OU on the BBC: The Other Medicine - Programme 3: Does It Matter How CAM Works?

Updated Tuesday 14th September 2004

In the third programme in the BBC/OU series The Other Medicine, Anna Ford explores the role of the placebo effect

Anna Ford samples some CAM Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Used with permission Are therapies like homeopathy or aromatherapy nothing more than elaborate placebos? If they work by some other mechanisms, what are they? And if they do work, does it really matter how they work?

In the scientific world, mechanism does matter. Without a plausible, testable mechanism, scientists are not impressed. That is why so many scientists are not convinced by homeopathy (where treatments are often so dilute that they are nothing more than water), or acupuncture (where there is no anatomical or physiological evidence for the “energy channels” on which the therapy depends). We hear from scientists and therapists who have tried to establish mechanisms for these therapies in formal experiments, and from practitioners who explain the importance – or otherwise – of understanding the “mechanisms”. Is there room for “alternative sciences”, such as those proposed by Lynn McTaggart, to explain the basis for CAM?

Dr Peter Fisher, president of the Faculty of Homeopathy, explains how homeopathy works in terms of an analogy - solutions hold a memory of the active substance just as video tapes hold pictures, so scientists analysing tape would only see iron particles, not images. Is it important, even if the effect is a type of placebo, for patients to have some image or concept in their mind of how the therapy is working? Why do some mainstream doctors, and others in the scientific community, get so worked up about mechanisms?

When doctors test a new treatment, they conclude that it works only when patients who receive it fare significantly better than those given a dummy treatment, or placebo. That’s because many patients feel better, no matter which one they receive. But having once written off the placebo effect as “no effect”, scientists are now discovering that the placebo effect can be very powerful indeed. Whatever the placebo effect really is, could it hold the secret mechanism for some complementary therapies? And if CAM is a sort of placebo, how do we explain the evidence that it can work in animals? We talk to one of the many vets who use CAM to treat their animal patients. And how do doctors who dismiss homeopathic remedies as “just water” explain the fact that trials show patients can often develop side effects?

We explore some of the latest biological theories which try to explain the placebo effect. Sir Ian Chalmers, past Director of the Cochrane Centre, explains that the size of the effect is determined by the way a patient and doctor interact, how a patient feels about their care, and what he or she is expecting from a therapy. And whether it’s conventional or alternative therapy, it’s now clear that patients and therapists need to believe that it will work. We also know that the more elaborate the therapy, the greater the effect. So with longer consultations and a more patient-centred, holistic approach, could it be that CAM therapies are simply tapping into this powerful placebo effect in a much more effective way than conventional medicine? And does that necessarily devalue it in some way? We ask patients, therapists, and sceptical physician Dr Roger Fisken, for their opinions.


This website is provided for general information only, and should not be treated as a substitute for the medical advice of your own doctor or any other health care professional. The BBC and the Open University are not responsible or liable for any diagnosis made by a user based on the content of the OpenLearn website. The BBC and the Open University are not liable for the contents of any external internet sites listed, nor do they endorse any commercial product or service mentioned or advised on any of the sites. Always consult your own GP if you're in any way concerned about your health.

First broadcast: Tuesday 21 Sep 2004 on BBC Radio 4

 

For further information, take a look at our frequently asked questions which may give you the support you need.

Have a question?

Other content you may like

Why are maggots making a comeback in hospitals? Creative commons image Icon Dean Morley under Creative Commons BY-ND 4.0 license article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

Why are maggots making a comeback in hospitals?

The use of maggots to clean a wound is being given a second look by some doctors. An ancient treatment with strong 21st century applications is investigated by Carrie Arnold.

Article
The sceptical scientist Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: photos.com article icon

Health, Sports & Psychology 

The sceptical scientist

OU chemist Peter Taylor takes a scientific approach to alternative therapies

Article
OU on TV and radio this week - 12-10-13 to 19-10-13 Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on TV and radio this week - 12-10-13 to 19-10-13

Chris Packham in the forest; Michael Moseley with some poison; summer wildlife and Evan Davis talking weapons of war.

Article
2012 on OpenLearn Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Dreamstime article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

2012 on OpenLearn

Coming in 2012: new learning materials from the programmes we make with the BBC

Article
Wild Weather with Richard Hammond - Water: The shape shifter Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Wild Weather with Richard Hammond - Water: The shape shifter

The crucial role water plays is explored in this episode where Richard Hammond starts an avalanche. 

Article
OU on the BBC: Everyday Miracles - Away Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on the BBC: Everyday Miracles - Away

After delving in to the vital materials encompassing the world around us, Mark Miodownik explores how these have made us go further and travel faster.

Article
ATLAS presents... New Maps For An Island Planet Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: BBC article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

ATLAS presents... New Maps For An Island Planet

Join the OU's Doreen Massey and guests for an exploration of how we navigate through a world as it changes rapidly.

Article
Charles Dickens: Celebrity Author Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: iStock audio icon

TV, Radio & Events 

Charles Dickens: Celebrity Author

As Britain marks the 200th anniversary of the birth of Charles Dickens, we delve into his world with these audio tracks

Audio
5 mins
OU on the BBC: More or Less - HPV Vaccine, Qatar migrant workers and chocolate diets Copyrighted image Icon Copyright: Thodonal | Dreamstime.com article icon

TV, Radio & Events 

OU on the BBC: More or Less - HPV Vaccine, Qatar migrant workers and chocolate diets

Tim Harford and the More or Less team investigate the numbers behin the side-effects of the HPV vaccine, deaths of migrant workers in Qatar and look at the story behind the chocolate experiment designed to fool the press. 

Article