Skip to main content

Managing your supervisors and other professional relationships

4. Navigating the supervisory relationship

4.1. Managing difficulties in your relationship with your supervisors

Blips and hiccups

Supervisor–student relationships rarely work completely smoothly and you will probably experience what Churchill and Sanders (2007, p. 48) call ‘blips’ or ‘hiccups’. These are temporary and usually trivial disturbances in the relationship that arise as a result of miscommunications and unclear expectations. They can usually be resolved by having an informal meeting where you raise your worries and listen to your supervisors’ responses. This is the kind of ‘relationship talk’ mentioned in Section 1.1 that is good practice in ‘relationships for themselves’. As you’ll know from your other professional and personal relationships, clearing the air is usually all that is needed in order to move forward productively.

As well as talking things through with your supervisors, it can really help to talk things through with other colleagues. Many universities allocate PGRs an independent advisor (sometimes called a PGR tutor, graduate tutor, academic advisor or mentor), so that they have someone outside of their supervisory team they can bring queries and concerns to. If this is the case in your institution, it’s a good idea to cultivate a positive working relationship with this person  early on, so that if you do need to use them as a sounding board, they are already well-briefed about your project and circumstances. You might also want to talk to the academic in charge of PGRs in your School or Faculty, or another academic with whom you have a good working relationship.

Your supervisors’ other research students are another source of potentially useful information about how to negotiate your relationship with them. It can be a good idea to compare notes with other students about how they find your supervisor’s style and what approaches work best.

Culture gaps

Another source of (usually minor) difficulties in relationships between students and supervisors has to do with culture gaps. These can arise when the student and their supervisors are approaching their relationship with differing sets of expectations about how educational relationships should work. If this is the case for you, it may be useful to spend a bit of time reading and thinking about cultural intelligence (see Ang and Van Dyne, 2015; Livermore, 2011). 

A useful concept in this literature that may be helpful as you navigate your relationship with your supervisors is power distance. This concept describes the different ways that cultures organise relationships between people in hierarchical systems. For example, many UK supervisors are from cultures with low power distance. This means that they are uncomfortable with overt expressions of hierarchy and authority and are most at ease when relationships are kept informal – it is almost universal in the UK that PhD supervisors expect their students to call them by their first name rather than by their title. They may be happy to socialise with their students and with informal methods of communication such as text or instant message.

In contrast, many students are from cultures with high power distance. This means that they are most comfortable keeping a fairly formal relationship with authority figures such as supervisors. They may feel uncomfortable being on first-name terms with their supervisors and may prefer a more formal approach to supervision and communication, for example addressing their supervisors as ‘Dr’/‘Professor’. Obviously these differences in expectations and approaches aren’t anyone’s fault and are unlikely to change, but having the language to describe them can really help with navigating them effectively, so reading up on cultural intelligence is recommended if you’re finding that culture gaps are causing awkwardness in your relationships with your supervisors.

Disruption

You may find that your relationship with your supervisor is disrupted by events in their life that may interfere with their ability to supervise you. They may take parental leave, experience long-term sickness, or move to a different institution. If this happens, the rest of your supervisory team and your faculty will usually liaise to appoint you a temporary or permanent replacement supervisor. You will usually be consulted during this process, and you may wish to suggest academics who you think would make good replacement supervisors. 

Serious concerns

Most issues in student–supervisor relationships fall into the above categories of ‘blips and hiccups’ and ‘disruptions’, but sometimes a relationship deteriorates to the point where the student has serious concerns. If you feel that you are not being appropriately supported or that your relationship with your supervisor(s) has become difficult, then there are various ways to move forward with this. 

In the first instance an informal approach is recommended which involves speaking to your supervisory team themselves, perhaps to their other students and to your independent advisor. If this approach doesn’t yield results, then you may need to take more formal action via formal complaint procedures.

Now that you have considered some common issues in student–supervisor relationships, Activity 5 will help you think about the kinds of action you might advise a peer to take in different situations.

Activity 5: Relationship case studies 

Allow approximately 30 minutes for this activity.

The scenarios below describe some problems arising in the relationships between PGRs and their supervisors.

Example 1: Annika 

Annika gets on well with her supervisor Mick, but Mick is very busy, travels a lot internationally and isn’t good at responding to emails. Annika sent Mick a chapter of her thesis to read six weeks ago but hasn’t heard anything back from him despite chasing him several times.

When she does hear back from him, she finds that he has only commented on the first and last few pages of her chapter, leaving very little feedback on the pages in between.

What would you advise Annika to do?

View Comment

Annika has several options here. Since she gets on well with Mick it would probably be a good idea to arrange a meeting with him to talk through how things are going. She could raise the issue of his scant feedback on her chapter and talk to him about how the delays in getting feedback are affecting her ability to work to schedule.

Annika could also seek out Mick’s other students and ask them how they are finding working with him. It may be that other students have tips for getting the best out of Mick – he might not be responsive to emails, but happy to receive prompts by text, for example. Her independent advisor will be another good source of advice and will be able to help Annika decide whether this is an issue that she can resolve herself or whether she needs to take more formal action.


Example 2: Ben

Ben has three supervisors. One of them, Kathryn, is an expert in the particular analytic techniques Ben is taking to his research, while the other two have expertise more broadly related to his topic.

Towards the end of his first year, Kathryn leaves the university and a new supervisor is appointed to replace her. The new supervisor, Andrew, has similar technical expertise to Kathryn but takes a very different theoretical approach. He wants Ben to redesign his study to reflect his theoretical and methodological preferences as he thinks this will result in a better outcome. Ben doesn’t want to do this as he is currently preparing for his upgrade assessment and would rather focus on this important milestone.

What would you advise Ben to do?

View Comment

This is a difficult situation for Ben and we’d recommend that he starts by asking all three supervisors to meet with him to discuss Andrew’s proposed changes to his project. He could prepare for this meeting by talking through his concerns with his independent advisor. If he feels it’s appropriate, he may have a private chat with one of his existing supervisors to raise his concerns in a more informal setting and get a sense of whether the other supervisor shares his view or is able to offer some reassurance.

At the meeting with the supervisors, Ben should set out how the proposed changes will affect the project timeline and his ability to complete the upgrade process. The fact that his upgrade assessment is looming is actually an advantage here, as the process is designed to ensure that projects are well-designed and likely to be completed on time. He could write up his current methodological dilemma in his upgrade report and seek advice from the assessors about how to move forward. It may be that Andrew has a good point and that his revisions would improve the project so substantially that it is worth any ensuing delay. Or it might be that the team need to persuade Andrew that it is best for Ben to complete the project as planned.

Reflecting on the ‘road not taken’ will in either case provide Ben with the basis of an interesting discussion chapter for his thesis. In the meantime, getting the opinion of other experts will help Ben and his supervisors to work out the best thing to do.