Assessment in secondary geography

# 1.1 Notions of progression

Progression takes place over a number of timescales: across a sequence of lessons; a year; a key stage. You have to decide how to structure teaching and assessment over these timescales in order to support students’ progression in learning.

Progression can be considered in relation to the learning experiences planned by the teacher:

- increasing breadth of study
- wider range of scales studied
- greater complexity of phenomena studied
- introducing more precise geographical terminology and vocabulary
- increasing use of generalised knowledge and abstract ideas, particularly through making connections and comprehending relationships (Weeden, 2013, p. 147)
- requiring greater precision in undertaking intellectual and practical tasks
- a more mature awareness and understanding of issues and of the context of differing attitudes and values within which they arise.

Progress will be apparent if students are ready for more demanding teaching and learning experiences. Progression can also be viewed in terms of student performance (achievement against mark schemes and grade criteria for specific units of work or GCSE or A Levels).

To help students make progress, you need to have a clear understanding of the learning that they need to do, where they are now and how best to help them bridge the gap. Assessment is, therefore, a key component of planning for progression. Individual students vary in the rate at which they progress, according to their individual interests and abilities, the learning and teaching styles employed and the nature and structure of the activity. Assessment should be designed so that all students have an opportunity to demonstrate their progress and so that you can plan to address individuals’ learning needs.

The following activity allows you to consider proposals from the Geographical Association (GA) for integrated planning for progression and assessment.

## Activity 2 Assessment and progression – views from the GA

Allow about 1 hour

In England, the Geographical Association is concerned that an emphasis on locational and place knowledge, human and physical processes in the Geography National Curriculum (GNC) 2014 will erode notions of progression in curriculum and assessment planning. They have published a framework to address their concerns. The discussion of the proposals related to assessment and progression will be relevant to teachers whether they work in England or elsewhere.

1. If you want to know more about the context of assessment and progression in England prior to the introduction of the GNC in 2014, read Lambert’s (2010) think piece on progression, which has a short discussion and some useful appendices.

2. Download and save An assessment and progression framework for geography (Geographical Association, 2014a) and the accompanying PowerPoint presentation, Progression and assessment without levels (Geographical Association, 2014b). You will use these again in Activity 4.

   Read the following sections: ‘A clear vision’ and ‘The framework’. Also look at the framework diagram on page 4. Read slides 1–12 and 28 in the PowerPoint presentation and the accompanying notes.

   What does the Geographical Association see as possible benefits of the framework advocated here?

(A text entry box would appear here, but your browser does not support it.)

## Discussion

The Geographical Association says:

- The framework seeks to address concerns that an emphasis on graded assessments encouraged a labelling culture (students saw themselves as being a Level 4b, etc.). This could place a ‘ceiling’ on student progress.
- The use of levels can encourage teachers and students to ‘race through’ the levels and see learning as a linear process.

Emphasis is placed on the following:

- progress through ‘revisiting places and topics in ways that build depth of knowledge and understanding rather than a simple step-by-step process’
- decisions at the school level in terms of assessment policies and teachers’ roles in contextualising expectations to develop assessment criteria that will make sense to students.

OpenLearn - Assessment in secondary geography
Except for third party materials and otherwise, this content is made available under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 Licence, full copyright detail can be found in the acknowledgements section. Please see full copyright statement for details.