Understanding UK universities
3. How do universities work? An introduction to university governance structures
3.8. Critical perspectives on university governance
The impact of the New Public Management (NPM) on universities has been a subject of ongoing debate with some commentators arguing that the corporatisation of higher education has transformed universities from largely autonomous, collegial communities which prioritised the production and dissemination of knowledge, into managerial organisations motivated as much by profit as by the pursuit of knowledge (See, for example, Collini 2017; Holmwood 2011).
Perhaps the most common criticism is that NPM reduces the role of academics in decision-making, with authority shifting from senates, faculty boards and academic committees towards executive teams. This has resulted in decision-making becoming more hierarchical and managerial, and academic staff having less influence over institutional strategy (Shattock 2006; Deem et al 2007).
The growth of audit and performance cultures in universities has also drawn criticism, with critics arguing that many of the essential functions of universities, such as supporting risky or long-term research, conducting public scholarship, and encouraging a culture of critical thought and intellectual curiosity, do not lend themselves to measurement and are therefore increasingly under-valued (Collini 2017).
Furthermore, the corporatisation of university culture has, critics argue, fundamentally changed the roles of both academics and students. Academics find that their work becomes less scholarly and more managerial, as they spend increasing amounts of time on reporting, performance reviews and quality assurance procedures. Meanwhile, students are positioned primarily as paying consumers purchasing a service, rather than as learners- meaning that the educational relationship between a student and their university becomes transactional rather than intellectual (Barnett 2017; Holmwood 2011).
In contrast, supporters of NPM point out that universities are now much larger, more complex organisations than many were 40 years ago, and that purely collegial governance may be impractical at this scale. In the context of the modern, large university sector, they argue, universities need more strategic leadership, better risk management, and stronger financial oversight if they are to remain viable.


