Managing your supervisors and other professional relationships

3. Understanding the supervisory relationship

3.3. First, know thyself

An important first step in identifying the resources you’ve got is reflecting on what you bring to the table. Think about your strengths and weaknesses as a student and as a colleague. 

  • What foibles and idiosyncrasies do you have that might make you difficult for some people to supervise? 
  • How much technical support are you likely to need? 
  • How strong is your grasp of the key theories and approaches in your research area? What gaps in your expertise are you aware of?
  • Do you tend to lie low when you are finding things difficult, or do you find it easy to seek support? 
  • Are you someone who needs a lot of structure and short deadlines or do you work best when self-directed? 
  • How do you respond to criticism and praise? 

It can be really useful to reflect on these things and, where comfortable and appropriate, to discuss them with your supervisors.

Activity 3: Care and Feeding 

Allow approximately 20 minutes for this activity. 

This activity is designed to help you think through what you’re likely to want and need from your supervisors. Have a go at answering each of the questions. You don’t necessarily need to share your answers with your supervisors- just articulating your wants and needs to yourself can be really useful.

Reflect on each question below. Make a separate note of your responses. Once you have answered all of the questions, select 'View Comment' to reveal possible responses and considerations.  

Question 1:

About how often would you ideally like to meet formally with your supervisors?

Question 2:

How long would you like formal supervision meetings to be?

Question 3:

How would you like to contact them between meetings?

Question 4:

How much guidance and structure do you usually need from managers, supervisors, etc.?

Question 5:

Do you usually prefer to work independently or more collaboratively?

Question 6:

Do you work best to longer or shorter deadlines?

Question 7:

How good are you at estimating how long tasks will take and meeting deadlines?

Question 8:

How are you with receiving constructive criticism? Would you prefer to receive written feedback on your work before a supervision, so that you have time to take it in?

Question 9:

How confident are you with using IT systems, especially when it comes to getting to know a new application? How much support are you likely to need? Do you know where to find help?

View Comment

Hopefully, answering the questions above has given you a chance to think through what you are like as a student and colleague. It can be enormously helpful to have as open and frank a conversation as you can about your wants and needs in your early supervision. It’s also a good idea to ask your supervisors some questions about how they usually like to supervise:

  • Do they prefer to work as a team or separately?
  • How often do they like to meet with students and for how long?
  • How do they like to be contacted between meetings?
  • What’s the best way for you to contact them if you just have a quick query?
  • If you email them and don’t hear back, how long would they like you to leave it before following up with them?

Having conversations like these is a really good step towards building a relationship for itself – one you work on together consciously and co-operatively, and with the understanding that you can re-visit and re-negotiate things as you go along.