
Fair dealing applies to exceptions in UK copyright law that allow you, under certain specific circumstances, to use copyrighted works without the need to seek permission from the owner. It’s important to know what these limitations are and how your thesis will be subject to more stringent restrictions as it will be published on an institutional repository. Here are some of the exceptions:
Fair dealing can relate to a whole copyright work or part of one and is tested by asking whether your use of that work would be fair. A whole work or large part of a work may be considered ‘substantial’ and a small part of a work ‘insubstantial’. The concept of ‘insubstantial use’ will be vitally important to your thesis and will support the non-commercial research element of the available exceptions. As your thesis will likely be openly accessible worldwide, all other exceptions should not be relied upon for your thesis due to the variations in type and application from country to country. If you feel your use of a work risks infringement, always check with your university’s copyright specialist if you are unsure.
If you are using a substantial part of a copyrighted work, you must seek permission. But what does substantial mean in this context?
An example of a substantial use would be the reproduction of whole images, articles and poems. Using short extracts or quotes that do not constitute a substantial part of a longer work may be copied. It is important to note that substance is down to quality and quantity; for example, you must not give away the essence of the work. Some institutions and publishers use rules of thumb to help judge whether an extract is likely to be insubstantial. These figures have no legal force, since UK fair dealing has no fixed word limits and every use is judged on whether it is fair in the circumstances, but they give a sense of the scale usually considered reasonable. Your own institution may publish different figures, and you should always check with your university’s copyright specialist rather than relying on these alone:
Check with your university’s copyright specialist for guidance and always ask yourself if your use will be fair. If your use of a copyrighted work has the potential to impact the copyright owner financially, or you have used more than you need to illustrate an academic point, your use may be considered substantial.
Allow approximately 10 minutes for this activity.
In your thesis you have decided to reproduce several extracts from Edith Hall’s 1999 translation of the play, Antigone, written by Sophocles c. 442 BCE.
Is this permitted?
Edith Hall’s translation is a contemporary literary work and in copyright, even though the original Greek play is in the public domain. However, extracts can be reproduced if they are an insubstantial part of the copyrighted work. Be cautious about what you use and remember that the substance is in the content of the extracts as well as the length of the extracts.