3.4 Two-particle spin states

If we have two indistinguishable[1] electrons, we can define a two-particle spin state. Due to symmetry and the rules of quantum mechanical addition of angular momentum, there are four possible spin states in total. These spin states are represented using the quantum numbers cap s and cap m sub s, as introduced in Section 3.1, but now the quantum numbers are the sum of the values for the individual electrons. Therefore the spin quantum number is equation sequence part 1 cap s equals part 2 one divided by two plus one divided by two equals part 3 one or equation sequence part 1 cap s equals part 2 one divided by two minus one divided by two equals part 3 zero and, for the case when cap s equals one, the spin magnetic quantum is equation sequence part 1 cap m sub s equals part 2 prefix plus minus of one divided by two plus minus one divided by two equals part 3 negative one or zero or prefix plus of one, while for the case when cap s equals zero, we only have equation sequence part 1 cap m sub s equals part 2 prefix plus of one divided by two minus one divided by two equals part 3 zero.

Such a two-particle spin state therefore can only have an overall spin function which is either symmetric or antisymmetric with respect to exchange of the electrons. The symmetric spin state is referred to as a triplet because there are three possible symmetric combinations:

multiline equation row 1 vertical line one comma one mathematical right angle bracket equals vertical line up arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket row 2 vertical line one comma zero mathematical right angle bracket equals one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket postfix plus vertical line down arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket right parenthesis row 3 vertical line one comma negative one mathematical right angle bracket equals vertical line down arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket

where the first arrow in each ket refers to particle 1 and the second to particle 2. The antisymmetric spin state is referred to as a singlet because there is only one possible combination:

absolute value of zero comma zero mathematical right angle bracket equals one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket postfix minus postfix down arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket right parenthesis
Equation label:(10)

You can see that the states vertical line up arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket and vertical line down arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket can be factorised into absolute value of up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two and absolute value of down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two respectively, where the subscripts label each particle. In contrast, the states one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket postfix plus vertical line down arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket right parenthesis and one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket postfix minus vertical line down arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket right parenthesis cannot be factorised into the product of a particle 1 state multiplied by a particle 2 state. Two-particle states which cannot be factorised are known as entangled states and said to exhibit entanglement.

Exercise 10

Verify that the three spin kets

multiline equation row 1 vertical line one comma one mathematical right angle bracket equals vertical line up arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket comma row 2 vertical line one comma zero mathematical right angle bracket equals one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket postfix plus vertical line down arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket right parenthesis comma row 3 vertical line one comma negative one mathematical right angle bracket equals vertical line down arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket

are symmetric with respect to swapping the labels of the particles.

Answer

Starting with

one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket plus absolute value of down arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket right parenthesis equals one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two prefix plus of absolute value of down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two right parenthesis comma

exchanging the particle labels and then rearranging gives

multiline equation row 1 one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two times absolute value of down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one plus down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two vertical line up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one right parenthesis multirelation equals one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one times absolute value of up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two plus up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one vertical line down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two right parenthesis row 2 multirelation equals one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one times absolute value of down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two plus down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one vertical line up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two right parenthesis row 3 equals one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket postfix plus vertical line down arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket right parenthesis full stop

Since this final expression is identical to the initial expression, this shows one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket postfix plus vertical line down arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket right parenthesis is symmetric to swapping particle labels.

For absolute value of up arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket equals up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one vertical line up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two and absolute value of down arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket equals down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one vertical line down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two the particle labels are interchanged and re-ordered (perfectly acceptable!) to get the same expressions as required.

  • 1 Particles are indistinguishable when they are identical (i.e. they have the same intrinsic properties like mass, charge, and spin) and they are so close together that their wavefunctions overlap so that we cannot tell them apart, even in principle.