Implementing Education 4 Justice in your University Implementing the United Nations Education for Justice (E4J) initiative in your university

Unit 2: Varied and active engagement

Copyright © 2020 The Open University

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transmitted or utilised in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the publisher.

Contents

- Unit 2: Varied and active engagement

- 2.1 Active engagement

- 2.2 Learning styles

- 2.3 Varied engagement

- 2.4 Class structures

- 2.5 Conclusion

- Solutions

Unit 2: Varied and active engagement

Welcome to unit 2 which explores varied and active engagement. For learners to gain a deep understanding of new knowledge, skills, or values, they must actively engage with it.

Watch this video where James Lang explains this learning principle further.

Video content is not available in this format.

View transcript - Uncaptioned interactive content

2.1 Active engagement

Figure 6 Engaging the mind

View description - Figure 6 Engaging the mind

Active engagement can come through listening to a lecturer or viewing a video, but that should never be the only form of engagement that students have with the learning material. They should also have opportunities to engage with it in other ways, such as through writing, discussions, brainstorming activities, role plays, debates, group work, and peer-to-peer learning and assessment.

In all the E4J Modules, there are recommendations for teaching and learning activities that require students to actively confront ethical questions, problems, and challenges. Whether you choose to use these recommended activities or develop activities of your own, you should ensure that students are required not only to listen, read, or view (which are more passive forms of learning), but also to speak, write, act, and collaborate.

Activity 2.1 Active engagement

10 minutes

Part 1

All the Modules contain within them recommendations for active engagement in different forms. For example, E4J Ethics Module 2 (Ethics and Universal Values) includes a Possible Class Structure with a variety of activities in a single class.

If you were to follow the suggested sequence, students would be engaging in the following activities:

• Listening to a lecture accompanied by a slide presentation

• Watching a short video

• Engaging in a whole-class discussion on key questions

• Working in small groups on a clearly defined task

• Writing their own Declaration of Human Values

• Creating a performance which might include poetry, music or dance

• Performing or presenting to their peers

• Introducing an educational board game or app

What are the benefits to active and varied engagement?

Provide your answer...

View answer - Part 1

Part 2

What principles should you keep in mind when you are planning teaching activities for the Modules?

Provide your answer...

View answer - Part 2

2.2 Learning styles

You might have heard or read about the theory that students have different learning styles - such as visual learning, or auditory learning, and so forth - and that hence teachers should seek to identify the preferred learning style of every student and tailor instruction to it.

This theory has been used to support and promote a range of educational initiatives, some of them expensive and time-consuming to put into practice. Over the past two decades researchers have tested this theory that students have different learning styles in several different ways and found that it is not well-supported by the evidence (Brown, 2014).

While it is generally true that some of us prefer to read or listen to lectures while others like to engage in discussions or write, no evidence supports the idea that we learn more effectively or deeply when we are working in our preferred learning style.

Indeed, some researchers have discovered that students are often mistaken when they predict the type of activity that produces the greatest learning for them.

Desirable difficulties

We are discovering more and more that learning is most effective when it requires some effort on the part of the student, which means that students might learn more effectively when they are required to engage in activities that they find challenging.

The student who enjoys listening to lectures may learn comfortably from lectures, but when that student has to gather her thoughts and deliver them to her peers in a role play activity, that challenge to her comfortable style of learning may be more memorable to her than the most brilliant lecture she has attended.

The literature often refers to this phenomenon as “desirable difficulties’’ (Yue, Bjork and Bjork, 2013).

Activity 2.2 Personal values

15 minutes

Watch the video What Are Your Values on the MindTools website and then scroll down below the video to Step 4.

Students are asked to think about the values and morals that they live by and list their top ten personal ethical rules. You can screen the video and then allow time in class for your students to develop their list. If time allows, they can also read the article and have a discussion in small groups.

What is the benefit of an activity like this?

Provide your answer...

View answer - Activity 2.2 Personal values

2.3 Varied engagement

All of this leads to an important conclusion about the kinds of engagement activities that should be designed for students: they should be varied. If the lecturer does nothing but lecture to students, those students who do not respond very well to lectures - because they have difficulty paying attention for long periods of time, for example - are at a disadvantage.

Likewise, if the lecturer does nothing but have students engage in debates, those students who like to have the opportunity to read or listen quietly to an expert are at a disadvantage. As you are putting together plans to teach any of the Modules, you should consider how to offer varied methods for students to engage actively with the learning material.

One example of how to do this is given below.

Activity 2.3 How to uncover community corruption

20 minutes

Figure 7 Fight against corruption

View description - Figure 7 Fight against corruption

This exercise is from E4J Anti-Corruption Module 6. It includes the following components (the time allocation is a guideline only and you can adapt it according to the circumstances):

- Initial information provided to students via presentation and handout, accomplished by video and reading materials (10 minutes)

- Small groups discuss and come up with recommendations (15 minutes)

- Presentations by small groups on recommendations (15 minutes)

- Students vote on best recommendation (5 minutes)

- Debrief by facilitator (5 minutes)

You start this session with the following video and news article to set the scene:

Watch this clip which provides an example of how an artificial intelligence software (AI) could be used to detect corrupt activities within the civil service. The video also discusses the various ways of how such information could be used.

Read this article exploring nine ways to use technology to reduce corruption.

Afterwards, students are presented with the various means of reporting, including self-reporting and citizen reporting as well as the role of the new technologies to facilitate reporting of corruption, based on the relevant parts of the Key issues section of Module 6.

The general flow of the session is as follows:

- The groups should come up with suggestions for new ways to use technologies to combat corruption in their community.

- You should capture the feedback from the groups, for example on a flipchart or by using online poll tools such as Mentimeter or Slido. This will also facilitate the voting at the end of the exercise.

- You wrap up the session with additional examples of new technologies used for anti-corruption purposes. You may wish to show similar videos and articles from local media that might be more relevant and interesting to the students. Then, the students can vote on the best suggestion from the groups.

What challenges do you envisage in delivering this exercise and how could you overcome them?

Provide your answer...

View answer - Activity 2.3 How to uncover community corruption

2.4 Class structures

As you use the Modules within your teaching, consideration should be given to the teaching sequence and timings to deliver the learning outcomes of a Module. Below is an example of a class structure used in E4J Ethics Module 13 on Public Integrity:

Example class structure

Discussion of ethical dilemmas is perhaps best achieved in small groups. The suggested length of this activity is 45 minutes, but you can adjust the timings to suit your requirements. You break students into small groups: for the first five minutes each student works individually by writing down an example of an ethical dilemma that he / she has faced in their own personal environment.

For the next 20 minutes the students get the opportunity to share their dilemmas in the small group - this is not compulsory and not everyone has to share. Students are requested to respect privacy issues and to acknowledge the stress that might be involved when sharing something very personal.

The final 20 minutes are spent on feedback from the groups: again - on an entirely voluntary basis - groups are invited to share one example with the class as a whole. You use the board or a flip-chart to capture keywords from the example, you lead a discussion and wrap up with your own views on the examples that have been shared.

Here is another example of a possible class structure for E4J Anti-Corruption Module 3: Corruption and Comparative Politics.

2.5 Conclusion

E4J conference delegates

In this unit we have discussed the importance of active and varied engagement. To illustrate the application of this theory we have explored three exercises which illustrate how this can be achieved.

Go to Unit 3: The challenge of transfer now.

Solutions

Activity 2.1 Active engagement

Part 1

Answer

This extremely wide range of activities gives every student the opportunity to feel comfortable in some aspects of the work and challenged in others.

The creative student might fidget through the lecture but come to life in the creation of the performance.

The more intellectual student will relish the lecture and video and must be helped by their peers to present their ideas to the class.

Back to - Part 1

Part 2

Answer

As you plan teaching activities for the Modules, you should keep in mind the principle that you are seeking to create a varied range of active forms of engagement for your students with the learning material.

Back to - Part 2

Activity 2.2 Personal values

Answer

It offers students a varied range of active forms of engagement with the learning material. We are discovering more and more that learning is most effective when it requires some effort on the part of the student, which means that students might learn more effectively when they are required to engage in activities that they find challenging.

Back to - Activity 2.2 Personal values

Activity 2.3 How to uncover community corruption

Answer

Depending on the time available, you could decide to make the video compulsory preparatory work. Use the first part of the class to give clear instructions, and – whenever small groups are engaged in discussion – move from group to group to answer any questions they might have.

Back to - Activity 2.3 How to uncover community corruption

Figure 6 Engaging the mind

Description
An outline of a human head with lots of cogs inside it.
Back to - Figure 6 Engaging the mind

Figure 7 Fight against corruption

Description
Male hand clenched into a fist splits the text CORRUPTION on a white background. Concept of the fight against corruption.
Back to - Figure 7 Fight against corruption

Uncaptioned interactive content

Transcript

JAMES LANG

The second principle is just about varied and active engagement. You might have read at some point or heard people talking about the idea of learning styles, that we all have different styles of learning. For example, some people are visual learners. Some people like to learn by reading or listening. Some people are hands-on learners.

That theory has become very popular in education. Unfortunately, the research support behind it is not very strong. What the research tells us instead is that in a generic way, we all do learn differently because we're all different human beings. And we have those kinds of individual differences that are true in any realm of human experience.

But in terms of learning styles, what we've learned is that people's learning styles might differ. But that doesn't mean that we have to tailor teaching to an individual's preferred learning style. And in fact, some research shows that teaching in a way that the learner prefers isn't always good. And sometimes it's better for the learner to struggle, actually, in a format or a style that's different from the one they prefer.

The research has also shown, in fact, that we're not always good at identifying what our best learning style is. So someone who thinks they're a visual learner and then is given material in the both visual and, say, audio form, turns out might actually learn better in the audio format. So I say all this just to note that everybody learns differently. That's certainly true. There are these different styles that people can use to learn.

But you don't need to tailor your teaching to those learning styles. And in fact, you should think about the opposite perspective, that you should be doing as many different things as possible. Because we all learn differently, some kinds of activities are going to be helpful to students who learn one way but will not be helpful to students who learn in a different way.

So I always just recommend to people, think about varying your strategies. Don't lecture all the time. But don't always have discussions. Don't always use group work. Mix it up a little bit. And as you mix it up, you're going to be appealing to learners who have different approaches and styles, and some of whom will gain when it's difficult for them, and some of whom will be able to feel more comfortable when you're doing things that are easier for them.

Back to - Uncaptioned interactive content