
Stage (2020) summarises three main changes since the 1990s which have affected the ways in which universities are run. Firstly, there has been pressure to deliver public services such as education more cost-effectively. Secondly, there has been a shift within universities towards a professionalised, centralised management where academic staff play a far smaller role. Thirdly, the introduction of education policies which have emphasised competition and consumer choice, meaning that universities are required to compete with one another for students and funding. Below, you will learn more detail about each of these changes.
The neoliberal (free-market) economic policies that have become dominant in much of the world since the early 1980s have resulted in changes in UK government approaches to the management of public sector institutions such as the National Health Service, local government, and schools, as well as universities.
These changes were aimed at modernising public services and making them more efficient by introducing private-sector management techniques such as performance measurement, competition, market mechanisms, strategic leadership, and audit-based accountability to the sector in order to provide greater accountability and value for money-an approach known as New Public Management (NPM) (Ferlie et al 1996; Deem et al 2007).
For universities, this was a significant change, meaning that they became much less autonomous as the state became more involved in their governance (Barnett 2011; Shattock 2006). Like other public sector institutions, HEIs found themselves facing increased expectations to demonstrate that they were delivering value for money with respect to the substantial public funding they received (Schofield 2009; Clarke 2004). In return for this funding, universities became subject to greater external scrutiny and accountability, with governments increasingly seeking to influence institutional priorities and monitor performance.
Historically, university systems of governance had made clear distinctions between ‘academic’ governance and ‘corporate’ governance (Schofield 2009, p.6). Academic governance, as you saw above, is usually the role of a senate or academic board made up of university staff, which oversees research and teaching (Schofield 2009, p.6). Theoretically, this approach ensures that ‘decisions on academic issues [are] taken by academic staff’ (Schofield 2009, p.6),
However, in 1985 the Jarratt Report recommended that universities should be managed more like corporations, with vice-chancellors acting as chief executives, and governing bodies taking a more strategic role (Schofield 2009, p.7). In 1992, new legislation, the Further and Higher Education Act 1992 embedded this in law. It created a more unified HE funding system by establishing Higher Education Funding Councils, and allowed for the establishment of new universities- the ‘post-1992 universities’ referred to in Section 2.2. The governing bodies of these new universities had greater powers and responsibilities. They were smaller than the traditional councils, and they were required to recruit a majority of external members (Schofield 2009, p.7). The effect was to centralise power within the university, and to reduce the influence of academic staff on university governance (Schofield 2009, p.8).
The third key shift identified by Stage (2020) and others was the gradual marketisation of the HE sector- a series of policy changes that positioned universities as competitors in a market. Although this didn’t mean that universities became private businesses, it did mean that public universities, while continuing to be largely state-funded, competed against one another for students, research income and reputation. One policy that cemented this approach was the introduction of student fees in 2006-7 (Schofield 2009; Shattock 2024). This meant that, instead of the government funding university teaching, the cost was passed to students, who took out loans to pay their fees. At the same time, the Government removed the cap on the numbers of UK-domiciled students who could study in each institution, with the effect that universities were put into direct competition with each other to attract students (Shattock, 2024).
Fee arrangements differ across the four nations, and the position described here is specific to England. If you are studying or working in Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland, your institution operates under a different funding settlement.
In this competitive environment, UK universities became subject to a growing range of performance measures. Various metrics and league tables were established against which universities could monitor their performance, such as: