Skip to main content
Printable page generated Friday, 20 November 2026, 12:51 PM
Use 'Print preview' to check the number of pages and printer settings.
Print functionality varies between browsers.
Unless otherwise stated, copyright © 2026 The Open University, all rights reserved.
Printable page generated Friday, 20 November 2026, 12:51 PM

Unit 3: Mixed methods designs

Introduction

You now understand the philosophical foundations that shape research design and where mixed methods sits on the methodology continuum. But what does a mixed methods study actually look like in practice? How do researchers decide when to collect quantitative and qualitative data, and how do they bring the two strands together?

This unit focuses on the practical ‘how’ of mixed methods research. You will learn the three core designs used in mixed methods studies, explore the iterative nature of the research process and develop a framework for choosing between designs. By the end of this unit you will be able to identify different mixed methods designs when you encounter them in the literature and select an appropriate design for your own research questions.

Unit learning outcomes

By the end of this unit, you will be able to:

  • explain what makes a study ‘mixed methods’ rather than simply using multiple methods
  • describe the iterative nature of the research cycle and how methods can be adapted within it
  • identify and describe the three core mixed methods designs (convergent, explanatory sequential and exploratory sequential)
  • apply a decision-making framework to select an appropriate design for a given research scenario
  • explain the five purposes of mixing methods (triangulation, complementarity, development, initiation and expansion).

Estimated study time for this unit: 1 hour.

3.1 What makes a study ‘mixed methods’?

A photograph of a river flowing through a lush valley.

Not every study that uses surveys and interviews is a mixed methods study. The defining feature of mixed methods research is not simply the presence of multiple methods but the intentional integration of quantitative and qualitative approaches.

A study is considered mixed methods if it adopts quantitative and qualitative approaches in one or more of the following ways:

  • Research questions: You might have one question that is quantitative (‘What proportion of students withdraw before completion?’) and another that is qualitative (‘How do withdrawing students experience their decision to leave?’).
  • Data collection: You might use surveys to gather numerical data and interviews or focus groups to gather textual data.
  • Data types: You might work with both numerical data (test scores, response frequencies, scale ratings) and textual data (interview transcripts, open-ended responses, observation notes).
  • Data analysis: You might use statistical analysis for one strand and thematic analysis for another.

You do not need all four of these elements; having just one of them can make your study mixed methods. What matters is that the quantitative and qualitative components are brought together intentionally to address your research questions more fully than either approach could alone.

The key word is integration. If you run a survey and conduct some interviews but never bring the findings together, you have a multi-method study rather than a mixed methods study. True mixed methods research requires you to explain how and why the two strands inform each other.

Activity 3.1: Mixed methods or multi-method?

Timing: Allow approximately 10 minutes

a. 

Mixed methods


b. 

Multi-method


The correct answer is b.

Answer

The correct answer is multi-method. Although two methods are used, there is no integration. The survey and interviews address different topics and the findings are not brought together.

a. 

Mixed methods


b. 

Multi-method


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The correct answer is mixed methods. The quantitative findings (low satisfaction scores) directly inform the qualitative phase (interviews with those departments), and the qualitative findings are used to explain the quantitative patterns. This is integration.

a. 

Mixed methods


b. 

Multi-method


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The correct answer is mixed methods. The qualitative phase (focus groups) is used to develop the quantitative instrument (questionnaire) and the quantitative phase tests the prevalence of qualitatively identified themes. This shows integration through development.

a. 

Mixed methods


b. 

Multi-method


The correct answer is b.

Answer

The correct answer is multi-method. Despite collecting both types of data, the lack of comparison or connection means there is no integration. The study uses multiple methods but does not mix them.

3.2 The iterative research cycle

Research is rarely a straight line from question to answer. It is an iterative process: a cycle of questioning, designing, collecting, analysing and refining.

The research cycle typically moves through the following stages:

  • Research question: You identify what you want to know.
  • Design: You plan how to investigate the question.
  • Data collection: You gather evidence.
  • Analysis: You examine and interpret the evidence.
  • Reflection and modification: You consider what you have learned and whether further investigation is needed.

This cycle often repeats. Analysis might reveal unexpected patterns that prompt new questions, data collection might expose limitations in your design and reflection might lead you to modify your approach.

For mixed methods researchers, understanding this cycle is particularly important because you can use different approaches at different stages. You might begin with qualitative exploration and then move to quantitative testing. Or you might start with quantitative measurement and then use qualitative inquiry to explain your findings. The cycle gives you flexibility to adapt your approach as your understanding develops.

The iterative nature of research also helps explain why mixed methods designs often unfold in phases. Rather than collecting all data at once, many mixed methods studies build one phase on the findings of another, allowing each strand to inform the next.

Understanding research as a cycle encourages methodological flexibility, reflexivity and more theoretically informed decision-making, which becomes especially important when you are juggling two strands.

3.3 Three core mixed methods designs

Researchers have developed many variations of mixed methods designs, but three core types appear consistently in the literature. Understanding these will equip you to recognise most mixed methods studies you encounter and to design your own.

The three designs differ in two key dimensions which shape how data is collected, integrated and interpreted:

  • Timing: Are the quantitative and qualitative strands conducted at the same time (concurrently) or one after the other (sequentially)? And at what point are they brought together: at design, during analysis or at interpretation?
  • Priority: Do both strands carry equal weight or does one take priority over the other? In some designs one strand plays a supporting role, informing or explaining the dominant approach.

You will now examine each design in turn.

Convergent design

A photograph of two hands holding separate puzzle pieces against a bright sky, positioning them to fit together.

In a convergent design you collect quantitative and qualitative data at the same time and then merge the findings to compare or triangulate them.

  • Timing: Concurrent. Both strands happen simultaneously or within the same phase.
  • Priority: Usually equal. Both strands contribute equally to answering the research question.
  • Purpose: To validate findings through triangulation, to gain a more complete picture by examining the same phenomenon through different lenses, or to compare quantitative and qualitative results directly.
  • Notation: QUAN + QUAL. Capital letters indicate equal priority; the plus sign indicates concurrent collection.
  • Example research question: ‘Do themes from staff interviews match patterns in our employee engagement survey?’
  • How it works: You might survey all employees about engagement and simultaneously conducting interviews with a purposive sample. After collecting both datasets you analyse them separately and then compare them. Do the interview themes align with the survey patterns? Where do they converge? Where do they diverge?
  • When to use it: Convergent design works well when you want to validate or corroborate findings from one method with findings from another, when you want to build a more complete picture by examining the same phenomenon from multiple angles, and when integration during interpretation is the appropriate stage to bring strands together.

Explanatory sequential design

In an explanatory sequential design you begin with quantitative data collection and analysis and then follow up with qualitative data to explain or elaborate on the quantitative results.

  • Timing: Sequential. The quantitative phase comes first and the qualitative phase follows.
  • Priority: Usually quantitative. The quantitative strand drives the study and the qualitative strand explains or elaborates.
  • Purpose: To use qualitative findings to explain quantitative results, particularly when quantitative data reveals patterns that need deeper understanding.
  • Notation: QUAN → qual. Capital letters indicate priority; the arrow indicates sequence; lower-case letters indicate the supporting strand.
  • Example research question: ‘Our survey shows that Group A is more satisfied than Group B. Why? What explains this difference?’
  • How it works: You might begin by surveying a large sample and identifying an interesting pattern – perhaps students in one programme have lower satisfaction than those in another. You then conduct interviews with students from both programmes to understand what drives the difference. The qualitative phase is designed specifically to explain the quantitative findings.
  • When to use it: Explanatory design works well when you begin with quantitative data that raises questions or produces results that require further interpretation or explanation, when you observe patterns that need deeper understanding, or when you want to give depth and meaning to statistical findings.

Exploratory sequential design

In an exploratory sequential design you begin with qualitative data collection and analysis and then use those findings to inform a subsequent quantitative phase.

  • Timing: Sequential. The qualitative phase comes first and the quantitative phase follows.
  • Priority: Usually qualitative initially, shifting to quantitative. The qualitative strand explores and discovers; the quantitative strand tests or measures.
  • Purpose: To use qualitative findings to develop quantitative instruments, to generate hypotheses for testing or to identify variables worth measuring at scale.
  • Notation: QUAL → quan. Capital letters indicate priority; lower-case letters indicate the supporting strand.
  • Example research question: ‘What themes emerge from pilot interviews about student experience that we could then measure across the whole cohort?’
  • How it works: You might begin by interviewing a small sample of students to understand their experience of online learning. From those interviews, you identify key themes (perhaps ‘feeling isolated’, ‘flexibility’, or ‘self-discipline challenges’). You then develop a survey instrument based on those themes and administer it to a larger sample to measure how prevalent each experience is across the student population.
  • When to use it: Exploratory design works well when you begin with qualitative inquiry to investigate a new area with limited prior research, when you need to develop or adapt measurement instruments, or when you want to ensure your quantitative measures reflect participant perspectives rather than researcher assumptions.

Activity 3.2: Identifying designs

Timing: Allow approximately 10 minutes

a. 

Convergent


b. 

Explanatory sequential


c. 

Exploratory sequential


The correct answer is b.

Answer

The answer is explanatory sequential. The quantitative burnout inventory comes first, identifying teachers at extreme ends of the scale. The qualitative focus groups follow, specifically designed to explain the quantitative findings.

a. 

Convergent


b. 

Explanatory sequential


c. 

Exploratory sequential


The correct answer is a.

Answer

The answer is convergent. Both data types are collected simultaneously (or in the same phase) and are then merged and compared. The study seeks triangulation between survey and interview findings.

a. 

Convergent


b. 

Explanatory sequential


c. 

Exploratory sequential


The correct answer is c.

Answer

The answer is exploratory sequential. The qualitative interviews come first, exploring barriers in participants’ own terms. The findings are then used to develop a quantitative instrument for broader measurement.

a. 

Convergent


b. 

Explanatory sequential


c. 

Exploratory sequential


The correct answer is b.

Answer

The answer is explanatory sequential. The quantitative data (learning analytics) comes first, identifying a pattern (early disengagement). The qualitative interviews follow to explain why this pattern occurs.

3.4 Choosing a design: a decision framework

With three core designs to choose from, how do you decide which is right for your study? The key question is: what do you need to know, and in what order?

Consider the following decision points:

  • Start with your research question: Does your question have both ‘how many/how much’ and ‘why/how’ dimensions? If so, mixed methods may be appropriate.
  • Consider what you already know: Do you have existing data or established measures? If you already have quantitative data showing a pattern you want to understand, explanatory sequential makes sense. If you are starting from scratch with little prior research, exploratory sequential may be better. If you want to compare or validate findings from different angles, convergent is appropriate.
  • Think about timing and resources: Convergent designs require capacity to collect and analyse both datasets in the same timeframe. Sequential designs spread the work but take longer overall. What is feasible given your timeline and resources?
  • Consider your audience: Who will use your findings? Some audiences value quantitative evidence more highly; others value qualitative depth. Your design can reflect these priorities.

The following table summarises when each design is most appropriate.

DesignUse when you want to …Key question
ConvergentValidate or triangulate findings from different sources‘Do my survey and interview findings point in the same direction?’
Explanatory sequentialUnderstand quantitative results in more depth‘The numbers show X. Why? What does this mean?’
Exploratory sequentialBuild theory or develop measures from qualitative insights‘What themes emerge that I could then measure at scale?’

Here is a short decision walkthrough:

  1. Does your question genuinely require both QUAN and QUAL? If no, stop and use a single approach.
  2. Do you already have one type of data (for example, an existing survey)? If yes, lean towards explanatory or exploratory sequential; if no, all three designs remain on the table.
  3. Can you collect both data types in the same time window? If no, sequential; if yes, convergent or sequential are both feasible.
  4. Who is your audience and what kind of evidence will they trust most? This shapes which strand carries the weight: QUAN-led, QUAL-led or balanced.

Activity 3.3: Selecting a design

Timing: Allow approximately 15 minutes

Read the following research scenario and consider which design would be most appropriate.

You are investigating why academic staff in your faculty report lower wellbeing than staff in comparable faculties. You have access to annual staff survey data showing the pattern clearly, but the survey does not reveal the underlying reasons. You want to understand the causes so that interventions can be designed.

Consider the following questions:

  • What do you already know? What do you still need to find out?
  • What type of data would help you answer the ‘why’ question?
  • Which design would be most appropriate and why?

Write your reasoning in the box below, then check the discussion.

To use this interactive functionality a free OU account is required. Sign in or register.
Interactive feature not available in single page view (see it in standard view).

Discussion

This scenario points toward an explanatory sequential design because:

  • you already have quantitative data (the staff survey) showing a clear pattern (lower wellbeing in your faculty)
  • what you lack is an understanding of why this pattern exists
  • qualitative data (interviews, focus groups) would help you explore the underlying reasons
  • the logical sequence is that you start with what you know (the quantitative pattern) and then investigate further (qualitative exploration of causes).

An explanatory sequential design would involve analysing the existing survey data to identify specific dimensions of wellbeing that are lower and then conducting interviews with staff to understand what factors contribute to those patterns. The qualitative findings would explain and contextualise the quantitative results and inform intervention design.

A convergent design would be less appropriate here because you are not trying to triangulate or validate. You already trust the survey findings and you want to explain them. An exploratory design would be less appropriate because you are not starting from scratch or developing new measures.

3.5 Purposes of mixing methods

A photograph of a glass prism refracting light and casting a rainbow spectrum onto a white surface.

Beyond choosing a design, it helps to be clear about why you are mixing methods. Researchers mix methods for different purposes, so articulating your purpose strengthens your rationale.

Greene, Caracelli, and Graham (1989) identified five purposes for mixing methods that remain widely used today:

  • Triangulation seeks convergence and correspondence of results from different methods. You use multiple methods to study the same phenomenon, checking whether findings align. This increases validity by counteracting the biases of any single method.
    • Example: Comparing survey responses about teamwork quality with observations of team meetings and interview accounts of collaboration.
  • Complementarity seeks elaboration, enhancement and clarification. Results from one method help explain or extend results from another. Each method contributes different insights that together create a richer picture.
    • Example: Using interviews with staff to understand what factors might drive the patterns and could explain and contextualise the quantitative results.
  • Development uses results from one method to inform the design or implementation of another. One strand helps develop the other.
    • Example: Using focus group discussions to develop survey items, ensuring the questionnaire reflects participant language and concerns.
  • Initiation seeks paradoxes, contradictions and fresh perspectives. When methods yield different results this is not a problem but an opportunity. Contradictions can prompt new insights and deeper investigation.
    • Example: Discovering that survey data suggests high satisfaction while interviews reveal significant frustration, prompting an investigation into what explains this discrepancy.
  • Expansion extends the breadth and range of inquiry by using different methods for different components. Rather than studying the same thing with multiple methods you use each method to address a different aspect of the problem.
    • Example: Using quantitative methods to measure outcomes and qualitative methods to study implementation processes.

When designing a mixed methods study, ask yourself: Why am I mixing methods? What purpose does it serve? At what stage will the strands be connected? What would be lost if one were removed? The degree of benefit you get from mixing depends on how deliberately you employ the two strands; a tightly integrated design will return more than two parallel sub-studies stapled together.

Unit 4 walks through a fully published mixed methods study (Herodotou et al., 2019) end-to-end, showing how each design choice shows up in practice.

Activity 3.4: Matching purposes to examples

Timing: Allow approximately 5 minutes

Match each research scenario to the primary purpose of mixing methods it represents.

Two lists follow, match one item from the first with one item from the second. Each item can only be matched once. There are 5 items in each list.

  1. Development

  2. Initiation

  3. Expansion

  4. Triangulation

  5. Complementarity

Match each of the previous list items with an item from the following list:

  • a.A researcher conducts both a survey and interviews about workplace culture, comparing findings to check whether they converge.

  • b.A researcher uses interview data to explain why some schools show better outcomes than others in the quantitative dataset.

  • c.A researcher finds that quantitative data suggests a programme is effective, but qualitative data reveals participant dissatisfaction. They investigate this contradiction further.

  • d.A researcher uses interview findings to develop a culturally appropriate questionnaire for use with a specific community.

  • e.A researcher measures student achievement quantitatively while using classroom observations to study teaching practices, combining both to understand the learning environment.

The correct answers are:
  • 1 = d,
  • 2 = c,
  • 3 = e,
  • 4 = a,
  • 5 = b

Answer

The following table further explains the correct answers.

ScenarioPurposeReason
A researcher uses interview findings to develop a culturally appropriate questionnaire for use with a specific community.DevelopmentThe qualitative findings are used to develop the quantitative instrument.
A researcher finds that quantitative data suggests a programme is effective, but qualitative data reveals participant dissatisfaction. They investigate this contradiction further.InitiationThe contradiction between quantitative and qualitative findings prompts further investigation and new insights.
A researcher measures student achievement quantitatively while using classroom observations to study teaching practices, combining both to understand the learning environment.ExpansionDifferent methods address different components of the research (achievement vs teaching practices), extending the breadth of inquiry.
A researcher conducts both a survey and interviews about workplace culture, comparing findings to check whether they converge.TriangulationMultiple methods study the same phenomenon (workplace culture) to check for convergence.
A researcher uses interview data to explain why some schools show better outcomes than others in the quantitative dataset.ComplementarityThe qualitative findings elaborate and explain the quantitative patterns, adding depth and meaning.

3.6 Notation and reporting

When you read mixed methods literature you will encounter standardised notation that indicates the design being used. Understanding this notation will help you identify study designs quickly.

The common notation conventions are as follows:

  • Capital letters (QUAN, QUAL) indicate a priority or dominant strand.
  • Lower-case letters (quan, qual) indicate a secondary or supporting strand.
  • Plus sign (+) indicates concurrent data collection (both strands happening at the same time).
  • Arrow (→) indicates sequential data collection (one strand follows the other).
  • Brackets or parentheses can indicate embedding (one strand nested within another).

The following table shows some examples.

NotationExplanation
QUAN + QUALConvergent design with equal priority
QUAN → qualExplanatory sequential (quantitative priority, followed by supporting qualitative)
QUAL → quanExploratory sequential (qualitative priority, followed by supporting quantitative)
QUAN(qual)Quantitative study with embedded qualitative component

When reporting your own mixed methods study, using this notation in your methodology section signals to readers that you understand the field’s conventions and have made deliberate design choices.

Unit 3 quiz

Test your understanding of the concepts covered in this unit. This is a formative quiz to consolidate your learning; your score does not count towards the digital badge.

Summary

In this unit you have explored the practical aspects of mixed methods design:

  • Integration is the defining feature of mixed methods research. Using multiple methods is not enough; the methods must be intentionally combined.
  • Research is iterative. The research cycle allows you to adapt your approach as understanding develops, using different methods at different stages.
  • Three core designs structure most mixed methods studies: convergent (simultaneous collection, then merge), explanatory sequential (quantitative first, then qualitative to explain) and exploratory sequential (qualitative first, then quantitative to test or measure).
  • Design choice follows from your research question. Ask: what do I need to know, and in what order?
  • Five purposes guide why researchers mix methods: triangulation, complementarity, development, initiation and expansion. Articulating your purpose strengthens your rationale.
  • Standard notation communicates your design to readers: capital letters for priority strands, plus signs for concurrent collection, arrows for sequential phases.

In Unit 4 you will explore how to ensure rigour in mixed methods research, including sampling strategies, integration approaches and managing conflicting findings.

When you are ready, you should move on to Unit 4: Ensuring rigour in mixed methods.

References and additional resources

References

Creswell, J.W. and Plano Clark, V.L. (2018) Designing and conducting mixed methods research. 3rd edn. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

Greene, J.C., Caracelli, V.J. and Graham, W.F. (1989) ‘Toward a conceptual framework for mixed-method evaluation designs’, Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 11(3), pp. 255–74.

Herodotou, C., Rienties, B., Boroowa, A., Zdrahal, Z. and Hlosta, M. (2019) ‘A large-scale implementation of Predictive Learning Analytics in higher education: the teachers’ role and perspective’, Educational Technology Research and Development, 67, pages 1273–1306.

Teddlie, C. and Tashakkori, A. (2009) Foundations of mixed methods research: integrating quantitative and qualitative approaches in the social and behavioral sciences. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

Additional resources

Creswell, J.W. (2015) A concise introduction to mixed methods research. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications. (A shorter, accessible introduction for those new to the field.)

Fetters, M.D., Curry, L.A. and Creswell, J.W. (2013) ‘Achieving integration in mixed methods designs: principles and practices’, Health Services Research, 48(6pt2), pp. 2134–56. (Detailed guidance on integration strategies.)

Schoonenboom, J. and Johnson, R.B. (2017) ‘How to construct a mixed methods research design’, Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, 69(2), pp. 107–31. (Step-by-step guidance on design decisions.)