Why would a researcher choose to combine quantitative and qualitative approaches in a single study? What does each approach reveal, and what might it miss? And how do your underlying beliefs about knowledge and reality shape the methods that you consider are legitimate?
This unit introduces the core rationale for mixed methods research through a concrete scenario about staff turnover in an organisation. You will explore the philosophical foundations (ontology, epistemology and axiology) that underpin all research design, and discover how these concepts connect to practical methodological choices. By the end of this unit you will have a framework for understanding why different researchers approach the same question in different ways, and why combining approaches can sometimes offer a more complete picture.
By the end of this unit, you will be able to:
Estimated study time for this unit: 1 hour.
Imagine you are researching why staff leave your organisation. Two researchers approach this question differently:
Here is the key insight: both findings are valid. Both are ‘true’. The researchers are looking at the same phenomenon through different lenses.
The survey tells you what people say; the conversations reveal what they actually mean. ‘Workload’ was the word that respondents used but ‘support’ was the need they had.
Each finding on its own offers a valid snapshot of the problem. But in isolation, each tells only part of the story. Put together, they reveal a deeper and more interconnected dynamic at play. The quantitative data shows the scale; the qualitative data unpacks the meaning behind it.
This is the value of mixed methods research. Complex social phenomena rarely have simple, single-dimension explanations. Combining approaches allows researchers to move beyond surface-level findings and explore the layers beneath.
Your beliefs about what is real and how we can know things shape which approach feels right to you. Those beliefs are what we call your paradigm, and understanding paradigms is the first step to making informed methodological choices.
Think about a research question that you are currently exploring, or one that you might investigate in the future.
Make some notes in the space below. There is no model answer for this reflection; the purpose is to begin connecting these ideas to your own research context.
A paradigm is your worldview: the set of beliefs that guide how you approach problems. It shapes what you consider worth studying, what methods and types of data you see as legitimate and how you interpret findings.
Your paradigm is shaped by three interconnected concepts:
Together, these three elements shape your methodology, alongside practical factors like access to data or available skills, time and resources.
The key insight is that these are not arbitrary choices. They are interconnected. If you believe that ‘workload’ is more than a number – for example, that it is about feeling supported or alone – you will probably want to use methods that capture how people make meaning, not just what they tick on a form.
Abstract philosophical concepts can feel disconnected from the practical work of research. An analogy may help to make these foundations more concrete.
Think of building a house:
Just as a well-built house requires a solid foundation, a clear blueprint and ethical considerations, effective research relies on:
You do not need to remember these definitions perfectly. What matters is understanding that your research choices are not made in isolation and are connected to deeper beliefs about knowledge and reality.
Before exploring mixed methods it helps to understand the two traditions that it draws upon. If you are already familiar with both, this will serve as a quick refresher; if your experience has been mainly in one tradition, this section offers a brief orientation to the other.
Neither approach is inherently better; each answers different kinds of questions and reveals different kinds of knowledge. As we will explore in Unit 2, most researchers draw on both to varying degrees depending on what they need to find out.
The different orientations extend to how researchers select their data – what we call sampling.
Imagine you want to learn about a pot of soup.
Both are valid approaches to knowing about the soup. They simply answer different questions.
In research terms:
When you mix methods you typically use both sampling strategies: usually, random or representative sampling for the quantitative strand and purposive sampling for the qualitative strand. These pairings are conventions rather than rules. Quantitative studies can use purposive sampling when generalisation is not the goal, and qualitative studies sometimes use convenience or snowball sampling. Understanding the conventional distinction is the foundation; understanding when to deviate from it is the next step.
a.
Random sampling
b.
Purposive sampling
The correct answer is a.
The correct answer is random sampling. To calculate a meaningful percentage that represents all students, you need a sample that reflects the wider population. A random sample allows you to generalise your findings.
a.
Random sampling
b.
Purposive sampling
The correct answer is b.
The correct answer is purposive sampling. Withdrawn students are a specific group whose experiences you want to understand in depth. You would deliberately seek out these individuals rather than hoping they appear in a random sample.
a.
Random sampling
b.
Purposive sampling
The correct answer is a.
The correct answer is random sampling. Comparing averages across groups requires data that represents each group fairly. Random sampling within each demographic category would support valid comparisons.
a.
Random sampling
b.
Purposive sampling
The correct answer is b.
The correct answer is purposive sampling. You are interested in the particular experiences of a specific group. You would deliberately recruit students from non-traditional backgrounds to explore their perspectives in depth.
You may be asking yourself ‘Why does any of this philosophy matter? I just want to do my research.’
The answer is that your paradigm shapes every decision you make, often without you realising it. For example:
The good news is that you do not have to commit to a single paradigm forever. As you will see in Unit 2, pragmatism – the philosophical home of mixed methods research – offers a way to draw on different approaches depending on what your research question requires.
But first, it helps to understand the landscape you are navigating.
Test your understanding of the concepts covered in this unit. This is a formative quiz to consolidate your learning; your score does not count towards the digital badge.
In this unit you have explored the foundational concepts that underpin all research design:
A note on prevalence: Most published social science research is either quantitative or qualitative, and only a minority is genuinely mixed methods. This is not because mixed methods is rare in principle. It is because doing it well takes more time, more skill across both traditions and more design discipline. Unit 4 will return to this and to how to recognise studies that mix methods well versus studies that simply run two things in parallel.
In Unit 2 you will explore the main philosophical positions in more depth and locate mixed methods on the research landscape.
When you are ready, you should move on to Unit 2: Understanding the research landscape.
Creswell, J.W. and Creswell, J.D. (2018) Research design: qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches. 5th edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Creswell, J.W. and Plano Clark, V.L. (2018) Designing and conducting mixed methods research. 3rd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Tashakkori, A. and Teddlie, C. (eds) (2010) SAGE handbook of mixed methods in social and behavioral research. 2nd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
Guba, E.G. and Lincoln, Y.S. (1994) ‘Competing paradigms in qualitative research’, in Denzin, N.K. and Lincoln, Y.S. (eds) Handbook of qualitative research. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, pp. 105–17.
Morgan, D.L. (2007) ‘Paradigms lost and pragmatism regained: methodological implications of combining qualitative and quantitative methods’, Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 1(1), pp. 48–76.