Understanding UK universities

3. How do universities work? An introduction to university governance structures

3.6. Changes in University Governance: How things were

Collegial governance

Until the second half of the twentieth century, UK universities were self-governing organisations. Their management structures and processes emphasised academic autonomy and shared decision-making – in short, they were run by, and for, academics (Schofield 2009, p.6).

Although UK higher education had always been state funded, universities were governed largely through their own internal structures rather than through direct state control (Shattock 2006; Schofield 2009).

Under this collegiate model of governance universities were led by a collective body of academics and administrators (de Ridder-Symoens 1992). This body, known as the university Senate or Council, included representatives from the university’s academic departments as well as other stakeholders. The Council (or Senate) was responsible for making key decisions related to:

  • academic policies
  • curriculum development
  • faculty appointments and promotions
  • budgeting
  • resource allocation. 

This collegiate decision-making structure aimed to ensure that academics had a significant influence over the academic and intellectual direction of the university (Bush 1997).

Under this model of governance, academic departments and faculties enjoyed a high degree of autonomy and were largely responsible for their own affairs, including recruitment and promotion decisions, curriculum design, and research activities. This autonomy allowed for academic freedom and fostered an environment where scholars could pursue their research interests independently.

Administrative functions such as financial management, infrastructure maintenance and clerical support were generally handled by a central administration but were seen as supportive of, rather than central to, the main business of the university, which was the pursuit of knowledge. Decision-making processes were characterised by deliberation, consultation and consensus-building, with academic staff playing a central role. This meant that decision-making could be slow and inefficient, which led to calls for reforms to enhance accountability, efficiency and responsiveness.