Skip to main content
Printable page generated Friday, 20 November 2026, 12:41 PM
Use 'Print preview' to check the number of pages and printer settings.
Print functionality varies between browsers.
Unless otherwise stated, copyright © 2026 The Open University, all rights reserved.
Printable page generated Friday, 20 November 2026, 12:41 PM

Unit 2: Understanding the research landscape

Introduction

In Unit 1 you explored the philosophical foundations that shape research design: ontology, epistemology and axiology. You saw how different approaches to the same question can yield different but equally valid findings.

This unit maps the broader terrain of research approaches. You will examine the main philosophical positions that inform social science research and understand where each one sits on the methodology continuum. By the end of this unit you will be able to recognise these positions when you encounter them in the literature, in your own assumptions, and in your research design and practice; and you will understand why pragmatism offers a compelling foundation for mixed methods research.

Unit learning outcomes

By the end of this unit, you will be able to:

  • describe the four main philosophical positions in social science research (post-positivism, social constructionism, critical realism and pragmatism)
  • explain how the same research question can lead to different methodological choices depending on the researcher’s philosophical stance
  • locate quantitative, qualitative and mixed methods approaches on the methodology continuum
  • articulate the key differences between quantitative and qualitative traditions
  • explain why pragmatism provides a useful foundation for mixed methods research.

Estimated study time for this unit: 1 hour.

2.1 Four ways of knowing

A photograph of three keyhole shapes cut from printed text, each with an arrow pointing in a different direction: left, straight up and right.

Researchers approach the world with different assumptions about what exists (ontology) and how we can know things (epistemology). These are the same concepts you met in Unit 1. These assumptions cluster into recognisable philosophical positions. You do not need to memorise these definitions but you should be able to recognise them when you see them in the literature.

Here are four such positions that you will encounter most often – they are not the only ones but they are the ones that shape how social science research is designed today:

  • Post-positivism holds that there is a real world out there, independent of our perceptions, but we can never know it with complete certainty. (The ‘post’ marks a step away from classical positivism, which assumed that careful science could deliver objective truth in full. Post-positivists accept that all observation is partial and theory-laden, but still believe that disciplined methods bring us closer to reality.) The best we can do is approximate reality through careful measurement, falsifiable hypotheses and statistical rigour. This position underpins most quantitative research. Post-positivists value objectivity, generalisability and statistical rigour.
  • Social constructionism holds that reality does not exist independently of human activity. Instead, reality is constructed by people and given meaning through social interaction. What counts as ‘knowledge’ is shaped by culture, language and context. This position underpins most qualitative research focused on meaning-making, lived experience and interpretation.
  • Critical realism distinguishes between three levels:
    • the ‘real’ – underlying structures and mechanisms that exist whether we observe them or not
    • the ‘actual’ – events that occur
    • the ‘empirical’ – what we can observe and measure.
  • Critical realists argue that we cannot directly see deep mechanisms but we can infer them from observable patterns. This position is useful when researchers want to understand not just what happens but what underlying structures cause it to happen.
  • Pragmatism takes a different stance altogether. Rather than committing to a single philosophical position, pragmatists ask: what works? They argue that the research question should drive method choice, not philosophical loyalty. If you need to know both ‘how many’ and ‘why’, then use both quantitative and qualitative methods. Pragmatism is the philosophical home of mixed methods research.

The following table compares the four positions.

Position View of reality View of knowledge Researcher role Typical methods
Post-positivism A real world exists independently We can approximate it through disciplined enquiry Detached, objective Surveys, experiments, statistical analysis
Social constructionism Reality is shaped through meaning-making and language Knowledge is co-produced in context Engaged, reflexive Interviews, ethnography, discourse analysis
Critical realism Real structures exist beneath observable events Knowledge bridges the real and the experienced Analytical, layered Mixed methods that move between mechanism and experience
Pragmatism Reality is what works for the question at hand Knowledge is judged by practical consequences Problem-driven Whatever methods best serve the question, often mixed

Activity 2.1: Recognising philosophical positions

Timing: Allow approximately 10 minutes

a. 

Post-positivism


b. 

Social constructionism


c. 

Critical realism


d. 

Pragmatism


The correct answer is c.

Answer

The correct answer is critical realism. This statement distinguishes between observable effects and underlying mechanisms that cannot be directly measured but can be inferred.

a. 

Post-positivism


b. 

Social constructionism


c. 

Critical realism


d. 

Pragmatism


The correct answer is b.

Answer

The correct answer is social constructionism. This statement emphasises that meaning is constructed differently depending on social context and that understanding requires exploring how people make sense of concepts in their own terms.

a. 

Post-positivism


b. 

Social constructionism


c. 

Critical realism


d. 

Pragmatism


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The correct answer is post-positivism. This statement reflects hypothesis testing, controlled comparison and the aim of establishing causal relationships through measurement.

a. 

Post-positivism


b. 

Social constructionism


c. 

Critical realism


d. 

Pragmatism


The correct answer is d.

Answer

The correct answer is pragmatism. This statement prioritises answering the research question fully, combining methods as needed rather than committing to a single approach.

2.2 Same question, four lenses

To make these philosophical positions more concrete, consider how researchers from each tradition might approach the same question: ‘Why do students drop out of online courses?’

  • A post-positivist approach would measure observable behaviours and correlate them with outcomes. A researcher might analyse login frequency, assignment submission patterns and forum participation, and then use regression analysis to identify which factors predict dropout. The finding might be: ‘Students who log in fewer than three times per week are 2.4 times more likely to drop out.’
  • A social constructionist approach would explore what ‘dropping out’ means to students themselves. A researcher might conduct in-depth interviews with students who left, asking how they experienced the decision and what it meant in the context of their lives. The finding might be: ‘Students described dropping out as “giving up on a version of myself”. It was about identity, not just completion.’
  • A critical realist approach would look for underlying structures that generate observable patterns. A researcher might examine both quantitative patterns and qualitative accounts, asking what mechanisms explain both. The finding might be: ‘We cannot observe “financial anxiety” directly, but we can infer it from dropout spikes after funding cuts and from what students tell us about the pressures they faced.’
  • A pragmatist approach would ask what methods best answer the question, combining approaches as needed. A researcher might say: ‘We need to know both how many students are dropping out and why. Let us use learning analytics to identify patterns and interviews to understand what drives them.’

Notice that each approach asks a slightly different question and produces a different kind of knowledge. None is inherently ‘better’. They reveal different aspects of the same phenomenon.

Activity 2.2: Applying the four lenses

Timing: Allow approximately 15 minutes
By signing in and enrolling on this course you can view and complete all activities within the course, track your progress in My OpenLearn Create. and when you have completed a course, you can download and print a free Statement of Participation - which you can use to demonstrate your learning.

2.3 The methodology continuum

A photograph of a smooth colour gradient blending from green through yellow and orange to deep red.

In textbooks and methods training courses, quantitative and qualitative approaches are often presented as opposites:

  • one deals with numbers, the other with words
  • one seeks generalisation, the other seeks depth
  • one is objective, the other is subjective.

This binary framing can be misleading. In practice, most researchers work somewhere along a continuum rather than at the extremes.

At one end sit researchers who lean toward realism and post-positivism, favouring measurement, hypothesis testing and statistical analysis. At the other end sit researchers who lean toward relativism and constructionism, favouring interpretation, meaning-making and rich description.

But very few researchers occupy the extreme positions. Most of us move along this continuum depending on our research question, our context, our practical constraints and what we value as evidence (axiology). A researcher might use quantitative methods for one study and qualitative methods for another, or combine both in a single project.

Mixed methods research sits in the middle of this continuum. It does not ask you to abandon either tradition; instead, it invites you to draw on both thoughtfully, depending on what your research question requires.

If you have ever felt torn between wanting to count something and wanting to understand it deeply, you are already thinking like a mixed methods researcher. You are recognising that different questions require different approaches and that sometimes a single approach is not enough.

Activity 2.3: Where do you sit?

Timing: Allow approximately 5 minutes

Reflect on your own research background and preferences.

  • Have you primarily worked with quantitative methods, qualitative methods or a mix?
  • Which feels more natural or comfortable to you?
  • Have you avoided any methods because they felt unfamiliar or intimidating?

There is no judgement here. The purpose is simply to recognise your own starting point, because this shapes the learning journey ahead.

To use this interactive functionality a free OU account is required. Sign in or register.
Interactive feature not available in single page view (see it in standard view).

2.4 Quantitative and qualitative: key differences

Before exploring how to combine approaches, it helps to understand what distinguishes them. The following table summarises key differences between quantitative and qualitative traditions.

DimensionQuantitativeQualitative
FocusMeasurement, magnitude, frequencyMeaning, experience, context
Data typeNumericalTextual, visual, observational
Sample sizeTypically largerTypically smaller
Sampling strategyUsually random or representative (also stratified, cluster, etc.)Usually purposive (also convenience, snowball, theoretical)
AnalysisStatisticalThematic, narrative, interpretive
GeneralisationTo populationsTo theory or concepts
Quality criteriaValidity, reliability, objectivityCredibility, transferability, reflexivity

These are generalisations. There are exceptions: some qualitative studies involve large samples; some quantitative studies are small-scale and exploratory. But the table captures the typical orientations of each tradition.

The key insight is that each approach answers different kinds of questions:

  • Quantitative methods are well suited to questions about what, how much and how many. They excel at examining relationships between variables, testing hypotheses and enabling comparison across groups.
  • Qualitative methods are well suited to questions about why, how and what does it mean. They excel at capturing context, exploring experience and understanding how people make sense of their worlds.

Neither is inherently better. They serve different purposes. The challenge – and the opportunity – lies in knowing when to use which, or when to combine them.

Activity 2.4: Matching questions to approaches

Timing: Allow approximately 10 minutes

a. 

Quantitative


b. 

Qualitative


c. 

Both


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The correct answer is quantitative. This question asks about proportion and completion rates, requiring numerical data and statistical analysis.

a. 

Quantitative


b. 

Qualitative


c. 

Both


The correct answer is b.

Answer

The correct answer is qualitative. This question asks about experience and meaning, requiring in-depth exploration of how students make sense of their transition.

a. 

Quantitative


b. 

Qualitative


c. 

Both


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The correct answer is quantitative. This question asks about a relationship between two measurable variables, suited to correlation or regression analysis.

a. 

Quantitative


b. 

Qualitative


c. 

Both


The correct answer is c.

Answer

The correct answer is both. This question has two parts: identifying factors (quantitative) and understanding how students make sense of their decisions (qualitative). A mixed methods approach would address both.

2.5 Strengths and limitations

Every research approach has strengths and limitations. Being honest about these helps you to make informed choices and strengthens your research design.

  • Quantitative strengths:
    • enable examination of relationships between variables
    • support hypothesis testing with statistical rigour
    • allow comparison across groups and contexts
    • have findings that can be generalised to wider populations (with appropriate sampling)
    • give results that are often seen as objective and credible by policymakers.
  • Quantitative limitations:
    • can miss contextual nuance and complexity
    • provide limited insight into ‘why’ and ‘how’
    • have a risk of oversimplifying complex phenomena
    • assume the constructs being measured are valid and meaningful
    • may impose researcher categories on participants.
  • Qualitative strengths:
    • capture real-world context and complexity
    • provide rich understanding of experience and meaning
    • explore emotions, beliefs and social processes
    • allow unexpected themes to emerge
    • give voice to participant perspectives.
  • Qualitative limitations:
    • has finding that are difficult to generalise beyond the sample
    • relies on samples that may be small and unrepresentative
    • use analysis that can be time-consuming and subjective
    • make it hard to assess relationships between variables statistically
    • may be seen as less credible by some audiences.

The promise of mixed methods is to bridge both traditions, drawing on the strengths of each while mitigating their limitations. Done well, mixed methods research can offer both statistical rigour and contextual depth, both breadth and richness.

But mixed methods is not a magic solution. It requires skills in both traditions. It takes more time and resources, and it must be done with genuine integration, not simply running a survey alongside some interviews and calling it ‘mixed’.

In Unit 3 you will explore the specific designs that make genuine integration possible. Unit 4 returns to this with three real-research case studies that illustrate where mixed methods adds value and where running two methods in parallel is not enough.

2.6 Why pragmatism matters

A photograph of a toolbox containing an assortment of spanners, socket wrenches, and screwdrivers of different sizes.

Of the four philosophical positions introduced earlier, pragmatism deserves particular attention because it provides the foundation for mixed methods thinking.

Pragmatism originated in the work of American philosophers including Charles Sanders Peirce, William James and John Dewey. Its core principle is simple: judge ideas by their practical consequences. In research terms, this means choosing methods based on what will best answer your research question rather than on philosophical loyalty.

For mixed methods researchers, pragmatism is liberating. It offers permission to combine approaches without feeling that you are betraying a paradigm. You are not being philosophically inconsistent; you are being practical.

Pragmatism rests on several key principles:

  • The research question is paramount. Method choice follows from what you need to know, not from prior commitment to a tradition.
  • Multiple methods can address different aspects of a problem. If your question has quantitative and qualitative dimensions, use both.
  • Knowledge is provisional. What works in one context may not work in another. Findings are tentative and open to revision.
  • Practical outcomes matter. Research should contribute to understanding and action in the real world.

This does not mean that ‘anything goes’. Pragmatic researchers still need to justify their choices, demonstrate rigour and ensure coherence. But the justification centres on fitness for purpose: does this design help answer the research question?

Pragmatism is sometimes critiqued for being insufficiently philosophical: by privileging ‘what works’ it can sidestep important questions about whose definition of ‘works’ counts, and can shade into method-shopping if the researcher does not pause to articulate why they are combining what they are combining. The discipline pragmatism asks for is the discipline of justifying fitness for purpose explicitly.

If you find yourself drawn to pragmatism you are in good company: explicitly or implicitly, most mixed methods researchers operate from this stance.

Unit 2 quiz

Test your understanding of the concepts covered in this unit. This is a formative quiz to consolidate your learning; your score does not count towards the digital badge.

Summary

In this unit you have explored the broader landscape of research approaches:

  • Four philosophical positions shape social science research: post-positivism, social constructionism, critical realism and pragmatism. Each makes different assumptions about reality and knowledge.
  • The same question can be approached differently depending on philosophical stance, yielding different but valid findings.
  • Quantitative and qualitative approaches sit on a continuum, not as binary opposites. Most researchers work somewhere in the middle.
  • Each tradition has strengths and limitations. Quantitative methods excel at measurement and generalisation; qualitative methods excel at meaning and context.
  • Pragmatism provides the foundation for mixed methods, offering permission to combine approaches based on what best answers the research question, provided that fitness for purpose is articulated.

In Unit 3 you will explore the specific designs used in mixed methods research and develop a framework for choosing between them.

When you are ready, you should move on to Unit 3: Mixed methods designs.

References and additional resources

References

Creswell, J.W. and Plano Clark, V.L. (2018) Designing and conducting mixed methods research. 3rd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

Morgan, D.L. (2014) Integrating qualitative and quantitative methods: a pragmatic approach. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

Shannon-Baker, P. (2016) ‘Making paradigms meaningful in mixed methods research’, Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 10(4), pp. 319–34.

Additional resources

Bhaskar, R. (2008) A realist theory of science. London: Routledge. (For those interested in critical realism.)

Feilzer, M.Y. (2010) ‘Doing mixed methods research pragmatically: implications for the rediscovery of pragmatism as a research paradigm’, Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 4(1), pp. 6–16.

Johnson, R.B. and Onwuegbuzie, A.J. (2004) ‘Mixed methods research: a research paradigm whose time has come’, Educational Researcher, 33(7), pp. 14–26.

University of Nottingham (n.d.) Understanding pragmatic research [online]. Available at https://www.nottingham.ac.uk/helmopen/rlos/research-evidence-based-practice/designing-research/types-of-study/understanding-pragmatic-research/index.html (accessed 7 May 2026). (A useful starting point for the philosophical underpinnings of pragmatism in research design.)