1.1 A tale of two researchers

Imagine you are researching why staff leave your organisation. Two researchers approach this question differently:

  • Researcher A takes a quantitative approach. They analyse exit survey data and find that 74% of leavers cite ‘workload’ as their primary reason for leaving. Researcher A concludes that workload is the main driver of staff turnover.
  • Researcher B takes a qualitative approach. They conduct in-depth conversations with 14 people who have left and uncover something that the survey did not capture: that they left not because they had too much to do, but because they felt unsupported and alone in managing that amount of work. Researcher B concludes that the main driver of staff turnover is because of support, not volume.

Here is the key insight: both findings are valid. Both are ‘true’. The researchers are looking at the same phenomenon through different lenses.

The survey tells you what people say; the conversations reveal what they actually mean. ‘Workload’ was the word that respondents used but ‘support’ was the need they had.

Each finding on its own offers a valid snapshot of the problem. But in isolation, each tells only part of the story. Put together, they reveal a deeper and more interconnected dynamic at play. The quantitative data shows the scale; the qualitative data unpacks the meaning behind it.

This is the value of mixed methods research. Complex social phenomena rarely have simple, single-dimension explanations. Combining approaches allows researchers to move beyond surface-level findings and explore the layers beneath.

Your beliefs about what is real and how we can know things shape which approach feels right to you. Those beliefs are what we call your paradigm, and understanding paradigms is the first step to making informed methodological choices.

Activity 1.1: Reflecting on the scenario

Timing: Allow approximately 10 minutes

Think about a research question that you are currently exploring, or one that you might investigate in the future.

  • How might a quantitative approach address this question? What would it reveal?
  • How might a qualitative approach address the same question? What different insights might it offer?
  • Can you imagine a situation where both approaches together would give you a more complete picture than either alone?

Make some notes in the space below. There is no model answer for this reflection; the purpose is to begin connecting these ideas to your own research context.

To use this interactive functionality a free OU account is required. Sign in or register.
Interactive feature not available in single page view (see it in standard view).

1.2 Selecting a research approach: your paradigm