Managing your supervisors and other professional relationships
3. Understanding the supervisory relationship
3.5. Understanding your supervisors
Now that you’ve thought about your own wants and needs, it’s useful to give some consideration to what your supervisors are likely to want and expect from your relationship. Activity 4 will help you to get started with this.
Activity 4: What's in it for them?
Allow approximately 10 minutes for this activity.
Reflect on each question below. Make a separate note of your responses. Once you have answered each question, select 'View Comment' to reveal possible responses and considerations.
Question 1:
What expectations do you think your supervisors are likely to have of your relationship? What are these likely to be based on?
View Comment
Your supervisors’ expectations of your relationship should be influenced by their formal responsibilities towards you but they are also likely to have been formed by their own experiences:
- As a PhD student.
- Of mentoring and being mentored in the workplace.
- With other PhD students.
- Of working with the colleagues in this particular supervisory team.
It can be useful to remember that each of your supervisors, like you, is likely to be bringing a lot of unspoken (and perhaps unconscious) experiences and expectations to your relationship. It can be really useful to ask your supervisors about their previous experiences supervising PhD students.
As you get to know them, you might want to ask them what their own PhD supervisors were like and what the PhD process was like for them? How do they usually like to supervise? What are the most common mistakes that they see students making? What do they find most difficult and most rewarding about supervision?
Question 2:
Academics are generally not obliged to supervise PGRs. Why do you think they choose to do so?
View Comment
When thinking about your relationship with your supervisor, it can be useful to try and think about the relationship from their perspective. There are a number of reasons why academics choose to supervise PhD students, here are just a few:
- There is a professional expectation that most research-active academics will be involved in PhD supervision.
- The number of PhD students that an academic has supervised and examined is one way to demonstrate academic seniority.
- Academics are expected to demonstrate their ability to bring funding into the University by successfully acquiring research funding. Getting PhD studentships funded is one way of doing this.
- Supervision is one of the major ways that early-career academics gain skills and experience in management.
- Joint publications with students count towards a supervisor’s research output.
- Supervision allows academics to extend their research networks via their students.
- Supervisors do not have time to carry out all the research they would like to. Taking on PhD students means that academics can benefit vicariously from the students’ ability to undertake time-consuming reading and data collection.
- Supervision is intellectually stimulating, engaging and often fun for the supervisor. A supervision meeting often represents a chance to think and talk about research in new and interesting ways.
- Supervision can give supervisors a sense that they are building a legacy in their field by supporting the next generation of scholars.
There are many more reasons why supervisors choose to work with PhD students although you can find an interesting and informal international discussion of supervisors’ motivations on Academia Stack Exchange. Thinking about your supervisors’ reasons for engaging in supervision (and asking them about them, if it feels comfortable and appropriate to do so) can help you gain insight into their motivations that will help you build good working relationships with them.
Question 3:
Why do you think that your supervisors chose to supervise your project in particular?
View Comment
In addition to having their own reasons for choosing to supervise PGRs in general, your supervisors will have made an active decision to supervise you, and it can be useful to think about what might have influenced their decision to do so. If you have been recruited to an existing project, you probably received feedback about what made you the most suitable candidate, and this will give you some indication of your supervisors’ motivations. If you have designed your own project, it can be useful to reflect on what it was about you, or the research, that made your supervisors want to get involved- perhaps your work touches on an area that they would like to expand their knowledge of, or where they feel their existing expertise could be usefully applied, or perhaps you have a methodological approach they find interesting. It can be really useful to think these questions through and, as you get to know your supervisors better, to ask them for their perspectives, so that you have a clear idea of your supervisors’ motivations, and their aspirations for your professional relationship.


