Evolution: artificial selection and domestication
Evolution: artificial selection and domestication

This free course is available to start right now. Review the full course description and key learning outcomes and create an account and enrol if you want a free statement of participation.

Free course

Evolution: artificial selection and domestication

2.3 Skin pigmentation and pattern

Most domesticated livestock differ from their wild ancestors in the colour and pattern of the skin, hair or feathers.

SAQ 10

  • What gene-associated factors determine the colour of feathers in modern birds?

Answer

Melanin and other pigments are synthesised and become incorporated into the feather early in its development. Different-coloured feathers can emerge from the same follicle in successive moults, showing that this process is modulated by hormones especially, but not exclusively, sex hormones.

Figure 5
Figures 5a, b: Copyright © Mike Dodd; Figure 5c, d: Copyright © Caroline Pond
Figure 5 Wild animals that closely resemble the ancestors of some domesticated mammals. (a) Pigs. (b) Timber or grey wolf. (c) ‘Aurochs’; this zoo animal is an artificially bred reconstruction of the now-extinct wild ancestor of European domesticated cattle. (d) Przewalski's wild horse, which was widespread throughout Europe and Asia in the Pleistocene but is now confined to a small area of Mongolia in central Asia

Most mammals, including extant descendants of the wild ancestors of domesticated species, are brown or black (Figure 5), or have markings that conform to consistent patterns (Figure 6). Many domesticated mammals and birds are white or piebald or skewbald (see Figures 2 and 3): pigs, sheep, horses, cattle (Figures 1 and 7) and dogs and cats (Figure 8) often have irregular and asymmetrical spots and blotches but very rarely the regular, symmetrical patterns seen in wild mammals (Figure 6). (Piebald (= black-and-white) and skewbald (= any other colour and white) are mostly frequently applied to horses, but as this section explains, very similar patterns are found in a wide variety of other domesticated species. These terms are still correct only for livestock; the equivalent term for wild animals is pied, e.g. pied wagtail.)

Figure 6
Figure 6a, b, d: Copyright © Caroline Pond; Figure 6c: Copyright © C. J. Eaton
Figure 6 Patterned wild mammals: (a) zebra (Equus burchelli); (b) giraffe (Giraffa camelopardalis); (c) tiger (Panthera tigris); (d) fallow deer (Dama dama)

Such irregularly patterned hair and plumage has appeared spontaneously among many lineages of livestock. Farmers and pet fanciers selectively bred preferred animals, producing ‘pure’ strains of livestock. For example, sheep have been bred so that the fleece is usually a uniform creamy white (Figures 1d and Figure 9a), but the occasional exceptions (Figure 9b) are still common and viable, and the faces and legs of those with white fleeces are often black (Figure 9c) or mottled (Figures 1d and Figure 9d). Note the similarity in the speckled patterns of these sheep and that of some dogs (Figure 8d). The patterns of ‘belted’ pigs and cattle (Figure 7 a and b) are also remarkably similar.

Figure 7
Figure 7a, b, c, e: Copyright © Caroline Pond; Figure 7d: Copyright © Mike Dodd
Figure 7 Piebald and skewbald domesticated mammals: (a) belted pigs; (b) belted bullock; (c) Friesian cows; (d) spotted piglets; (e) skewbald mare and foal
Figure 8
Figure 8a, c: Copyright © Caroline Pond; Figure 8b: Copyright © Mandy Dyson; Figure 8d: Copyright © Mike Dodd
Figure 8 Piebald and skewbald dogs and cat: (a) Dalmatian; (b) collie sheepdog; (c) Shih-tzu, an ancient oriental breed related to Pekinese dogs; (d) pointer; (e) piebald cat

Mottled and white feathers are also common in birds that have been bred under domestication (Figure 10). Domestic fowl are order Galliformes, related to peafowl and pheasants; the breeding plumage of male galliforms is almost always colourful and elaborate, but that of females is speckled brown because they and they alone incubate the eggs and protect the chicks. For similar reasons, the plumage of mallards and many other ducks (order Anseriformes) is sexually dimorphic, at least during the breeding season.

Figure 9
Figure 9: Copyright © Caroline Pond
Figure 9 Various domesticated sheep
Figure 10
Figures 10a(i), (iii), (iv), b(i), c: Copyright © Caroline Pond; 10a(ii), 10b(ii): Copyright © Mike Dodd
Figure 10 White or pied domesticated birds compared to their wild relatives. (a) Domestic poultry: (i) brown hens; (ii) adult male inbreeding plumage similar to that of the wild ancestors; (iii) adult male (left) and female (right) that are white with some pied neck feathers; (iv) adults of a pure white breed. Note that none of these birds is true albino: all have red combs and pigmented beaks and legs. (b) (i) Greylag geese (Anser anser) that are the ancestors of (ii) European domestic geese. (c) Indian peacocks (Pavo cristatus), with plumage of natural breeding colours (i), and white domesticated forms (ii)

Question 3

Why would white plumage in poultry (Figure 10a) and peacocks (Figure 10c) during the breeding season be eliminated by natural selection in (a) males and (b) females?

Discussion

  • (a) Males without the species-specific breeding plumage would attract very few females and would be unlikely to succeed in male-male rivalry.

  • (b) Conspecific males may be unable to recognise white females as members of their own species. Predators would more easily notice white females brooding eggs on a nest than well camouflaged hens.

Question 4

What features of the plumage of the peacocks (Figure 10c) show that the only difference between the wild and domesticated forms is pigmentation, i.e. the mechanism of formation of the feathers is unaltered?

Discussion

The crown of feathers on the head and the long tail feathers are the same sizes and shapes in both the wild-type and white birds. Feather size and shape are determined by elaborately controlled proliferation, maturation and death of keratinocytes. A distinct lineage of cells, the pigment cells, synthesise various coloured molecules, or none, and may or may not be incorporated into the developing feather. If the pigment cells are absent or inactive, the feathers are white.

S366_1

Take your learning further

Making the decision to study can be a big step, which is why you'll want a trusted University. The Open University has 50 years’ experience delivering flexible learning and 170,000 students are studying with us right now. Take a look at all Open University courses.

If you are new to university level study, find out more about the types of qualifications we offer, including our entry level Access courses and Certificates.

Not ready for University study then browse over 900 free courses on OpenLearn and sign up to our newsletter to hear about new free courses as they are released.

Every year, thousands of students decide to study with The Open University. With over 120 qualifications, we’ve got the right course for you.

Request an Open University prospectus