In Activity 2, students constructed their own mathematical ‘truths’ by building on their natural powers for deductive reasoning and using their knowledge of mathematical properties. Knowing about mathematical properties is very important, because any argumentation in mathematical proof should be based on these. Similarly, defining mathematical conditions about when a statement applies and when it does not is equally important.
Sorting and classifying tasks are effective in supporting students to become aware of defining properties and conditions for mathematical sets; that is, which properties belong to which set. Sorting and classifying makes you think about differences and similarities. The next activity uses this approach.
Tell your students that a ‘proportion’ is a pair of ratios that are equal. Being proportional is a property that occurs frequently in mathematics across different topics and concepts.
The statements that follow describe some scenarios that illustrate mathematical concepts. Ask your students to read these and classify whether they would be proportional or not, and under what conditions. They should provide their reasons and explain to a friend what the example would be proportional (or not proportional) to. Be critical!
Figure 1 Qutab Minar, Delhi.
To help the students engage with this activity, we read the instructions and examples (a) and (b) together aloud in the classroom. We then had a brainstorm about possible answers for (a), and discussed the conditions that would need to be fulfilled for the enlarged photograph to stay proportional to the old one. This was started by Rahul, who said that to enlarge the photograph to make it twice as big, you would have to double its width. I could see that Usha was thinking, as she was frowning, and then she said that would not work because it would make the picture look weird.
I then asked the students to first work on the examples individually so they could develop their own thoughts and ideas first, and then to discuss their thinking and reasoning with their partner.
After some time, I picked some statements to discuss with the whole class and for the students to share their ideas. I noticed that students were using some phrases repetitively, such as:
I pointed this out to the students and they agreed that these were good phrases to find out about mathematical properties and conditions. Two students quickly wrote the phrases and a title ‘Good phrases to find out about mathematical properties and conditions’ on a large piece of paper, which was then stuck on the wall.
![]() Pause for thought
|
OpenLearn - Developing mathematical reasoning: mathematical proof Except for third party materials and otherwise, this content is made available under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 Licence, full copyright detail can be found in the acknowledgements section. Please see full copyright statement for details.