3.5 Entanglement

Entanglement is a consequence of quantum theory and leads to a correlation between the outcomes of measurements which cannot be explained by classical physics. Two-particle states which show such non-classical correlations are known as entangled states.

Consider the following thought experiment. Suppose you have a two-particle system in the spin state vertical line zero comma zero mathematical right angle bracket as given in Equation 10. Before the experiment you know that particle 1 can be either spin-up or spin-down with equal probability. However, if you measure particle 1 to be spin-up then you know that particle 2 is spin-down as the measurement means that the two-particle state has collapsed into the vertical line up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket arrangement of spins. In contrast, if you measure particle 1 to be spin-down then you know that particle 2 is spin-up as the two-particle state has collapsed into the vertical line down arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket arrangement of spins. This type of prediction is quite puzzling because the two entangled particles can be as far apart as possible and when a measurement is made on particle 1 then it is known simultaneously what the outcome of a measurement on particle 2 will be.

Entanglement is essential for quantum computing. Entangled states are generated as part of the workings of a quantum computer, as you will see later.

Exercise 11

Confirm that the following states are normalised and determine whether the states are entangled.

  1. absolute value of cap b mathematical right angle bracket equals one divided by Square root of two postfix up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket negative one divided by Square root of two vertical line up arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket
  2. absolute value of cap c mathematical right angle bracket equals one divided by two postfix up arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket negative one divided by Square root of two times absolute value of up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket negative i divided by two postfix down arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket

Answer

The normalisation condition for a general two-particle state is that the sum of the squares of the probability amplitudes is equal to 1.

The states are entangled if the two-particle state cannot be factorised into the product of a particle 1 state multiplied by a particle 2 state.

  1. Checking the normalisation of state vertical line cap b mathematical right angle bracket:

    equation sequence part 1 absolute value of one divided by Square root of two squared plus absolute value of negative one divided by Square root of two squared equals part 2 one divided by two plus one divided by two equals part 3 one comma

    showing state vertical line cap b mathematical right angle bracket is normalised.

    vertical line cap b mathematical right angle bracket can also be factorised:

    multiline equation row 1 vertical line cap b mathematical right angle bracket equals one divided by Square root of two times absolute value of up arrow down arrow mathematical right angle bracket negative one divided by Square root of two postfix up arrow up arrow mathematical right angle bracket row 2 multirelation equals one divided by Square root of two times left parenthesis vertical line up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one times absolute value of down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two minus up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one vertical line up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two right parenthesis row 3 multirelation equals one divided by Square root of two times absolute value of up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub one left parenthesis vertical line down arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two postfix minus up arrow mathematical right angle bracket sub two right parenthesis

    which is a particle 1 state multiplied by a particle 2 state so state vertical line cap b mathematical right angle bracket is not entangled.

  2. Checking the normalisation of state vertical line cap c mathematical right angle bracket:

    equation sequence part 1 sum with 3 summands absolute value of one divided by two squared plus absolute value of negative one divided by Square root of two squared plus absolute value of i divided by two squared equals part 2 sum with 3 summands one divided by four plus one divided by two plus one divided by four equals part 3 one comma

    showing state vertical line cap c mathematical right angle bracket is normalised.

    State vertical line cap c mathematical right angle bracket cannot be factorised and so is an entangled state.