7.1.2 Different decision-makers

The criminal courts are concerned with wrongs done to the community as a whole. They therefore involve lay people (non-lawyers) from the community, who sit as jurors and magistrates.

Because the civil courts are concerned with private disputes between individuals, they do not need to involve lay people. Decisions are almost always made by legally-qualified judges.

Court decision-makers

Criminal courts  

Magistrates’ courts

A panel of lay magistrates or a legally trained district judge decide questions of law and fact

Crown Court

A legally trained judge decides questions of law

A lay jury decides questions of fact (i.e. whether the defendant is guilty or not guilty)

Civil courts  

County Court

A legally trained judge decides questions of law and fact

High Court

A legally trained judge decides questions of law and fact