social lives of all military spouses is rigidly structured in accordance with partners’ rank and roles and the differences in education, income and backgrounds influence individuals’ access to support services. The partners of minorities and migrants serving in the British Army face particularly difficult challenges of isolation and loneliness as I discovered while researching my book Military Migrants.

The idea that military wives constitute a tribe of their own surfaced in the UK with the phenomenal success of the reality TV show Military Wives Choir. The show’s format was based on a project to get people singing and create community – in shops, business, hospitals, places of work. In this case, it was the wives of marines living on a base in Devon who were brought to national attention through the insistence of choirmaster Gareth Malone who persuaded them that they only had to sing to find a voice.

Military Wives singing God Save the Queen at Official Opening of the London Olympic Stadium on 5 May 2012 Creative commons image Icon Cmglee (Own work)licensed for reuse under CC-BY-SA 3.0 or GFDL under Creative-Commons license Military Wives singing God Save the Queen at Official Opening of the London Olympic Stadium on 5th May 2012

Impeccably timed to peak around the season of national remembrance in November 2011, their first song – ‘Wherever you are’ – was scripted from wives’ loving letters to their partners in Helmand. Sure enough, it topped the charts, culminating in a performance in the Royal Albert Hall at which the future king was caught on camera mopping his eyes with a royal handkerchief.

The interviews throughout the TV series captured the sense of isolation that many military wives feel. It is clear that the particular nature of the institution to whom they are hitched entails living in a psychological timewarp, not to speak of a physical one. It is little surprise that there is now a Military Wives Choirs Foundation entitled Stronger Together. The choirs form a network so that members can move from one to another when they are posted with their husbands.

Another problem is the chronic difficulty of living with partners who are simply away from home a great deal. Not only that, there is the question of ‘homecoming’, a particularly fraught period in which soldiers are expected to adapt instantly to domestic life after six months in a war zone. The online forum Rear Party, ‘the friendly sister of the Army Rumour Service for forces friends and families’, often explores these issues. A recent thread - ‘Don’t know how to feel’ – pretty much sums it up.

British Army soldiers marching in desert camouflage uniform Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Stockcube | Dreamstime.com British Army soldiers

While the media focus remains on the soldier as a hero, bemedalled, battle–scarred or increasingly down and out, the predicament of partners and children is absent. One exception is Joanna Trollope’s novel The Soldier’s Wife in which she portrayed the dilemmas of the officer class. Speaking on BBC Radio 4 Women’s Hour last year she announced that the real problem was that the men returning from Afghanistan were basically all in love with each other. Their wives were reduced to figureheads that functioned to keep them going in the heat of battle. And this was after she was permitted to do her research in a real regiment where everyone was desperate to talk.

A more tangible problem is housing. Army housing in the UK continues to be notoriously poor quality, often consisting of rows of sub-standard houses with leaking roofs, dangerous levels of dampness and horrible decor. Maintenance is contracted out to impersonal and inefficient companies. Welfare officers – usually senior NCOs out of uniform and at the end of their careers – are the first port of call for family members with housing problems and are often powerless to help, even if they want to.

The same is true in cases of domestic abuse and marital discord. The military welfare services are part of what the Army Families Federation (AFF), the ‘voice of the army family’, calls the ‘green machine’. From the spouses’ point of view, why would anyone with relationship problems seek advice from their partner’s employer? In theory the systems to address domestic abuse in military communities are in place but there is barely any publicly available research to monitor how effective they are.

Army housing near Glencorse Barracks, built in 2005 Creative commons image Icon Richard Webblicensed for reuse under CC-BY-SA 2.0 under Creative-Commons license Army housing near Glencorse Barracks, built in 2005

Latest model army

Reform is not just about modernising the social aspects of military institutions. In the UK at least, tracking the policy statements relating to spouses and families soon brings into view the ideological, material and logistical shifts that have been taking place during the last decade and a half.

In 2010 the Coalition government announced a New Model Employment policy intended to modernize the terms and conditions of military service life. Clearly driven by the need to downsize the defence sector, the new policy builds on earlier plans to integrate military communities into adjacent or surrounding civilian towns. Vast sums of money have already been spent on relocating, refurbishing and expanding military bases, up and down the country.

And for the first time, local authorities have been involved in auditing the impact of the ‘military footprint’ in terms of everything from rubbish collection to teenage pregnancies to the particular needs of army children in schools. Drawing on the emotive language of the Military Covenant campaign, first launched in 2007, the MoD administers the Armed Forces Community Covenant scheme which channels funding into local projects that bring the communities into greater contact.

One of the latest developments is a two-year ‘model employment project’, launched in April this year. According to the AFF, the aim is to improve the financial situation of families through a second income which would allow them to increase their standards of living. Importantly, they say, it will enable more families to look at buying their own homes where they might have some stability and autonomy.

All change and none

And while the regular army is being reduced and restructured, the private contractor Capita has been told to recruit thousands of part-time soldiers to emulate the US system of reservists. Another cost-cutting exercise designed to normalise the occupation of military work and to embed the military in society, the scheme for the new Army Reserve entails doubling the number from 15,000 to 30,000 by 2018.

Seasoned soldiers such as Colonel Bob Stewart, Tory MP for Beckenham, have been particularly voluble in challenging the new policy. After calling for a debate in the House of Commons he suggested that ‘someone at the MoD is smoking a lot of dope if they think they will actually manage to get the reserve up to 30,000.’

Many reservists could not be deployed overseas, he added. ‘What happens is that employers don’t want to lose their staff for up to a year, wives don’t want to lose their husbands and the blokes themselves don’t actually want to go.’

But let no one say that the UK military is not prepared to change. General Sir Peter Wall, the Chief of the General Staff, recently announced that the new plan was part of a ‘cultural reset’ that required a very different attitude towards military reservists. What was needed, he said, was ‘a cultural revolution in the way the civilian population supports the reservists, particularly in the work place’.

In an interview with the Telegraph he revealed which bits of the culture had to be re-thought and by whom: ‘The area we need to look at is the relationship between the Army and the employer…We need to have the employers on side.’ No mention of how they intend to address the different needs of the part-time military spouses and families, if at all. Presumably they count as members of the civilian population which are evidently expected to pick up the cost of the military in our midst.

This article was originally published as part of Vron's Up in Arms column on the openDemocracy website.

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Privacy rights and the law Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Privacy rights and the law

Privacy has long been recognised as an important human right, but how does society balance this right with the protection of others, such as the right to freedom of expression? This free course, Privacy rights and the law, will examine how privacy is protected in UK law and the impact on this of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Free course
20 hrs
Sacred and secular: Judge Thomas Griffith Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license video icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Sacred and secular: Judge Thomas Griffith

Preserving religious rights and the religious clauses in the United States Constitution are discussed in this video with Judge Thomas B. Griffith. 

Video
10 mins
Languages of class Creative commons image Icon By Chris Jones via Flickr under Creative Commons license under Creative-Commons license article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Languages of class

The Open University's Geoff Andrews explores the revived interest in class

Article
Shades of grey - legitimate or illegitimate? Creative commons image Icon The Open University under Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license activity icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Shades of grey - legitimate or illegitimate?

Opinions differ about activities such as fracking, genetically modified foods or foie gras, often leading to controversy. Are these activities legitimate or not? What do you think? 

Activity
Human rights and law Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission free course icon Level 1 icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Human rights and law

Human rights now seem to take precedent over many areas of our lives, but where do these rights come from and how did they develop? This free course, Human rights and the law, looks at the impact of the European Convention on Human Rights and its influence on law in the UK and examines the Human Rights Act 1998.

Free course
20 hrs
Saudi Arabia is paying a heavy price for Iran’s global rehabilitation Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Artwork by Catherine Pain © The Open University article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Saudi Arabia is paying a heavy price for Iran’s global rehabilitation

Saudi Arabia is paying a heavy price for its role in escalating the tension in Saudi-Iranian relations, which has been felt far beyond the Middle East.

Article
Nationalisms – the whys and the wherefores… Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Dreamstime article icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Nationalisms – the whys and the wherefores…

OU academic Wendy Maples talks with journalist activist Joe Makepeace about the changes to nationalism in the UK and the significance of nationalist sentiment during the ‘Jubilympic’ celebration

Article
PodMag September 2016 Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: The Open University audio icon

Society, Politics & Law 

PodMag September 2016

PodMag is the monthly update of news, views and interviews from the Faculty of Social Sciences and Arts (FASS) at The Open University.

Audio
20 mins
Waste not, want not? Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Paper bales image (c) Philnik | Dreamstime.com activity icon

Society, Politics & Law 

Waste not, want not?

Despite it being part of our everyday lives, waste management is a mystery to many. Try our quiz to test your knowledge.  

Activity